@Denial: thank you for your hint, I didn't notice it, by the way results hold the same.
@IDS: your model give me the same results as mine actually.
Are you confident with Ansys? If so, how can I use LINK180 for nonlinear analysis as a compression only element?
Because I define the real costant...
Thank you for your help and your suggestion for Strand7 output display.
By the way I also modeled the problem with Strand7 using node stiffness and beam support, results are very close. I was now focusing on the spring model in order to compare it with Ansys analysis.
Actually I guess the...
Looks like I coudn't upload more than one file.
The one in the previous post was the STRAND 7 model.
This one is the ANSYS input. Note: "NUMERO PILASTRI" means "COLUMNS NUMBER".http://files.engineering.com/getfile.aspx?folder=2de24210-4766-4351-8707-431c0a3ac4d1&file=travi_rovesce_serie.txt
Thank you all, I'm sorry I'm new to the forum now I get what you meant by "upload the models".
@IDS: I get the same values, now I should have posted the models so you can check everything.
@Denial: I started to solve a 4000m beam because I have the "hand calculated" solution for that, which...
Ok then here I have a few screenshots.
Problem data:
Beam section: 200*200 mm2 (square)
Elastic modulus: 10000 MPa (Poisson ratio=0)
Length between vertical forces: 4000 mm
Nodal forces: -12000 N
Spring axial stiffness: 1000 N/mm
ONE nodal force - Strand 7 results:
ONE nodal force - ANSYS...
Hi everyone!
I'm trying to model a continuous footing foundation: Winkler springs bed under a continuous slab with one or more loaded nodes (corresponding to the columnus).
The problem is that I modeled it with two different softwares (Strand7 and Ansys) and I obtained two different results...