Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations Ron247 on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Search results for query: *

  1. Greenalleycat

    Cantilevered Beam on Wall

    Re Refer back to Celts model, he covered this Not wanting to be rude, but being blunt, if you are a chemical engineer then why are you designing this beam?
  2. Greenalleycat

    Cantilevered Beam on Wall

    This is what all of us have been saying in this thread The bearing point is known as it will sit on the LVL beams at the front The unknown is where the tension restraint is that resolves the cantilever moment further back As the designer, you can specify this: closer together = lower deflection...
  3. Greenalleycat

    Cantilevered Beam on Wall

    Reading your outputs (and forgive me for errors as I don't work in imperial) Moment = 9954 ft-lbs Shear = 15408 lbs or 20771 lbs 9954/15408 = 0.646ft = 7.75" 9954/20771 = 0.479ft = 5.75" So in neither case is it 5.25" - there's a mystery 0.5" being applied once correcting for your 2" dummy gap...
  4. Greenalleycat

    Cantilevered Beam on Wall

    Ah OK. We'd call those purlins supported by rafters typically, or maybe rafters supported on a roof beam depending on the exact roof framing setup Makes sense now and I understand your problem better. Looks like classic misuse of software: rubbish in, rubbish out Back calculating, your first...
  5. Greenalleycat

    Cantilevered Beam on Wall

    Thanks, that helped I think my point 1/ is relevant then - be careful with assuming that loads are equal on the backspan and the cantilever Otherwise you will underestimate the deflection and the hold down forces at the backspan Also, should there be a live load component to this? If you have...
  6. Greenalleycat

    Triangular CMU

    Here's a job I worked on with this case - they neatly cut the blocks and laid a steel layer in the top course Our walls are always fully filled/reinforced though so the detailing wasn't super critical On older buildings that are partially filled I've typically seen it like (a) in Pham's...
  7. Greenalleycat

    Cantilevered Beam on Wall

    I'm struggling to interpret what is going on here as the diagram sucks and I'm not familiar with the analysis software Where are the connections to the top plate defined to resolve the cantilever loads? So, some general thoughts 1/ It looks like you've applied 2 loads on the backspan and 1 on...
  8. Greenalleycat

    Casting New Slab in Existing Building

    The loads are strange, 3.5kPa seems low for a dancing/party area - it's 5kPa in our code
  9. Greenalleycat

    Lateral earth pressure at rest for a standing cliff

    Looking at that picture it is one hell of a site I feel that designing to a soil bearing pressure is almost an academic exercise only: if that cliff decides to go, your house is going with it Your retaining wall at the back is basically just doing its bit to protect the exposed face from...
  10. Greenalleycat

    Crazy cantilevered steel deck

    It's no utopia and there are certainly plenty of people willing to undercut! However, the seismic design requirements adds a lot to our engineering requirements so our fees are higher generally
  11. Greenalleycat

    Staggered Stud Wall LTB

    Ron, higher S1 = bad (number = how slender it is, higher = more slender) I suppose I left out the useful context of the normal equation - basically, reverting to 3*d/b is hugely favourable over how the same beam would calculate out if it didn't have tension edge restraint
  12. Greenalleycat

    Unistrut in Torsion

    I don't really understand the geometry of this thing in all honesty so not sure if what I said applies But the P2542 will be torsionally flexible AF so this thing is either a) unstable or b) resolves elsewhere Depending on how your pipes are connected, they may actually have moment capacity in...
  13. Greenalleycat

    Staggered Stud Wall LTB

    Our code allows tension face restraint to count (compression side would obviously be even better) I've always interpreted 'continuously restrained' to allow sheathing with discrete fasteners at 150-300mm crs max in the context of residential framing
  14. Greenalleycat

    Unistrut in Torsion

    How is the eccentricity arising? Can you resolve the torsion as a major axis moment into the tube instead?
  15. Greenalleycat

    Crazy cantilevered steel deck

    Ha more power to him if he pulls that off Here, you would have invalidated your contract by doing that and the client would then have the opportunity to say "get stuffed" if they're smart enough to realise you're taking the piss
  16. Greenalleycat

    Crazy cantilevered steel deck

    Yes it's Goods and Servies Tax. It's a flat 15% tax applied to basically every single thing - we don't have the double down of state and federal taxes, nor are there variations between items: it's 15% on everything It's the consultant in me to state +GST on all fees - you only want to forget to...
  17. Greenalleycat

    Unistrut in Torsion

    What's the context? In my case we were hanging a few panel heaters off 2 rows of unistrut I got them to stick a vertical member in between the two rows and then hang the panel heater off that which they preferred anyway for maximum flexibility/tolerance on site There is some potential residual...
  18. Greenalleycat

    Crazy cantilevered steel deck

    Obviously this is going to be hugely dependent on the job but here is a ballpark: - Say 500+GST per inspection on average (travel time, mileage, inspection time, memo time, maybe a phone call or two) - If we are doing a full house then there will be an excavation inspection (subgrade - by us or...
  19. Greenalleycat

    Steel Cranked Beam End Supports

    Can't you just drop the beam down to the plane of the ceiling joists anyway?
  20. Greenalleycat

    Unistrut in Torsion

    Funnily enough I was dealing with exactly this situation recently - P1000T in torsion It's an open section, they're rubbish I decided to do as much as I could to avoid the torsion, as canwesteng said

Part and Inventory Search