PC vs Workstation
PC vs Workstation
(OP)
I'm trying to convince management to purchase new computers. In the past we were using VersaCad and AutoCad and regular PC's were fine. I need some info to show management the difference between a PC and a Workstation. Any takers?
Thanks,
DT
Thanks,
DT






RE: PC vs Workstation
FAQ559-974
http://www.scottjbaugh.com/Tips_Tricks/Hardware%20Recommendations.htm
FYI - Workstation RAM from Dell is sooooo expensive that I bought a 2nd computer (PC) for the cost of the RAM. And the Computer out performs the Workstation (Dell Precision 220). Plus I have more RAM than my Workstation does. My workstation is my backup computer and it's good backup. But that's all it is now. My PC rocks! It's fast and reliable when it comes to SW. When the Workstation is new it will run and perform great... but when it becomes outdated. The question is... are you willing to pay the price for upgrades to keep that computer running top notch?
A single 512 stick of RAM cost around $3-400 (at the time). I needed 2 sticks. I tried lokoing for third party but I couldn't get below $300 apiece.
Are you willing to pay then I would say go with a workstation. You won't regret it in the beginning I know that much.
Regards,
Scott Baugh, CSWP

http://www.3dvisiontech.com
http://www.scottjbaugh.com
FAQ731-376
RE: PC vs Workstation
Engineering Technician
Fisher Research Laboratory
RE: PC vs Workstation
When I was looking a year ago I coulnd't find it anywhere for less than $300+. I looked at www.buy.com, www.pricewatch.com, www.tigerdirect.com, www.kingston.com... I didn't matter. I looked every I could think of and places I didn't know about and couldn't find it any cheaper.
Regards,
Scott Baugh, CSWP

http://www.3dvisiontech.com
http://www.scottjbaugh.com
FAQ731-376
RE: PC vs Workstation
Engineering Technician
Fisher Research Laboratory
RE: PC vs Workstation
I have had one WS class machines (dual processors, RAID 0 hard disk array, professional graphics) which I used for six years...the only changes were graphics card and memory as the prices dropped on these items (and new OS, but thats for IT department reasons.) That dual P900 Xeon still runs rings around the P2.4's they bought last year (1MB L2 not 256kB, 2x 10,000rpm UW3 SCSI in Raid 0 disk not 7,200 rpm ATA.)
Spend 2000 every year for six years keeping your PC at top performance, or spent 6000 once in the same timeframe and maybe another 1000 after 5 years to boost it...thats how management needs to see it...its NOT a PC, its a WS.
RE: PC vs Workstation
Oh yeah, while it is a known fact that SolidWorks will NOT benefit from multiple processors (its basic coding doesn't allow multiple processors), I HIGHLY recommend dual processors if you think for a second that you'll be running any other types of intensive packages (say your company maintains AutoCAD files as well and you have to have both CAD packages open at once...) or if you'll have several other programs running at once. The hyperthreaded Xeons keep SolidWorks clocking along happily while AutoCAD is running with several other packages in the background, and each of the 4 virtual hyperthreaded processors is pegging along at only about 60% usage. One day I turned just the hyperthreading off, and this machine came to a crawl. I shudder to think what performance would be on one processor with everything running.
Just my thoughts...
RE: PC vs Workstation
RE: PC vs Workstation
Regards,
Scott Baugh, CSWP

http://www.3dvisiontech.com
http://www.scottjbaugh.com
FAQ731-376
RE: PC vs Workstation
In my case, hyperthreading is a benefit not because SW runs faster, but simply because it gives my other applications more virtual processors to work with. Even though SW does run slower than it could, given my other processes and their clamoring for CPU time, the net result is a faster machine than if the OS thought it only had two processors. Things to think about when you're building up your machine.
RE: PC vs Workstation
FAQ559-986
Ray Reynolds
"Computers in the future may weigh no more than 1.5 tons."
Popular Mechanics, forecasting the relentless march of science, 1949
Have you read FAQ731-376 to make the best use of Eng-Tips Forums?