Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by tmoe

  1. tmoe

    Repair Options for Buckling Wide Flange.

    phamENG - Welcome to Tahoe, CA! Client was not happy when we previously told him he needs to be removing cornices like this at least once a season to prevent damage or injury/death. these are particularly large due to the heavy winter we got this year, but either way, some due diligence is...
  2. tmoe

    Repair Options for Buckling Wide Flange.

    @Rabbit12 - yes the large eave snow load is being removed and the beam temporarily shored. @jayrod12 - yeah I suppose the tapper could remain. no sense making things more difficult. @KootK - The column connection detail does have stiffeners but the WT section left over as a result of cutting...
  3. tmoe

    Repair Options for Buckling Wide Flange.

    @canwesteng - yeah that my initial thought, but the web is tapered from the end back to roughly the buckling locations. Perhaps cutting out the tapered portion of the web and replacing that with a full depth plate at the same time as the new bottom flange plate.
  4. tmoe

    Repair Options for Buckling Wide Flange.

    See attached photo for reference. Basically, this W10x12 outrigger had its bottom flange removed for aesthetic purposes without coordination of the structural team. While the original beam was well designed for conservative eave snow loads, particularly heavy cornices have developed at the...
  5. tmoe

    How to discuss a nightmare client without slandering them.

    I have my first official client from hell. No need to go into details of it, but this simple $5k seismic retrofit project has been drug out by the client for months. She is EXTREMELY hard to work with, requesting multiple (unnecessary) changes, extremely late on payments, refusal to pay for...
  6. tmoe

    Moment Frames In Combinations with Shear Walls. Large Brace forces.

    Yes, Im in agree with your interpretation, but where exactly are the detailing requirements for a Special or Ordinary Cantilevered Column system?? ASCE7 Table 12.2-1 kicks me to Section 14.1 which then kicks me to AISC 341, but I cant seem to find anything there. Am I overlooking it or in the...
  7. tmoe

    Moment Frames In Combinations with Shear Walls. Large Brace forces.

    jdgengineer, that is a great reference, thanks for the info. We use A$ in this office as we typically don't know (or don't get) 2nd floor wall layouts required for the FEMA analysis. What the the deal with the wording in section A6.3 regarding a cantilevered column system meeting the detailing...
  8. tmoe

    Moment Frames In Combinations with Shear Walls. Large Brace forces.

    RMassoudi, thanks for the reply. That seems like a potential solution, I will have to give some thought to how to account for different types of sheathing above and below the joists (existing board sheathing above, new ply below). SF is pretty strict on what you can use for allowable values (if...
  9. tmoe

    Moment Frames In Combinations with Shear Walls. Large Brace forces.

    I live in SF CA and I'm currently involved in a number of seismic retrofit jobs. These jobs are all wood framed residential units 3 to 4 stories over mostly open garage spaces. Basically your classic soft story type structure. Almost all of them are rectangular in shape aprox 25'X75' Often these...
  10. tmoe

    wood shear walls using wood siding

    I have a residential seismic retrofit where the board sheathing is covered with asbestos paper and then topped with galv. metal sheeting. Does anyone know if new plywood can be installed over the board sheathing and if so, what kinds of values we get??
  11. tmoe

    Modulus of compound beam member

    Great input everyone, it has really helped to clear things up for me. Ultimately Im creating a spread spreadsheet for work, that will run this scenario. I live in San Francisco and see a lot of remodels and additions to the old Victorian structures. We are often sistering members onto...
  12. tmoe

    Modulus of compound beam member

    BA, What type of connection would allow the members to behave as a true composite section rather than individually? You mentioned nailing would not. Why? thanks
  13. tmoe

    Modulus of compound beam member

    Thanks all, appreciated.
  14. tmoe

    Modulus of compound beam member

    Thanks Mike, that reduces down to exactly the ratio I was looking for.

Part and Inventory Search