×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Radiator Sizing?
2

Radiator Sizing?

Radiator Sizing?

(OP)
I am aware that this is a very broad question, but was wondering if there is an approximate method to evaluating a needed radiator size?  For example, lets take a 200hp, turbocharged engine, 1.8L, 4cyl motor.  I know there are lots of variables in this problem such as the coolant flow rate, air speed, radiator heat transfer coefficient, etc, and detailed analysis would be needed to properly size the radiator.  I am looking basically for a worst case scenario.  First of all what would be a good assumption for how much heat is dissipated to the coolant from the IC engine.  As I read, that would be about 1/3 of total power, which assuming 1/4 only goes down to the groud, that would mean almost 200kW gets transfered to the coolant.  Now, at steady state, are radiators sized to cope with this condition or some precentage of that?  To start would two flow conditions be sufficient, for example at idle, and at max power output, in order to size the radiator?  What is a typical heat transfer coefficient, U for an automotive radiator of average size 3.0L?  I found it very dificlut to find any information, data, U, effectiveness, etc on automotive radiators, if anybody can provide me with a good source, website, book for this type of data that would be great.  Thanks for reading.

 Best Regards,

   Cymeryss

RE: Radiator Sizing?

You really don't have to reinvent/redesign the wheel.  Water cooled cars with radiators have been in existance for over 100 years.  Just go and look at a similar sized car with a similar sized engine. (engineers have all ready solved the problem for you)  What size radiator is in there?  There's your answer.

Chumley

RE: Radiator Sizing?

2
For a high output n/a 3.0L V6, here's a heat balance (based on dyno data). As you can see, heat to coolant is  nearer 1/4 of ouput power. Radiators are normally sized to achieve steady state cooling at maximum torque, but this is not very realistic unless you are towing.
I don't have any info on heat transfer of radiators I'm afraid.

Andy


Engine Heat to    Exhaust    Coolant Oil Brake  Other
Speed   Fuel
7080    100%    See Other    7%    2%    27%    64%
7019    100%    See Other    7%    2%    27%    63%
6959    100%    See Other    8%    4%    27%    61%
6707    100%    See Other    8%    4%    27%    61%
6457    100%    See Other    8%    4%    28%    60%
6205    100%    See Other    8%    4%    28%    60%
5955    100%    See Other    9%    4%    29%    59%
5454    100%    See Other    9%    4%    29%    57%
4951    100%    See Other    8%    3%    30%    58%
4649    100%    See Other    9%    4%    30%    58%
4600    100%    See Other    9%    4%    30%    57%
4550    100%    See Other    9%    3%    30%    57%
4450    100%    See Other    9%    3%    29%    59%
3949    100%    See Other    9%    4%    28%    59%
3450    100%    See Other    10%    4%    31%    55%
2949    100%    See Other    10%    4%    30%    56%
2444    100%    See Other    12%    4%    32%    51%

RE: Radiator Sizing?

Andyv8's post is relevant and I gave it a star.  The reason I thought it was relevant was that it gave real numbers for the proportion of the energy going into the coolant, which I thought was probably a handy number if you are designing a radiator.

Cheers

Greg Locock

RE: Radiator Sizing?

Just out of curiosity. . . . . .

has anyone done any work figuring out how over designing the coolant system decreases fuel efficiency? For example -- If you design the radiator surface area for the absolute highest thermal load (towing a trailer up a hill at 85 mph) the radiator cross sectional area will cost fuel efficiency at lower loads where that much area is not needed.

The same thing could be said about the water pump; designed to pump the amount of coolant necessary for cooling at maximal loads, resulting in excess power being used to generate a coolant flow that's too high most of the time.

The only area that I can see this being addressed is in the design of cooling fans and clutches.

RE: Radiator Sizing?

SBBlue

Davies Craig make a plastic, electrically driven water pump with a microprocessor controlled electric motor that senses water temperature, and increases pump speed according to temperature.

The air duct to the radiator could also be thermostatically controlled to adjust air flow, and if correctly designed, could significantly reduce the drag caused by the duct when the minimum airflow was required.

I don't know if this is being done, just that it must be possible.

Regards
pat   pprimmer@acay.com.au
eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Radiator Sizing?

From what I understand the Davies Craig water pump has some problems. Autospeed (www.autospeed.com) tested one, and DC were so displeased with the results they threatened legal action, or something along those lines... You wouldn't happen to have any personal or anecdotal experience with them would you?

RE: Radiator Sizing?

No, But I think I saw somewhere that they are supplied to Jaguar as OEM on at least one model. It might be a rumour, as I cannot recall the source of the info.

Regards
pat   pprimmer@acay.com.au
eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Radiator Sizing?

Just thought that if cymeryss didn't really know anything about engines, then knowing % heat rejection to coolant for a modern engine may be of use. (Thanks for the star Greg !)

Andy

RE: Radiator Sizing?

(OP)
Thanks a lot Andy.  When in comes to Davies Craig electric pumps, I was going to use one on my project, but the head pressure on the pump is really low, and just did not suit my application.  I don't know what the problem with the pump was, but maybe because of fouling the flow rates are reduced and that is what causes them not to perform.  Does anybody know what is a typical pressure drop through an average size engine, such as a 3.0L V6?

Cymeryss  

RE: Radiator Sizing?

Didn't measure the pressure drops, but flow rates were as follows for the V6:
    EngWatP    WatinT    WatoutT    Wat_flo
RPM    Bar(g)    øC    øC    l/min
7080    0.69    89    94.5    142.5
7019    0.73    91.5    97.4    140.9
6959    0.78    93.6    99.7    140
6707    0.81    93.6    99.8    140.8
6457    0.75    89.2    95    144.3
6205    0.78    92.8    98.8    139
5955    0.77    90.3    96.5    140.2
5454    0.73    87.2    93.5    131.9
4951    0.77    93    98.9    120.7
4649    0.78    91.1    97.2    114.8
4600    0.78    90.3    96.3    114.1
4550    0.78    89.5    95.6    112.8
4450    0.77    88.9    95    110.7
3949    0.76    88.1    94.3    99.6
3450    0.75    89.9    95.6    86.9
2949    0.76    90.6    96.7    73.2
2444    0.77    90.6    97.3    59.3
1939    0.78    90.1    97.6    46.4
1438    0.78    89.1    97.7    34.8
1039    0.79    87.5    97.7    25.7

Based on some other data for a 2.0L I4, I've got pressure drops of ~45kPa&105L/min@5000rpm and 55kPa&135L/min@6000rpm.


Andy

RE: Radiator Sizing?

(OP)
Hey, all my thanks to you Andy.  This is great info and definitely very insightful information which I was exactly looking for.   

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources