×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

(OP)
Does anybody know what could be the minimum C % on a HSLA steel used for through hardening gears (8 in. thick rim)in order to guarantee not only hardness range (310-350 BHN through hardened) but also to be scuffing resistant ? I know that I can easily achieve that range of hardness, as well as improve hardenability and weldability by increasing other alloy elements and by reducing carbon. However, that`s my metallurgist state of mind. The gear designer , on the other hand, does not want to give up carbon because of its "self-lubricating" properties when gear teeth go through mesh with pinion. Today, we fabricate those gears out of 4340 Q & T plates with 0.30% C min. Also, I would appreciate if you could suggest a literature that reffers to C% as an anti-scuffing recommended element (I did not find it on AGMA standards).

Thank you.

RE: MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

Ivo

I don't think there is any relationship between carbon content and scuffing resistance in alloy steels. If you change to a cast nodular iron gear then perhaps some benefit may be observed due to the lubricating effect of the free graphite???

RE: MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

If your metallurgist meant
nickel or lead might have some
anti scuffing qualities, I would
agree.  Have never seen any reference
to carbon having anti galling or
anti scuffing qualities.
I think I have seen some references
to boron having anti scuffing qualities.
Can you have the gear designer site
his references?

RE: MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

Both the above posts are correct. AFAIK (as far as I know) 4340 is not anHSLA steel. 4340 is a low alloy deep hardening steel commonly used in the application you describe. In these steels with carbon <1% there is definately not any free carbon available for lubrication, It is all tied up in the carbides.

The HSLA steels I've seen have relatively low strengths compared to the 4xxx alloys. In fact generally the ones I've seen are sheet material for stamping, have yeilds no higher than 80ksi and tensiles up to 20ksi> the yeild. Carbon content is generally restricted (in the drawing steels) to less than .13% and wont through harden at all....

IF you were to go to a hypo-eutectic casting , (as carburize noted), then there would be free graphite available for lubrication.

nick

RE: MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

Any reasons why you don't use a case-hardened gear?

RE: MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

(OP)
diamondjim; The only reference found to substantiate that statement is : "Modern Gear Production" by H. J Watson - PAGE 60 item 4.2.1 (Pergamon Press - 1970).

Carburize: I am in fully agreement with you and f.y.i, we also design gears made out of ductile iron when possible (it depends on service factor , rpm , H.P of the equipment, .... and so on ).

Nicke: Our Pinions are usually carburized in order to take the advantages you have mentioned. Our gears, on the other hand, are fabricated in segments (2 or 4) due to their size (38 to 40 feet in diameter).

RE: MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

Oh my those ARE really big gears.... Ahh I see mining after your name. What school did you go to? What mining company/ore are you after....

(just chatting now, I really have no other help for you.)
nick

RE: MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

(OP)
Nicke: give me a call when you have time - 610-264 6046

Metengr : Thank you.

RE: MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

ibf,
Have you looked into long and short
addendum gears to reduce the scuffing?
Also called semi-recess action gearing.

RE: MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

(OP)
diamondjim: Sorry for the delay in answering your question. Yes we did.

RE: MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

ibf,
I don’t think that you can get a definitive answer to your question concerning carbon vs scuffing except for specific steel.  You might be an work up a relationship up to 0.65% C,  but then the whole thing will probably get murky even in alloy steels, unless you are talking carburized case.  I think the best correlation would be by looking a machineability and possible surface finish on a particular steels.    They are just too many variables in the equation concerning wear on gears.  

We used Austenitic Ductile Iron with great success running against flame hardened CI and carburized case steel straight cut spur gears.  The results were varied with  DP's below 4.5 (4'' OD), but above 4.5 the biggest factor we found influencing scuffing was the lubrication.   If we didn’t have the proper lubrication package we essentially got scuffing, then wear no matter what the combination of materials.  The secret was that the lubrication had to be heavy on the EP additive plus a dry film package.  Tackiness was also an attribute, but was frowned on by operations due to the lubricant finding the leaking seals and gaskets.      

RE: MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

(OP)
Thanks unclesyd. Please see above the sizes of my gears : 38 to 40 ft. in diameter. That kind of eliminates A.D.I & case hardening. I just want to know if there is any info other than the one I gave to diamondjim in April 22(see it above) , as far as carbon % vs. scuffing is concerned ? If I could use less carbon (less than 0.30%), weldability during fabrication would improve but scuffing resistance would be impaired as per mentioned literature. It is not an easy task to modify something of that order of magnitude ! That`s the dilema. NOTE: We are aware of the important observations you`ve brought up on lubrication.

Thank you.

RE: MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

OOOP'S,
Have you looked at Astralloy-V material?  If not, you might give them a call as they were quite familiar with large segmented gears.   As I've mentioned in previous posts we have used this material for both it's toughness and wear resistance.  

As NickE stated the 43XX alloys above 4330 and below 4345 can give good wear resistance for gears.  The application of this family of alloys for gears is supposedly optimum at 4337.  

RE: MINIMUM CARBON % TO GUARANTEE SCUFFING RESISTANCE

(OP)
Yes, actually ASTRALLOY represents our French supplier in the USA.

Thank you anyway.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources