Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by BantrelStructural

  1. BantrelStructural

    Pre-tensioned Anchor Rods - A Few Questions

    I am looking for some back up literature on pre-tensioned anchor rods to fill in a few gaps in the information that I have been able to find todate: 1. I have seen recommendations in the past not to pre-tension rods with yield strength below 60-70 Ksi. I basically understand that there are...
  2. BantrelStructural

    ASCE 7 - Impact Loading for Bulkheads

    Oops, one mistake in my post when I said K factor for seismic, I meant R factor. Glad I was able to help. Your response was the only positive in a bad day where I got sideswiped by the cancellation of a $2.5 billion (going onto $8.5 billion - which kind of explains the cancellation) project.
  3. BantrelStructural

    ASCE 7 - Impact Loading for Bulkheads

    The commentary in ASCE 7-98 helps a little (see p. 241-242). It indicates that rigid structures of concrete or steel may reduce the velocity to zero time interval to 0.1 - 0.5 sec. But even at t = 0.1 second your distance to zero is 1.25 ft., which could still translate into a large force on...
  4. BantrelStructural

    Anchor Bolt Head Plates

    Wondering if anyone has a simple technique for determining the required thickness of a head plate on an anchor bolt embedded in concrete. I'm not looking for a conservative method that gives me a safe solution, but rather looking for a way to assess a reliable capacity for an existing bolt...
  5. BantrelStructural

    Foundation Design for Large Lateral Load

    I don't think that you get very large capacities out of Chance anchors (10-20 kips I believe). So assuming that you could install them at a 45 degree angle you would need 20 to 40 anchors. With group effects spacing requirements you would need a large area, and a big cap to ties these together...
  6. BantrelStructural

    Foundation Design for Large Lateral Load

    Typical working loads at 1/5th. of the wire rope capacity is similar to lifting lugs which are designed for 5 times the specified lifting capacity to account for multiple handling and abuse such as impact damage from being dropped small distances. But since docking ships is not done under a...
  7. BantrelStructural

    Foundation Design for Large Lateral Load

    With liability concerns, the presumably third party designer of the foundation, would not design his foundation for anything less than the capacity of the anchorage.
  8. BantrelStructural

    Design by rule of thumb

    Sometimes it seems that if there are two ways to approach a problem, that with some clients it pays to do it the wrong way first, because regardless they'll want to see the other way too, and so you only have to change it once. This applied more to the days of manual draughting where it wasn't...
  9. BantrelStructural

    Foundation Design for Large Lateral Load

    A 300 kip lateral load (even assuming it is 100% horizontal with no additional vertical uplift component) will require a very massive AND deep foundation. Using a combination of passive pressure, base rocking and base friction and ignoring several limiting factors (such as the suitability of...
  10. BantrelStructural

    Blast resistant structure

    One key thing to remember is that internal explosion and external blasts present different loading criteria. Internal blast generally requires relief (blow-out panels) or reflected pressures significantly increase the overall blast load on the structure. Factory Mutual has information for...
  11. BantrelStructural

    How often do your calculations get checked ?

    I currently work for a major EPC consultant in the oil & gas industry. We are ISO 9001 registered, and have committed to checking all calcs. This is actually too much. Some stuff needs checking, maybe even more than once, other items could probably go with no checks. In my earlier commercial...
  12. BantrelStructural

    Rigid Frame Foundations

    On some very large industrial rigid frame structures that I have seen (high eave heights, and heavy crane loads), and where floor trenches/pits are a factor or could very likely be in the future, a foundation with a pair (or more) of piles in line with the frame/truss span have been used. These...
  13. BantrelStructural

    Out of plumb column

    It would actually depend on whether the lateral load restraint system was a moment frame, (particularly if this column was a participating element), or some other system like shear walls or bracing. If for example the column was part of a line of columns that were braced, and ignoring beam...
  14. BantrelStructural

    Precast Drawing Liability

    In theory as the engineer of record the structural consultant is on the hook for everything structural. With the usual fee structure and insane schedules it is almost a virtual impossibility to actually achieve full control of everything, requiring that we rely on other structural engineers to...
  15. BantrelStructural

    NC State Frost Depth

    Frost penetration and jacking/heaving is also a function of soil type, so (assuming that you have a geotechnical engineer on the project) he may be able to give you some site specific guidance.

Part and Inventory Search