I have a pattern of 4 holes, which in turn exists in 4 places of a frame. Engineer wants to give it a location tolerance of 4mm in X axis, 2mm in Y axis, and wants to tie each of the 4 holes to each other with a tolerance of 0.6mm. I came up with top option, which in my opinion is better, but...
Please see the attached file. I'm making a print with gd&t that supposed to be based on older drawing (3 top views). In my opinion though the bottom view shows the way it should be dimensioned correctly (gdt frame placement). Would you agree with me, or would you say that top views are...