×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

(OP)
Has anyone had any more recent (ref: post re: 9700 in April 03) experience with the Radeon 9800 or 9700. I was thinking of getting a 9800"All in Wonder" for my home system, but if it has marginal capabilities in SW...I will stick with an Nvidia card.
I curretnly use Ti 4600s both at work and at home...and they work quite well with SW( Currently using 2004B2). I would like to upgrade, though...and have read some articles describing less than complete DirectX9 compliance for the Nvid Fx5900.
Also, the 9800 seems to have somewhat better visuals.
I once bought an ATI 9500(for home) but with the drivers that came with the carc, SW would open up...but there would be nothing in the workspace...completely unusable!
I have since heard (and read) that the newer CATALYST Drivers have added CAD support. Although I have also read that ATI wants you to buy a Fire GL card for CAD!!!
Anyway, any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks all.
Kelin

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

no do not get the ATI card you will have problems. Spend the money and get a low level nvidia Quadro FX card

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

PNY NVIDIA QUADRO4 FX500 GRAPHICS BOARD 128MB 8X $300-$350 I think these will enable RealView in SW 2004 but I would call and ask them to confirm

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

(OP)
Is the "realview" option worth it...as I stated, I have been using Ti4600s with great results....and for my home system, I also need to be able to run games (although I understand the Quadro does a great job with the games I play...UT2003, Q3, etc).
Well, thanks all for the help...I will check into the Quadros.
Kelin

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

I think your best bet is to wait 3 months and see what everybody thinks of realview(if it slows down SW) and for the card prices to drop some more.

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

I have the ATI 9700 Pro card at home. There is still nothing faster for games. (this might change next week!)
My home use of Solidworks is fairly light, but it does seem to work well there as well. Last December, this card was $360 retail.

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

I have 9700 Pro (128M) at home too and SW2001 Plus is running well. I agree with Mandrake22 and it's the best gaming card.

It looks like that 9700/9800 is not listed for the compatibility test yet, but others are listed as "Passed W/L"

http://www.solidworks.com/pages/services/VideoCardTesting.html

SW 2003 will be installed soon. I will post if anything goes wrong.

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

ATi's workstation equivalent of the Quadro is the FireGL. Its basically a 9700pro with different drivers, much like a Quadro is a Geforce4/FX with different drivers. I have heard of various dodgy methods of converting a 9700pro into a FireGL. If you want to take the risk. My home 9700pro can't run SolidWorks very well at all. I have to turn the hardware acceleration down to just about nothing

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

(OP)
Once again, thanks all for the responses...one question to LoveAeris...was that a typo re: SW2003 being released soon...I have 2003SP4.0 and 2004B2 running....you might want to check the SW support if you are still on 2001+.
While I am still doing some homework on the subject...looks like my initial ideas have been supported by all of you.
To NathanN...I have read the same stuff re: changing the 9700 to a FireGL similarly to the SoftQuadro. While some have had success...I would rather not spend $400 and have to hack it.
I am also intrigued (sp?) by the "realview"....and whether it might be worth it to get a Quadro FX500 or so...either way, I am going to hang on a few weeks to do alittle more research...at $350-500 I would rather not make a mistake!!!
Thanks Again ALL....
Kelin

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

KillaK,

I said "SW 2003 will be installed soon". I have to bring my PC to work and IT is going to install SW 2003.

I wouldn't recommend 9700 Pro for SolidWorks, but for 3D games. My PC at home is primary used for Online Game and Chat, not for work.

I believe the best video card for SW is WildCat. G400 is so so for SW and Game. GeForce4 is good for game and so so for SW. Each cards has own specialty, so define your needs first and pick right one.

However, it's interesting to see two opposite result on 9700 Pro. Well, it may not be opposite result and it could be caused by different expectation. "works well" and "doesn't work well" is not clearly defined. I was using previous driver on W2K, but I updated the driver to Catalyst 3.6 (released July 15). Of coerce I enable X8. I don't work at home frequently, but as far as I operate parts and small assemblies, SW runs without any problem.

By the way, I get over 5500 points by FF11 official Benchmark and FF11 was a main focus when I bought 9700 Pro.

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

Keep tellin' ya...... now it's public.  SW2004 was baselined on Quadro (any Quadro).  Seems to me it makes sense to try and eliminate as much doubt as possible even if you are not going to use RealView.

3/4 of all the Spam produced goes to Hawaii - shame that's not true of SPAM also.......

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

I brought my home PC to work yesterday and IT installed SW2003. I run a benchmark program of "SolidWorks 2003 Workstation Benchmark" on both PCs.

http://www.specbench.org/gpc/downloadindex.html

This is the result of "Test Average for 5 tests" of Graphic.

Radeon 9700 Pro (home): 37 sec
Wildcat VP760 (work): 105 sec

I first run on my home PC and I immediately noticed when I run on work PC that test was going very slow. My home PC has faster CPU, RAM and Hard Drive than work PC and I am not sure how they affect the graphic test, but I am really happy with the result that my video card is about 3 times faster

Now I am confident to work at home with my PC.

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

SBaugh,

Sure I did. I love my batch file I posted.

Thread559-65220 SW crashed, I run the program and I did it right before running the benchmark and made sure no application was running and I didn't even move the mouse following Readme.

The test was not to compare video cards. I just wanted to make sure Radeon 9700 Pro runs SW2003 well and it does without any problem while the benchmark test. I still don't recommend Radeon 9700 Pro for SW though. It's a best gaming card and I would say good enough for SW2003 at home.

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

I forgot you made that batch file I guess I was getting some since my loooong day today, of answering Tech support SW questions, as well as answering SW questions here.

You might try doing a fresh install of SW on the work machine. I new computer without a lot of apps on it or just the plain fact hasn't bee running that long. IMO would get better performance than a old one would.



Even better yet reinstall the OS i wouldn't do it just for a test but if you want accurate results I would consider it.

Best Regards,

Scott Baugh, CSWP
3DVision Technologies
http://www.3dvisiontech.com
http://www.scottjbaugh.com
FAQ731-376
When in doubt, always check the help

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

I was looking on ebay for video cards, and it seems like there's quite a price disparity. If you do a search for wildcat in video cards, you'll find cards from $1 to over $1000. There are some II's for under $100. And, there's a wildcat 4000 G2 for $1! Should I go for one of em? Is there something else I should know?

PS I'm currently running AMD 1.2Ghz, 512 RAM, and Gforce 2 MX 32MB All 2 years old before I did too much heavy CAD work. I may buy another 512 RAM too, it's pretty cheap. But, I bought my board about week before the XP chips came out, so 1.4 is as fast as my board will ever support so no processor upgrade for now.

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

Just how much risk are you willing to take?

It is published fact the SW2004 is baslined (irrespective of RealView) on the Quadro chipset.

Bear in mind the issues with alternative graphics cards/drivers in the past - particularly with SW2003 (no RealView there!).

Look at all the old posts relating to graphics issues, speed and stability, etc.  Look at all the whining and crying as well.

I have to be blunt about this. All I can say is if you choose to go out and buy anything but a Quadro based graphics card, heading into SW2004, don't you dare to come back and complain if it does not work later.  You will get no sympathy from me nor I suspect most of the regulars on this news group.  For once SolidWorks have made their basline choice and publicly stated it.  We really do not have any excuse if we do not follow that guideline.

Granted if you are looking at your home system for light use, home licence, then maybe you can stay with what you currently have or choose the best opion for you heaviest application and deal with the results if necessarly.  But for commercial use there really is no question.

3/4 of all the Spam produced goes to Hawaii - shame that's not true of SPAM also.......

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

Dear JNR ,
 I do not agree with your view, if Software companies that produce games can allow for 2 or 3 brands of graphic card producers why not SW. I understand that realview may not be available if you choose a non Quadro Chipset, but having that option not on is a choice and should allow those who really think that it is not that great of a thing anyway operate without a Quadro Chipset card. I always have a problem with software companies when they get to dictorial about specific brands of hardware you can use. I have no problem with them giving general guidelines such as RAM, Graphic Card Brands & Ram size, HD Size and RPM, and processor SPeeds. What SW has to remember that alot of us have numerous programs both engineering and business related on our systems and perhaps there choice is not the best for those programs.

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

Dear Rocko,

I think what JNR is saying is since SW is "baselined" on the Quadro chipset that is the safest bet!  If you choose another chipset that's fine just don't cray about it later if and when it dosn't work with 2004!  As far as SW being dictorial all they did is publish what they used as a baseline by way of information.  If you choose to ignore it and make other choices for whatever resons your SW performance or nonperformance is on your head and no one elses

David A. Johnson
Thunder Systems Inc.
Corona, CA

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

I agree with Rocko.

Selection should not be ONLY one. I have no problem to see a program is tuned up based on hardware or unique software function at beginning. However, a software manufacture should not limit the selection of video card.

It seems like some of forks are giving a message "Use it or loose it", but I am very interesting to hear on this by SolidWorks personnel. "Realview" is available with Quadro Chipset on a future release does not necessary mean that other video card will not support it.

For example, FF11 was in same situation. It was developed based on nVidia GeForce3 card, but the official page now says "nVidia GeForce or ATI Radeon9000". We, customers should have more than one selection, especially for video card because it is a major component of PC. A competition will improve the price and quality.

By that way, is there really risk involved if you select something else other than Quadro? This is a web site of SolidWorks.
http://www.solidworks.com/pages/services/VideoCardTesting.html
As long as you see "Pass", the card should be OK. That means SW run without problems. However, there are other functions to check, like speed, quality of pictures, or etc. That's why a personal preference is involved and we select different video card based on the preference. "Realview" is only one of function and even if it doesn't work, it does not necessary mean the card is listed as "Failed", probably "Passed W/L".
Is there an official web page that "Realview" works only with Quadro?

Anyway, Eng-Tips is NOT only for Quadro user and I will support you anyway as long as they are listed as "Pass" or "Pass W/L" on the SolidWorks web page. I would say it's on your risk if you select "Failed" from the page above.

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

The new Quadro cards have some new Technology on them and the Real view takes advantage of that (To my understanding). That's why the Real view is only available to those cards (at this time) When the technology gets spread out a little we may see and may have more of a choice in cards that support Real view.

But I'm glad to see SW has stepped up to the plate and said these cards will work for SW and support realview at the same time. I get a TON of calls everyday asking what card SW recommends. Well now I can give them a card instead of saying go here and pick out a card that you like. Even though it may pass at the site, it maybe an old card (This happened recently to one of my customers).

If you don't want or care about Real view then get a card that doesn't support it. It's that simple... but if you get a card that doesn't pass in the green, then you really can't complain, unless you didn't check out the website first, but make sure it's a newer card and not one that's been out a while.

SW isn't saying that other cards won't work with SW, they are only saying that some cards don't support Realview. It's not SW fault because certain cards don't have that technology yet. Talk to Nvidia and ask them why the Geforce cards don't support it or other types for that matter..?

I understand Rocko's point but I also agree with JNR to some degree as well. I think I have made it clear above, that SW isn't saying just use these cards and that's it. They are saying these cards work with SW and with Real View. So if you want a card that SW recommends directly with SW04 get one of those cards.

Regards,

Scott Baugh, CSWP
3DVision Technologies
http://www.3dvisiontech.com
http://www.scottjbaugh.com
FAQ731-376
When in doubt, always check the help

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

dear guys a bit of background first

real view is based on the cg high level programming language cg is a developers kit for games makers and the like and allows more realistic on screen realtime rendering using the graphics hardware as opposed to software more recently the technology nvidia has incorporated in its graphics cards has evolved to take advantage of the advances in chipset technology and enable it to be used in software applications for dcc and engineering

the basic view window will enable creation of realtime rendered images to a very high standard approaching rendered images sufficiently detailed and accurate enough to make believe that the two technolgies combined can produce a non rendered photo real image


whilst this is still a long way off the support on nvidia cards means that this particular method of shading and colour sampling is very very good and is suited more to these cards moving towards hardware rendering as opposed to software rendering reducing timescales for realy high quality images.

scott may remember my gripes about the pw2 renderer now based on mental ray taking so long well basically hardware rendering eliminates a lot of rendering time

as with any form of high end rendering software shaders must be pre written and applied and whilst this is slightly outside the scope of most solidworks users what you get in realview is a set of pre prepared shaders to apply ,the graphics card takes care of taking this c based information and interprates it to what you see on screen

Now im pretty sure that the support for nvidia cards by solidworks is based partly on this technology nvidia had a big hand in it and whilst im sure ati cards may support cg ive not seen any code development tools for ati cards to fully implement cg or termed real view this may mean that the nvidia card is the better choice for now

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

To Killak !

I have ben using a radeon 9500 non pro.

Its essentially the same card as the FireGl X1.
You can "upgrade" your 9500 to a firegl class card.

If you get hold of the 1036 firegl drivers , and apply patch with Rivatuner.

http://download.guru3d.com/pafiledb.php?action=file&id=163

It has some issues on my system, like large performance drop when having more than 5 windows(assemblys, parts) open at the same time. Otherwise performance is unmatched, made an assembly with 5000+ parts, and it spinned around with no problem. I did NOT use large aseembly mode.

Try it out, an let us know how you are doing !

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

We have been using SW on Radeon 9000Pro's without problems.  On the other side when I upgraded at home to a Radeon 9600Pro I couldn't run SW no more.  Same symptoms as described further up with empty workspace (although when moving cursor over model outlines will come up).  Read somewhere on a German 3D forum that there are some fundamental issues with ATI cards and CAD software.

RE: Radeon 9800 (or 9700) use in Solidworks

TreeHugging : have you tried the firegl mod on your card?

It would be nice to se if it works for you .

Ps: if you get it working, try the 6x antialiasing setting, things look very nice feels like having  twice the resolution . I can only use it if I´m opening one or two assemblys, the problem mentioned in previous post get worse with AA anabled.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources