Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Help with API650 - 3.11 - Wind load on tanks 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

pdosreis

Mechanical
Jul 12, 2006
5
Hi,
I'm calculating a storage tank, of D=13,5m and H=10,85m.
When calculating wind load on tanks (overturning stability), section 3.11, I've followed all the steps in this section and reached the conclusion of no need for anchorage, because M<2/3x(WxD/2).
Now, I really don't know (understand) what to do with 3.11.4 that refers to sliding due to wind, and gives me a "maximum allowable sliding friction of 0,40 multiplied by the force against the tank bottom".
What am I suppose to due with this factor, where do I apply it? How do I calculate if I need anchorage because of sliding? Can anyone help me?
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

Take the total weight of the tank, including the floor and structure, and multiply by 0.4 to find the sliding resistance. Compare to the total lateral wind force.

Addendum 4 to API-650 revises the wind loading considerably by adding a wind uplift requirement- you need to look into it if this tank is not specified to be built by Addendum 3.
 
Thanks! That really helped.
Can you just tell me if I should consider also 2/3.

Like this:
MaxOverturningMomentwithoutAnch.=2/3x((Wtank+Wfloor+Wroof)xD/2)
And then compare this to:
OverturningMomentfromWindPress.=Wind PressurexDxH/2

Did I understood it right?
 
Generally the floor would be considered for the sliding resistance, but not for the overturning. Or at least that's the way I would work it.

Your second formula would be M = pressure x D x H x H/2. But in the new Addendum 4, you have a term for uplift on the roof as well, and some additional equations to calculate uplift resistance.
 
Sorry, but maybe I didn't explained myself very well.
Forget the "Overturning" term I used, I'm only talking about sliding.
The overturning issue it's already taken care of, and I agree with you, I didn´t consider the floor when calculating overturning.
So:
MaxSlidingwithoutAnch.=2/3x((Wtank+Wfloor+Wroof)xD/2)

And then compare this to:

MomentfromWindPress.=Wind PressurexDxH/2

It's this what you were saying in your first answer?
 
If you're considering sliding, then it's not a moment. I don't think there's any requirement to use a 2/3 factor, for that matter.

You'd have maximum sliding force = (Wtank+Wfloor+Wroof) x 0.4

And compare to Wind Pressure x D X H
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor