×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Best device for low power DC current generator

Best device for low power DC current generator

Best device for low power DC current generator

(OP)
Hi,
I would like to know what is the best device to use to convert mechanical power to DC current (low voltage 12 V, low power, about 60 to 100 Watts).
I want to know if a brushless DC motor is the right choice?
Is it more efficient to use a 12 VDC brushless motor or a higher voltage motor (90 or 180 VDC) with a DC/DC converter to have a 12 VDC?

Martin Gagne

RE: Best device for low power DC current generator

A "brushless" motor will not work. The replacement for brushes used to commutate the armature current are solid state switches designed only to switch current into the motor. The power level and voltage you mention is approximately that of an automotive alternator or generator. The former uses diodes to rectify the generated AC while the latter uses brushes to do the same thing. If you remove the switching circuits from a brushless motor with permanent magnets and replace them with diode bridges, you will get an unregulated DC. The automotive alternator uses a variable armature current to regulate the magnetic field and thus the voltage out. It may need battery voltage to start producing power.

RE: Best device for low power DC current generator

Suggestions to the original posting marked ///\\\
I would like to know what is the best device to use to convert mechanical power to DC current (low voltage 12 V, low power, about 60 to 100 Watts).
///A suitable small dynamo might be used.\\\
I want to know if a brushless DC motor is the right choice?
///A motor is normally used for electrical energy conversion into mechanical energy.\\\
Is it more efficient to use a 12 VDC brushless motor or a higher voltage motor (90 or 180 VDC) with a DC/DC converter to have a 12 VDC?
///It is better to have the lower parts count, if possible, to have a high reliability, low maintenance and operation costs.\\\

RE: Best device for low power DC current generator

I have used a brushless DC motor to convert mechanical power to DC with good results. A three phrase full wave bridge was used to convert the motor(generator) output to DC.

If the speed of the power source varies, the output voltage will vary. (This may or may not be a problem)

The output voltage may be much lower than the rated motor voltage.

RE: Best device for low power DC current generator

How much voltage variation can you have and what is the current and RPM range ?

The BRUSHLESS MOTOR is a 2 -- 3 phase AC motor which can
be used as a generator. With diodes it generates
rectified AC with considerable ripple. Peak voltage is
proportional to speed.

<nbucska@pcperipherals.com>

RE: Best device for low power DC current generator

The "brushless motor" cited by CarlPugh is in reality an AC alternator with a DC rectifier.

My opinion is that the less expensive solution will be an automobile alternator. A lot of them are designed to charge 12 Volts batteries.

If the required voltage has to be exactly 12 VDC, you should adapt a voltage regulator sensing the DC output.

RE: Best device for low power DC current generator

The DC wind generators have all gone to perminent magnet alternators with rectifiers and regulation. This has proved the most reliable under the punishment these things take.

Using Car alternators are problematic as these require a field current to be supplied. I had a home made wind generator self destruct because the car alternator lost the field power. It was a lousy design, the field was initially generated using a bicycle type generator riding on a belt.

hey, by the way, what about the good od bicycle PM generators or several?

RE: Best device for low power DC current generator

Suggestion: The original posting needs clarified "best". E.g. If the generator voltage is increased and DC/DC converter added, this will increase parts count and negatively affect the system reliability.

RE: Best device for low power DC current generator

(OP)
thanks for the answers.
I would like to clarify my question.
What I want to do is convert mechanical power to electric power. Since I don't have a lot of power (between 60 to 100W) I want to have the more efficient solution.
I have found a 10A permanent magnet DC generator that can do the job. I think to use a 12VDC voltage since its more standard for batteries and lights I think and I will have to charge a battery with the generated current.
I would like to know if a brushless permanent magnet DC motor can be used as DC generator? If yes, is it more efficient than the DC generator? What about the shaft RPM?

Thanks for your help,

Martin Gagne

RE: Best device for low power DC current generator

One minor detail:

If you must charge a standard automotive 12VDC battery, you need to generate ~14VDC to recharge it.

RE: Best device for low power DC current generator

(OP)
I know that. I will be able to adjust the load on the generator in order to set the voltage.

Martin

RE: Best device for low power DC current generator

Suggestion to mgagne (Mechanical) Feb 26, 2004 marked ///\\\

I would like to know if a brushless permanent magnet DC motor can be used as DC generator?
///Yes. DC commutator motors tend to have the larger diameter of the commutator than DC Generator to negotiate larger currents during starts/stops, load variations, etc. Also, the DC motor can be designed structurally stronger because of the load side impact and more severe duty than the DC generator.\\\
 If yes, is it more efficient than the DC generator?
///No.\\\
 What about the shaft RPM?
///Optimal RMPs are preferred for DC Generator\\\

RE: Best device for low power DC current generator

A regular brushless DC motor has permanent magnets in the rotor, three phase stator winding, rotor positioning sensors, encoder sensors and an electronic commutator control.

To make it work as a generator the electronic commutator control should be replaced with a three phase rectifier bridge identifying the output 3 phase power leads from the stator.

With permanent magnets, power electronic regulation of the voltage output is required. Other way the voltage will change proportional to the rotational speed and the load.

This machine is MORE EFFICIENT than the traditional DC machine because it has no field winding losses. The optimum speed should be that in the nameplate data.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources