×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Iron FE56

Iron FE56

Iron FE56

(OP)
I'm an electronics engineer who is involved in an experiment where I need to locate a small piece of common Iron, atomic weight 56. I'm getting conflicting info on how to insure that I have FE 56 rather than other common types. This is probably a trivial question in this field, but can someone please tell me how <as a layman> I can easily discern FE 56 from the other isotopes. I only need to obtain a small piece approx 4" long - dia not important, for this experiment. Is iron "rebar" FE 56?
Your help is appreciated,
ElectroTechie

RE: Iron FE56

Rebar is steel, not iron.  But either one will have about 91+ % of Fe56--is that close enough?

RE: Iron FE56

If you are looking for relatively pure elemental composition with a definate isotope (Fe56) then you might want to try a chemical supply house.

Try VWR Scientific.

nick

RE: Iron FE56

Is it possible someone is having some fun with you?  Iron is composed of four stable isotopes of which Fe56 is about 91%.  Separation of isotopes is extremely difficult since the isotopes are chemically identical.  Although it is theoritically possible to get Fe56, I would think it would be extremely expensive.

RE: Iron FE56

Hoganas or Armco  iron would be closest on a commercial grade. Lab chemical suppliers can be able to meet your needs.

RE: Iron FE56

(OP)
I've been having browser problems <mozilla> that would not let me log in. That's why I haven't replied til now. :O(
........................
 Thanks to everyone for all the tips. My "client" specified "common iron FE 56" be used as an "inductor" core, in order for his <experimental> device to work as designed. It sounds like I may have to purchase a small quantity from from a lab supplier as was suggested by Nick - just to be safe. You all made good points, and yes "sreid", you may "have a bit of fun" with me..... after all, if this didn't lead back to a valid request for some tech help <from a client/friend>, I'd suspect an April Fools joke was being played on me.  ;O)
 After some research I had more or less come to that same conclusion <as per sreid>, but I had the nagging feeling that I must have missed something, since my client suggested that FE-56 was "common". Perhaps 91% FE-56 is suitable. I'll have to speak to him about it. Even so, I'll still have to find a source for "iron", as I now see that it apparently comes in many grades, with differing amounts of each isotope. I had wondered about using wrought or cast iron, and one site even mentioned a type of slag supposedly containing a high concentration of FE56 <??>. Funny how something that sounded so simple at the start, could be so involved.
 Thanks to all who replied for all the help. I'll go back and question the source of the request at this point. At least I'm armed with a little knowledge on the subject now (......and as we all know,  a 'little' knowledge is a dangerous thing!  ;O).
Cheers to all,
ElectroTechie

RE: Iron FE56

ElectroTechie-

I think that inductor cores are commonly fine-grained pressed compacts... you might be able to get a very available one from one of the electronics supply houses. IE mouser-digikey-allied

How big of an inductor do you need?
You may be able to remove the core from the (probably old style) common inductors in old tuning equipment.

nick

RE: Iron FE56

ElectroTechie-

I think that inductor cores are commonly fine-grained pressed compacts... you might be able to get a very available one from one of the electronics supply houses. IE mouser-digikey-allied

How big of an inductor do you need?
You may be able to remove the core from the (probably old style) common inductors in old tuning equipment.

nick

RE: Iron FE56

Another common choice for inductor cores is ferrite.  Magnetics, Inc. is a good supplier
http://www.mag-inc.com/

RE: Iron FE56

(OP)
Thanks for the latest tips, but this doesn't involve inductors as we normally know them. It's far removed from conventional electronic theory, where this particular <special> core is concerned. It's closer to the realm of physics rather than "normal" electronics theory. In this design standard inductors would be useless (I could have handled that with ease). Since a probable patent is involved I can't go into the details. Unfortunately, it doesn't make much sense without those details. Sorry I can't share it, but I've signed a non-disclosure statement. I spoke with the person involved today, and after all the questions raised he agreed to supply the FE himself, so that takes care of that. Thanks again to everyone for all the suggestions. Good to know that help is out there when you need it. :O)
ElectroTechie

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources