×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Butterfly vlv.s to Knife Gates?

Butterfly vlv.s to Knife Gates?

Butterfly vlv.s to Knife Gates?

(OP)
Need some help here please ...doing a project where the client wants to trade out butterfly valves for knife gate valves (S.Stl.). This is suppose to happen on a gas line, from sizes 6" to 16"-150# service. My problem is I'm not all that familiar with knife gates. The only time I've seen one used was on a surrey line, but with the exposed gate it doesn't seem like a good valve to use in this particular situation (gas service). The ONLY reason I have been told that we are using these valves is that they are a direct replacement for the butterfly valve (...i.e. they only have to bolt them up with no changes to existing piping). Anybody have any experience with this type of valve? ...Any opinion on this application? THX!   ...Mark

RE: Butterfly vlv.s to Knife Gates?

Mark,
    sorry, I don't have any answer, at the moment... but just another question   

   Why must the butterfly valves be replaced? Is it a matter of weight and/or costs?
     And... what kind of butterfly valves (rubber lined or metallic, high performance or tripple-offset, ...) are they?


Many thanks,         'NGL



RE: Butterfly vlv.s to Knife Gates?

(OP)
anegri   ...The client wants to replace the butterfly valves because they say the valves are leaking. There are approximately 15 valves (in varying sizes) that they want to replace. At this point I don't know exactly what type of butterfly valves they are or who the manufacture is. I have just been introduced to this "project" and I just feel that for sake of convenience the client is making a bigger mistake. Problem there is I really don't have the experience with the knife gates to make that call, hence my question. So any help you can provide would greatly be appreciated!   ...Mark

RE: Butterfly vlv.s to Knife Gates?

11echo,
            I agree with your impression. I'm not axpert about this type of valves either, but as far I can see they're usually employed for "dirty" services: pulp and paper, slurries, etc...

        Just take a look to a brief list of Manufacturers: may be it helps getting an idea of the animal       

 http://www.redvalve.com/Knife_Gates.html

 http://www.velan.com/products/catalogs/kg.htm

 http://www.thomasregister.com/olc/73231680/knife2.htm

 http://www.pulpandpaper-technology.com/contractors/valv...


         I think the valves that leak are simple or "high performance" butterfly valves... if it is so, how about tripple-offset metal seated valves?

Bye,     'NGL

RE: Butterfly vlv.s to Knife Gates?

I have only used knife gate valves on wood pulp slurry service ie for paper making and viscose fibre production, in which they proved ideal. I wouldn't think that on a clean gas duty they would be the valve of choice. I do however stand to be corrected.

RE: Butterfly vlv.s to Knife Gates?

Hi,

There is absolutely no reason not to use butterfly valves for a gas application, whereas knife gate valves are NOT a good choice. As indicated by jet1749 before, knife gate valves are good at "cutting" through media, and do not have a very low leakage rate as you might need for gasses.
The question of the selection of type of butterfly valve and materials is what kind of gas it is, at what pressure, what temperature and if it is used for control or just on/off.
In general rubber lined BFV's are used up to 16 bar and 100°C - any higher and you'll get in the "high performance" type BFV ranges, usually with reinforced PTFE or metal seated valves. Please note that also these valves can have a "zero" leakage rate (eg. the tripple eccentric valve Anegri talkes about) for valves up to 1500# and 28". Now we're talking about some big valves...
Resuming: I strongly suggest against knifegates in gas applications. Use BFV's following the process conditions for this specific application.
Good luck, Magicfrog  

RE: Butterfly vlv.s to Knife Gates?

11echo,

Whereas I agree with the prevoius contributors that the knife gate valve is primarily used in the paper & waste water industries, there are specialist manufacturers who make 'wafer pattern' bonneted knife gate valves. These have a conventional rising stem/gland packing arrangement. Also, a resilient body seat to give bubble tight shut off. We have used them in the past on Hexane vapour duty and they performed well. The valve are not inherently firesafe and are not manufactured to any particular dimensional or design standard ( dont think there is one for knife gates anyway)...

Jeff

RE: Butterfly vlv.s to Knife Gates?

  Another reference about knife gate valves:

            http://www.knifegate.com

   They seem specialized in slurries, too.

Bye,         'NGL

RE: Butterfly vlv.s to Knife Gates?

I'll throw in my 2 cents worth:  As explored earlier, knifegate valves are good for streams with entrained solids. The seats MAY be provided with a resilent seal ring and you MAY get good shutoff initally.  HOWEVER, the packing arrangement of a knifegate provides a VASTLY greater possibility of leakage to the environment than a butterfly valve.  Butterfly valves rotate a relatively small stem 90 degrees through the stem seal, but knife-gates drag the entire gate through the packing by a distance equal to the pipe diameter.  They leak. Most people really DON"T want a lot of free natural gas wafting around in their plants.  It's dangerous on several levels.

Use a good double-offset (High-performance) butterfly valve. They have good shutoff, good seat life, and almost zero environmental leakage.  Two models are Durco BX, Tyco Keyston K-lok, and there are many others.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources