My question is is it allowable to test two welders on one coupon, one would weld one side and one would weld the other side of the test coupon, if the test assembly is inclined 45 degrees to qualify all positions for each welder? The test would be on 18"OD x 0.500"WT X65 line pipe radiography and destructive testing.
Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!
Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!
-
Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!
API 1104 20th edition welder qualification
- Thread starter cjgrass
- Start date
cjgrass,
The 'brother in law' qualification could be performed provided the requisite number of coupons are destructively tested and pass. Your statment "one would weld one side and one would weld the other side of the test coupon" was meant to believe that each would weld one half of the circumference, not one half of the thickness, the latter not permitted.
While testing at 6G would qualify for butt welds and lap fillet welds in all positions, each welder would still be restricted by the many other essential variables for single qualification. I've seen this done many times in the past, and eventally the welder will make a weld for which their single qualification was not approproate, resulting in a cutout.
However, in addition to the above test, a branch test performed to API 1104 6.3.1 (each welder will need to make their own weld) will impart multiple qualification which will make them more valueable to you and your organization in the long run.
The 'brother in law' qualification could be performed provided the requisite number of coupons are destructively tested and pass. Your statment "one would weld one side and one would weld the other side of the test coupon" was meant to believe that each would weld one half of the circumference, not one half of the thickness, the latter not permitted.
While testing at 6G would qualify for butt welds and lap fillet welds in all positions, each welder would still be restricted by the many other essential variables for single qualification. I've seen this done many times in the past, and eventally the welder will make a weld for which their single qualification was not approproate, resulting in a cutout.
However, in addition to the above test, a branch test performed to API 1104 6.3.1 (each welder will need to make their own weld) will impart multiple qualification which will make them more valueable to you and your organization in the long run.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Question
- Question
