×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Heater to prevent sump water from freezing HELP!!!

Heater to prevent sump water from freezing HELP!!!

Heater to prevent sump water from freezing HELP!!!

(OP)
I have (3) 21' x 7' x 6' Sump

We are being told to prevent this sump water from freezing. I don't know how to spec a heater that would be enough to keep this sump water around 40F when ambient temperatures fall below 40F. I think it will have a thermostat to control the heating operation. This sump water comes from the cooling tower.

The middle sump will not require heating since it will share temperature its 2 neighbor sumps.

Do anyone have any experience as far as sizing the heater and any recommendation action? Someone told me about 15KW will do the job. Thank you.

RE: Heater to prevent sump water from freezing HELP!!!

The chromalox catalog has some data on this.  For example, heat losses from an uninsulated open tank to ambient air for a 10F differential (80F water, 70F ambient) varies from 20 to 50 watts per ft2 depending on the air's relative humidity and velocity.

You might want to track down a copy to take a look at it.  I'd use 35F to 40F as my maintenance temperature and then whatever minimum air temperature you have.

RE: Heater to prevent sump water from freezing HELP!!!

That's a lot of water.  Its not like it will instantly freeze if the ambient temperature reaches 32F.  There is this thing called the latent heat of fusion.

RE: Heater to prevent sump water from freezing HELP!!!

(OP)
Do you know if there are any source of reference for calculation? Thank you very much and special thanks to TD2K

RE: Heater to prevent sump water from freezing HELP!!!

To thien2002, answers to these questions may help clarifying the situation:

1. Does any of the sumps contain stagnant water; are operations of an intermittent character ?
2. Are the sumps located beneath the CT ?
3. How do you control your cooling tower's (CT) operation in cold weather (louvres, fans, etc.) ?
4. What is the returning circulating cooling water (ccw)  "warm" temperature ?
5. Is there a possibility of by-passing the CT putting some of the returning warm ccw straight into the sump(s) under temperature control ?
6. What is the ccw flow rate ?
7. What is the "exposed" surface of the sumps ?
8. What is the lowest air temperature ?

RE: Heater to prevent sump water from freezing HELP!!!

(OP)
To 25362,

1. Does any of the sumps contain stagnant water; are operations of an intermittent character ? Stagnant
2. Are the sumps located beneath the CT ? Beneath
3. How do you control your cooling tower's (CT) operation in cold weather (louvres, fans, etc.) ?  Fans
4. What is the returning circulating cooling water (ccw)  "warm" temperature ? 40F
5. Is there a possibility of by-passing the CT putting some of the returning warm ccw straight into the sump(s) under temperature control ? No
6. What is the ccw flow rate?
7. What is the "exposed" surface of the sumps ? Air
8. What is the lowest air temperature ? 19F

RE: Heater to prevent sump water from freezing HELP!!!

My question 4. wasn't clear, it should be: what is the temperature of the returning warm ccw entering, not leaving, the CT ?  Q 6.: does the lack of an answer means the CT isn't working ? Q 7.: are the air-exposed surfaces three times  21' x 7' ? Thanks.

RE: Heater to prevent sump water from freezing HELP!!!

Freeze protection in stagnant systems may have to be extended to piping, the CT itself, etc. Sumps may be heated for example, by electricity as you suggest, steam coils, direct steam injection.
Various solutions can be found doing a web search. In the meantime, I found these two sites:

http://www.jlhermon.com/freezing_weather.htm
http://www.ogontz.com/freeze.htm

that may be of help.

RE: Heater to prevent sump water from freezing HELP!!!

Freezing could happen anywhere in the system, even on the (stopped) wet fan blades and CT filling. Freezing on the sumps' would happen on the surface by the cooling effect of water evaporation (~605 kcal/kg) since the heat of vaporization comes from the sensible heat of the water and from the latent heat of ice formation (~80 kcal/kg) driven by the drier air around, rather than by direct air convection cooling. Snow may be another factor, the soil's low temperature may also affect albeit in a lesser degree.

Once formed ice (having a lower vapour presure) may become an efficient physical barrier for cold dry air.

Coming back to your original question, a 15 kW (12900 kcal/h) heater would take care of melting some 350 lb/h of potential ice. For the cooling effect of the cold (dry) air follow TD2K's advice, and multiply the heat in W/ft2 by the exposed area, to obtain the wattage needed. Good luck.

RE: Heater to prevent sump water from freezing HELP!!!

Consider where you install the temperature measuring instrument(s) because of possible "layering" of the stagnant water in the sumps.

RE: Heater to prevent sump water from freezing HELP!!!

(OP)
25362 - Thank you very much for your accurated information.
TD2K - Thank you very much for your valuable advice.

This type of helps meaning you are so dedicated in your career and man, "god bless you". I got me out of the problem. I am sure it will come some more as I live. Thank you.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources