Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by recs

  1. recs

    GF Protection on LV 3-Wire Unbalanced Systems

    If a 3-phase, 3-Wire (no Phase to neutral loads), Y-G, 480V system has several phase-to-phase loads unbalancing the system. I would like to provide GF protection at the service disconnect and a second level at the feeder. All 600 A frame breakers I have seen (Eaton, GE, and Square D) have GF...
  2. recs

    Short-Circuit Withstand Rating for Motors

    According to NEMA MG 1-2011 section 32.13, generators can withstand a maximum short-circuit current equal to the three phase fault current at its terminals for at least 30 seconds (unless otherwise specified by the manufacturer) when operated at rated kVA and power factor and with a maximum of...
  3. recs

    CT SIZING FOR PRIMARY PROTECTION RELAY

    Lets assume that we have a 10,000 kVA 138 kV to 12.47 kV transformer with a primary FLA of 41.8 A. The short-circuit available at the secondary side of the transformer is 5.76 kA which referred to the primary side is 520 A. Assuming this CT feeds a typical electromechanical 50/51 relay (CO...
  4. recs

    Electric (not electronic) circuit simulation

    Does anybody knows of a software that can draw and calculate steady state single phase electrical circuits? I have SKM but is not what I want. SKM is an excellent program but it can't draw the single phase schematic diagrams, including phase, neutral, and equipment grounding conductors and then...
  5. recs

    Standard Sizes for MV or HV Circuit Breakers

    The NEC allows for transformer protection to go to the next standard size. It is very clear how to apply this rule for low voltage circuit breakers. But what are defined the medium voltage or high voltage breaker standard sizes?
  6. recs

    Contradiction is Scope for Part 32 in NEMA MG 1-2011

    In standard MEMA MG 1-2011 Section IV Part 32 the title shows the following: "Synchronous Generators (Exclusive of Generators Cover By ANSI Standards C50.12, C50.13, C50.14, and C50.15 Above 5000 kVARatings". Then in the scope section establishes that this part 32 covers synchronous generators...
  7. recs

    IEEE Std. C37.102-2006 Voltage Restrained Relay for Short, Short-Circuit Time Constant

    I am confused how this answer justifies a voltage-restrained relay better than a voltage-controlled relay?
  8. recs

    IEEE Std. C37.102-2006 Voltage Restrained Relay for Short, Short-Circuit Time Constant

    Thank you for your responses. But I might not have clear on the purpose of my question. I understand and agree with all what you wrote. But the questions is: Why the IEEE determines that a Voltage-Restrained relay (not a Voltage-Controlled Relay) is advisable when the time constant of the...
  9. recs

    IEEE Std. C37.102-2006 Voltage Restrained Relay for Short, Short-Circuit Time Constant

    In IEEE Std. C37.102-2006 related with generator protection, it is recommended to use voltage-restrained back-up protection when the following condition is present (Section 4.6.1.2 Overcurrent Type Backup, page 77): Short, short-circuit time constant. The actual wording is: "On units that have...
  10. recs

    Comparison of UL 1066 and ANSI C37.13

    UL 1066 and ANSI C37.13 are recognize standards for Low Voltage Power Circuit Breakers (LVPCB). Are these standards equivalent, in other works, did ANSI or UL adopted one of these standards from the other organization? If different, what are the main differences? Thanks.
  11. recs

    Lightning protection of steel water tank

    I would not use an ESE device to provide proper lightning protection. As told, in spite of a ferocious war waged by specialized lightning air terminals suppliers, NFPA and IEEE did not find any credible evidence that they work, on the contrary. But they have an excellent marketing machine...
  12. recs

    LV Transformer arc flash labeling

    I only affix one worst case label to a transformer. I model the transformer with a bus at the primary and a bus at the secondary (i.e. TR-1-P and TR-1-S). I then run the arc flash and these two locations will be together and easy to compare which is the worst case. When I print the labels I...
  13. recs

    Which short-circuit current to use when checking coordination time intervals (CTI)

    I want to correct an error with the previous statement. When the relay curves tend to converge in a lower value of time as current values increases, you may have that the momentary duty results in a lower CTI than the CTI obtained by the lower interrupting duty.
  14. recs

    Which short-circuit current to use when checking coordination time intervals (CTI)

    I agree that the momentary asymmetrical duty (RMS or Crest depending of the rating of the CB's) should the one to use because is higher than the interrupting duties (Symmetrical or Asymmetrical depending on the CB's). But if you have two relay TCC's growing apart from each other as current...
  15. recs

    Which short-circuit current to use when checking coordination time intervals (CTI)

    When performing a coordination study on a MV system, we can use many types of short-circuit currents in the TCC curves. If we use the ANSI C37 standard for calculation, we have many types of short-circuits to show in the TCC. Some of these are: 1. Momentary: Calculated using the first-cycle...

Part and Inventory Search