Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by Schambach

  1. Schambach

    Grade of anchor bolts

    The reason I've taken a liking to the plate washer idea is because of the use of the Simpson Anchor Designer program which employs those. I am NOT in a high seismic zone so I don't see ductility as a huge deal.
  2. Schambach

    Grade of anchor bolts

    Thanks. I used the wrong terminology. I meant to say threaded rod. I'm using plate washers and nuts for the "head."
  3. Schambach

    Grade of anchor bolts

    When specifying anchor bolts to attach steel columns to concrete, everything I read suggests specifying ASTM F1554. I have specified Gr36 and my supplier says that it is much easier and cheaper to get ASTM A193 B7 bolts. Those I read are not as ductile and are stronger. What would preclude me...
  4. Schambach

    ASCE 7 minimum wind speeds on vertical projection

    Thanks phamENG. That makes sense........kind of. I hadn't considered a downdraft acting on a building and exerting a positive pressure on the windward side of the roof, unlike that which is tested in a wind tunnel. I like your Cessna example.........I get it. Couldn't one argue though that...
  5. Schambach

    ASCE 7 minimum wind speeds on vertical projection

    Quick correction. Engineers I know choose to disregard the ROOF vertical projection and only use the wall vertical projects in determining their total shear forces. Is that acceptable is my question?
  6. Schambach

    ASCE 7 minimum wind speeds on vertical projection

    The pre-2010 ASCE 7 used a minimum wind pressures of 10psf on the vertical projection of the entire building and then in 2010 and thereafter the minimum pressures are 16psf on walls and 8psf on the roof. This thread is not about ASD vs LRFD, I found posts on that, this question is about the...
  7. Schambach

    Visual Analysis software users out there that are good with plate modeling?

    I use the VA software for frame analysis and I get along pretty good. When it comes to modeling plates I struggle a bit. I'm curious if there are any users out there that would be willing and open to having dialogue and answering questions off-line and ideally be able to learn from each other...
  8. Schambach

    Is it possible to limit the extent to which an engineers stamp applies on a set of permit drawings?

    Great discussion folks! Thanks for answering my question and then some. It has been very helpful!!
  9. Schambach

    Is it possible to limit the extent to which an engineers stamp applies on a set of permit drawings?

    Excellent! Thanks. I appreciate that perspective. Have others done the same? I'd like to know how prevalent this is and whether or not it has been successfully used where the IRC or IBC controls. Ultimately, do we as engineers have a legal leg to stand on or could actions such as these be...
  10. Schambach

    Is it possible to limit the extent to which an engineers stamp applies on a set of permit drawings?

    To expand upon the subject line, does a note like "I have designed this project according to ASCE 7-10 specifications?" immediately above or below my signed seal limit my liability as to what I am "certifying" by stamping those plans? Does anybody use clarifying notes to limit exposure when...
  11. Schambach

    Electronic testing equipment

    I am wanting to get some test equipment to do some small-scale testing for various structural connections and assemblies that I've dreamed up. I am not wanting to become a certified testing laboratory, but I'd like to get my hands on some decent equipment. I'm basically looking for a data...
  12. Schambach

    Finish floor elevation??

    Thanks all! Anybody see much 0'-0" out there or do you feel the majority of drawings (if not using NAVD) are 100'-0"? Appreciate the help!
  13. Schambach

    Finish floor elevation??

    Thanks JedClampett. I work in an industry where we don't know what the local datum elevation is and for ease of construction (single or double story wood structures) we have typically called finish floor 100'-0" so that when defining an elevation below finish floor we don't have to go to...

Part and Inventory Search