Change from 2d to 3D models
Change from 2d to 3D models
(OP)
We are a aerospace sheet metal house that is using Microcadum 2d software to develope all of our flat pattern and lofting data. We want to go to solid modeling for the sheet metal, I use Catia V-5 for mechanical part modeling i.e. forgings, castings. How well does Catia aerospace sheet metal package work? We are looking at SolidWorks also but are not sure, SW does look much more intuitive to use and learn than Catia.
Any input is valuable
Thank you
Any input is valuable
Thank you





RE: Change from 2d to 3D models
First of all, I think is better to put your thread in CATIA products forum.
In my opinion, CATIA is the best choice for aerospace industry. Most of the companies involved in aircraft industry use this software for their designs (including 3D models).
You are right about SolidWorks but I think you should take in consideration what software is used in this industry.
Regards
Fernando
RE: Change from 2d to 3D models
Thanks for the reply, I put the thread in the aerospace forum because I was wanting input from people in that sector and was trying to avoid to much Catia bias.
I agree on using the software most used in the industry but, we do not get cad files from our customers, we generate all of our own data from paper prints or from old mylars. We also design most of our forming tools in-house. This is a big change over for us and we need to look at all of our options, and again thanks for the input.
Larry
RE: Change from 2d to 3D models
TheTick gives you the right answer on the SW forum. I have the same opinion like him.
I can use both softwares and, in my opinion, CATIA is the best choice for the aerospace.
On the other hand, SW have a special module for molds which is very easy to use. As I remember CATIA have also a special module for molds (this is your primary concern?).
I can suggest to you to discuss with those companies (dealers?) who can make some demonstrations at your company headquarter with these two softwares, probably the best choices you can done.
Regards
Fernando
RE: Change from 2d to 3D models
If your customers are using CATIA, I would look into CATIA. CATIA translation is difficult and trying to be interoperable using a system other than CATIA may lead to communication problems and inefficiencies in your workflows.
--Scott
For some pleasure reading, the Round Table recommends FAQ731-376
RE: Change from 2d to 3D models
RE: Change from 2d to 3D models
<airplaneany@yahoo.com>
RE: Change from 2d to 3D models
RE: Change from 2d to 3D models
It's amazing how many software houses will confidently make claims about what they can do, until you say 'off y'go then..'
Excessive accuaracy is a sign of poor breeding. -Socrates.
RE: Change from 2d to 3D models
Larry
RE: Change from 2d to 3D models
I know at least 5 people with good CATIA V5 skills and aerospace backgrounds. They're looking for jobs. Where are you located? Has your company posted jobs on the web?
.... Jack