Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

greenimi's latest activity

  • greenimi
    greenimi replied to the thread Datum callout question.
    I am okay with both schemes shown in my replay above (green scheme and dark red scheme). I only have hard time to explain to people what...
  • greenimi
    greenimi replied to the thread Datum callout question.
    Burunduk, What are you showing on your latest replay looks okay for me. What does not look "very clean" is this MMC......RMB or...
    • AB - Copy.jpg
  • greenimi
    greenimi replied to the thread Datum callout question.
    I agree with the INCORRECT training. And I think I had that, hence my confusion.
  • greenimi
    greenimi replied to the thread Datum callout question.
    Sorry I was not trying to be facetious. I am just trying to "provoke" people to give me more arguments (on both sides of the issue) that...
  • greenimi
    greenimi replied to the thread Datum callout question.
    Well, I guess that is exactly the purpose of this forum. To find arguments and provide potential solutions. (If you don't want to...
  • greenimi
    greenimi replied to the thread Datum callout question.
    Just to make sure you understood me. I am talking about MMB versus RMB for the 8mm hole. I am not talking about MMC for the 8mm hole...
  • greenimi
    greenimi replied to the thread Datum callout question.
    Yes, I was assuming (rightfully or not) that if position of the 2X features is RFS, THEN the location of the Ø8mm hole is also RMB...
  • greenimi
    greenimi replied to the thread Datum callout question.
    Ok. I understood. Or I guess....I understood. The question was: are there two features (and consequently two simulators, one of each...
  • greenimi
    greenimi replied to the thread Datum callout question.
    It's a pattern at RFS so I am asking how that works?
  • greenimi
    greenimi replied to the thread Datum callout question.
    pmarc, Is it true that figure 10-58 in Burunduk's laytest replay will have an interpretation problem IF the callout is RFS? Otherwise...
  • greenimi
    Per 8.4.4 (ASME y14.5-2018): Cylindricity may be applied on a unit basis as a means of limiting an abrupt surface variation within a...
  • greenimi
    If you can tell us how this part works, what is the design intent mabe we can find a solution together to convert your shown...
  • greenimi
    greenimi replied to the thread Can I omit Basic dimensions?.
    How accurate is the measurement from 3DPDF? Otherwise I am asking if you measure a basic dimension from the native CAD and the sameone...
  • greenimi
    greenimi replied to the thread Can I omit Basic dimensions?.
    Question for the people with MBD knowledge: Can you “measure” basic dimensions from the 3D PDF? I know the 3D PDF format can be very...
  • greenimi
    greenimi replied to the thread Can I omit Basic dimensions?.
    Yes, only if those parties can use it (the STEP242) at its full capacity. I found how that the vasty majority of OUR supplier do not...

Part and Inventory Search