Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!

Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!

  • Congratulations JAE on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

60Hz designed Geno operating at 50Hz

Status
Not open for further replies.

asggsa

Electrical
Joined
Oct 10, 2006
Messages
2
Location
CL
Will receive offer for review data of a Generator constructed to operate at 60Hz, 3.600RPM, to be used at 3.000RPM in 50Hz Grid.
What do I have to consider may vary, besides cooling?
Waveform (Harmonics) may change, how much?
Shall it be rewound to counter this, changing auxiliary winding configuration?

May be more a problem than a faster delivery

 
The generator will put out less power.
The output voltage will need to be less and since a generator 'sets' the voltage as compared to a motor taking what is sent to it. The voltage control board will need to address this.

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.-
 
You can review this FAQ as it addresses your situation from a motor's point-of-view which is similar.

faq237-1224

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.-
 

Generator output and voltage will be reduced by 20%. As Keith said, AVR to be set for new reduced voltage. No need to change the stator or rotor windings.

If it has brushless exciter (with rotating rectifier), its ac output will have a lower frequency resulting a higher ripple content in the dc output of the rectifier. Whether your AVR can handle it is to be checked.

 
The majority of diesel gen sets manufactured in the world are suitable for either 50Hz. or 60Hz.
The frequency jumper on the Automatic Voltage Regulator must be moved to the 50Hz. position for proper operation of the Under Frequency Roll Off circuit.
You may want to adjust the overspeed protection circuit on the engine.
The unit will produce the same current and the same voltage, hence the same power. You may have a problem with the prime mover as more torque will be required to develop the same power at at the reduced speed.
Cooling is not an issue at 3000 RPM.
These comments are valid for the majority of diesel gensets manufactured in the range of about 5KW up to about 2MW with conventional voltage regulators. There may be exceptions for very small sets.
respectfully
 
I have to say waross I have seen perhaps 40 generators in my time and I have never seen one that was rated for both frequencies. If it is a 60Hz only and you try to run it at 50 you better reduce the voltage or it is a crap shoot as to whether it will be damaged or not.

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.-
 
thank you all.
Yes power has to be derated in ratio 50/60. Also Voltage has to be derated in same relation or otherwise excitation has to be raised in ratio 60/50 to keep original voltage.
But this would most probably go over limit of the winding rating. Flux will also increase and most probably waveform will suffer, as losses will increase.

 
Keith, I know that the CAT cut-sheets list ratings at both frequencies and yes, you get 6/5 as much out of the machine at 60Hz than you do at 50Hz. On the other hand, they rate the 50Hz machines in kVA and at a unity power factor since they are not engine limited at 50Hz the way they are at 60Hz. (At least that's the way I remember it; haven't looked at a cut-sheet for a while and never tried to apply one at 50Hz.)
 
Hi davidbeach; Admittedly I haven't seen very many >500kW units or at least not their name plates. Tiz all interesting information.

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.-
 
Hi Keith;
I agree, you won't find the ratings on the nameplate.
You have to look at the manufacturers technical info sheet for the set model.
When you order the set, it will be given nameplate with the single set of ratings that you have selected.
The ultimate KVA that a set will produce is determined by two basic factors;
The maximum current that the set may handle safely, and the maximum voltage, limited by insulation and saturation.
The maximum KW is limited by the capability of the prime mover.
The power factor is the ratio of KW/KVA. The prime mover is normally selected so that the power factor will be 80%.
There is normally a lower rating when a set is designated for use at 50HZ.
This is not because of the speed drop as with a motor, but because the normal 60HZ. rating will be at 480 volts, and the 50HZ. rating will be at 400 volts.
Coincidentally the voltage ratio, (480/400=1.2) is the same as the frequency ratio (60/50=1.2), and is the reason for the derating.
Voltage issues. An electric motor is excited by line voltage. An alternator of the size that I am discussing is excited by the exciter, controlled by the voltage regulator. These components have a wide range of adjustability.
These questions may be considered three ways.
1> The ultimate rating of an alternator.
Maximum allowable voltage times maximum allowable current equals KVA.

2> The rating of the alternator when applied to a standard system.
System voltage times maximum allowable current equals KVA.
The allowable rating will change in the ratio of the original or ultimate voltage to the application voltage.

3> The rating of a complete set with a prime mover.
The power of the prime mover determines the maximum KW. that the set may produce. If the torque curve is fairly straight over the range that the speed is changed (3600RPM/3000RPM, 1800RPM/1500RPM) the reduction in speed will result in a reduction in power (KW). This fits nicely with the normal drop in system voltages from the NEMA world to the IEC world.

I didn't mean to write this much, but as I am this far, please let me share with you an experience with generator ratings.
A customer (a movie theatre) had a fixed load and ordered a diesel generator for standby service.
His system was 120/208 volts. As I remember the load was 32 KVA. The supplier sold him a set rated at 32 KVA at 120/240 volts 4 wire delta. The rated current was 77amps. At the utilization voltage of 120/208, this resulted in a KVA rating of 27.7 KVA.
The set supplier was uncooperative and we had to reduce the load.
To make things more confusing, a diesel set manufacturer will rate the same alternator differently for standby service as compared to prime power service.
To compare ratings, look at the following sites;
Note, F G Wilson used to manufacture the Olympian Brand for Caterpilar. Several years ago, Caterpilar bought F G Wilson.
Caterpilar markets both Olympian (F G Wilson) and Marathon branded gensets.



On the Cat site, go to Latin America for dual 50/60 hz. ratings.

Cummins Power
and click on:
On-Site Power Generation Systems - Full Line PDF icon (1.8MB)
When the set is ordered, the governor, dead-rack adjustment, voltage, Under Frequency Roll Off, motor overspeed protection etc. will be set for the frequency and class of service, (Prime, Standby, or Continous) and the Nameplate will be supplied showing only one frequency.
I haven't mentioned widely variable temp. rise ratings and "Fudge" factors. Both common in set ratings.
Respectfully
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor

Back
Top