×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Reinforcement of flat heads

Reinforcement of flat heads

Reinforcement of flat heads

(OP)
I am looking for a method for analyzing a flat head design with welded, radial stiffeners.  UG-47 does not seem to apply.  Thanks for any help.

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

Chapter 7.7 of "Chemical and Process Equipment Design" by Azbel & Cheremisinoff has a method where the head takes half the load & the ribs take half the load.

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

Rib stiffened flat heads are not allowed by Div.1.
Also radial stiffeners are not necessarily the best choice, as the center portion, with highest stresses, will require the ribs to be heavily welded together.
The italian code for pressure vessels has a method for that.
First check is that the thickness of the flat wall satisfies the rules for unreinforced flat heads with a diameter equal to the largest circle that may be inscribed between the ribs, and, using the method of UG-34, with C=0.2.
Then one has to calculate the ribs, but the detailed method is too complex to be repeated here.
However you can simply calculate the ribs with the participation of the flat wall as an equivalent T beam, by taking the following limits (t is wall thickness):
-width of participating flat wall not higher than 20t (and of course you can't account the same material for separate ribs, this holds for the central portion of your radial ribs)
-height of ribs between 5 and 15 times their thickness
-rib thickness between 0.75t and 1.5t

prex

http://www.xcalcs.com
Online tools for structural design

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

prex

Not sure I agree with you about rib stiffening not being permitted by Div.1.  See U-1(a)(3). Do you have a reference?

I do agree it is hard to prove and there may be better choices.

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

UG-34 and UG-39 govern the design of flat heads.  I would think it would be more economically feasible from a material and welding perspective to just make the head thick enough to take the loading rather than add reinforcement to a thinner flat head.

Brian

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

prex,
I think deanc is right.  ASME VIII does not prohibit rib stiffened flat heads... it just doesn't give the rules for it.

Steve Braune
Tank Industry Consultants
www.tankindustry.com

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

SteveBraune (Structural) & deanc (Specifier/Regul)

You need to go back to the erly 1940 I have seen calculation set in the State of Ohio

Leonard@thill.biz
www.thill.biz

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

When you want to keep the t down, there is no choice. ribs act as stays and can cut t in half, not even radially but crosssectional as well. radially are most difficult to calc.
look in sec VIII-1 vessels of rectangular configurations, calcs for stiffeners on the flat surface.
ER      

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

Waskilly,

Sometimes that thickness increase you are suggesting might be for an expensive material, while ribbing can be plain old (formerly) cheap carbon steel.

we used to do flat side side and flat head designs for evaporator equipment made of CU/NI material, and it was obviously much more cost effective to make the CU/NI thickness minimal, and pour on the ribbing.

Secondly, now-a-days, some head and covers are limited in maximum weight by specifications so that they can be lifted by a single person without the aid of lifting devices, in which case, ribbing would produce a lighter piece than thickening.

rmw

rmw

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

If thickness and Ribbing proves difficult on can think of Doming the head, some thing like floating head of Exchanger. This would reduce the thickness (As compared to flat head) and unnecessary complicated calc could be avoided.

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

For a rib stiffened flat head, you need to look to U2g, which states basically that for configurations for which the code design rules (i.e. the thickness sizing formulas in the code) do not specifically apply, do something just as safe as other code construction.  Perhaps you may find a suitable hand calculation procedure; if not, FEA is an appropriate evaluation method.  This is typically done using the Div 1 allowable stresses, but the evaluation methodology of Section VIII, Div 2, Appendix 4.

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

You can check on the calculations use to analyze FT power boiler tubesheets w/ welded diagonal stays.  I do not believe that calculations can be significantly different.

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

FT staying calcs. will not work on bar stiffeners.as stays.
the area of staying will be part of the stiffeners calcs.,
the needis the same.
I am looking into the calculations myself and it is not easy. I will keep looking.
ER

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

Two parts must be calculated. first the stiffener itself and if stiffener is right then plate.
Stiffeners for crossectional areas as previously stated by prex are in Italian Codes RACCOLTA VSR and VSG for vessels and boilers respectively.
Plate between stiffeners are also in these codes but in others too because in its crossectional versión is a tipicaly boiler used construcction. Out of my head is UNE 9300, new EN (12935?)for pirotubular Boilers, TRD perhaps.
It's based in calculate thicknes with the major circle diameter with three supporting points, a factor for other auxiliar circles of 0,75D with two supporting points which center are off the main circle (thats forms a oval area)and another factor for the stiffening method. Rectangular areas must be also considered with a factor for the rectangular form.

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

During one of my interactions with ASME code committee, I was informed that ASME Section VIII div 1 permits the use of stiffeners in the design of flat circular heads, bolted covers or flanges. The requirements of U-2g are to be satisfied.

V.Dwaraka Krishna.

RE: Reinforcement of flat heads

Stiffened heads do not function very well due to unequal deflection. The sealing is a headache, so be warned in advance to stiffeners very liberally and check the differential deflection.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources