×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water
2

VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

(OP)
Shaft corrodes in environment where it survived before use of VFD.

Does anyone have deep knowledge in this field? Suspect stray currents from frequency inverter (same thing as you have in ball bearings) that somehow affect the titanium.

Common wisdom says that AC should not cause electrolytic damage (no net charge transportation), but observations indicate that corrosion is a fact.

Theory: Streaming water spools ions away so they don't find their "way home" again when the current changes direction. Anyone done any observations?

RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

(OP)
Anyone? Please!

RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

Dunno what VFD means (variable fan drive?), but half the time with AC is in the wrong direction corr.-wise, and you don't regain anything the other half.

RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

(OP)
Thanks Metalguy,

VFD = Variable Frequency Drive aka Frequency Inverter.

The frequencies involved in the corrosion are in the several hundred kilohertz region (HF part of the switching frequency) and my thinking was (is?) that the ions do not move much in a couple of microseconds and hence "fall back" when polarity reverses.

So I did not expect to lose tens of mm due to that kind of corrosion. Do you know about any publications that describe this?

A razor's edge is quite another story. Any progress?

RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

Its sounds lke you are enhancing the galvanic coupling between the titanium and the surrounding environment. You may also be ionizing species in the water.

RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water


you may have a grounding problem. VFD(variable freq drive) in and of itself does not cause corrosion.

what is you fluid, is the pump direct drive, have you grounded the motor, where is the corrosion occuring, and what sort of mechanical coupling are you using?

RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

(OP)
Sorry hacksaw, I am awfully late in answering your question:

The liquid is North Atlantic seawater. Current seems to flowing through shaft (steel coupling, not insulating) into pump and from internal shaft and impeller to pump housing and from there to ground. The affected parts are internal shaft and impeller. We obviously have to insulate the coupling. Or find some other solution.

Have you experienced similar problems?

Thanks for your interest!

RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

I've heard of the swept away ion hypothesis before. Also heard that some metallic joints will tend to rectify the induced current. I cannot confirm either one.

A few decades back I was involved with the salt water system of an aquarium. After changing from rubber coupled pumps to close coupled pumps, the corrosion of the cast iron impellers increased dramatically. I could measure both AC and DC potentials on the fan end of ther motor shaft to ground while it was running. 60 Hz, no VFD involved. Pump manufacturer tried various coatings with no luck. Finally replaced impellers with SS. I had thought of rigging a brush to ground the shaft, but never got the chance to try it.

RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

I presume that the speed after the installation of the VFD was LOWER rather than higher, but that may not be true.  Why was the VFD installed?  If the new operating speed is higher than before, have you considered that you may be experiencing velocity-induced damage to the shaft and impeller, due to removal of the passive layer on the titanium- I have heard of erosion-corrosion phenomena with titanium before.  Just a thought...

RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

(OP)
Thanks stevenal and molten,

I should have mentioned that there are several pumps involved. The older ones are DOL and the newer ones are VFD. The old ones have normal lifetime but those with VFD have only months before they need repair/changing.

The speed of the new ones is lower than that of the DOL pumps (flow regulated by adjusting valves).

I had another case today. A small motor (4 kW with VFD) and I was finally able to measure about 20 mA AC in shaft between motor and pump. Sounds not so serious, but I guess that it will have some effect over time. N.B. that this is not the pumps in the original posting, but much smaller ones.

Have also started to think about shaft grounding with a carbon brush.

Have started a test with Titanium bars in salt water and feeding them with AC to find out what happens. Keeps the water circulating around one of the bars and still around the other. Central common bar is the counter-electrode. Any comments to that kind of setup?

RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

2
I have encountered something similar to this on boiler feedwater pump with variable speed gear drive - stray currents in shaft jumped across gaps of gear teeth and pitted teeth making excruciating noise. Solution was a simple insulated coupling

RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

(OP)
Thanks hamma1,

Yes. An isolated coupling would do the trick. But not possible in this case (motor shaft carries impeller and seals). No intermediate bearings and no room for it.

We have had several cases this year where PWM inverters have caused damage to seals, tubing, bearings and gears. We try to use inverters with sine-wave output whenever possible. They solve all these problems.

RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

Since these are fairly small units I wonder how good the output filtering on the VFD is.  There should be no stray harmonics.
I have had VFD/pump problems in the past.  They turned out to not be galvanic, but corrosion fatigue.  The VFDs were causing a small amount of high frequency pulsing that was wearing the heck out of couplings.  Pitting, fretting, fractures, the whole works.  It was solved with better output filtering.
I have trouble believing that this is galvanic.  Almost everything else in you system is less noble than Ti.  If you have some stray current or induced voltage issues I would expect the non-Ti parts to be going away very fast.

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Corrosion never sleeps, but it can be managed.
http://www.trenttube.com/Trent/tech_form.htm

RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

Hamma1

Request to give more inf on insulated coupling ! esp. gear type coupling & other jaw type.It will help us esp in problems like above.

YBG 58
ybgandhi@gnvfc.com

RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

(OP)
Ed,

"I have trouble believing that this is galvanic.  Almost everything else in you system is less noble than Ti.  If you have some stray current or induced voltage issues I would expect the non-Ti parts to be going away very fast."

All components that are in touch with the liquid are Ti and diamond coated silicon carbide. And it is only where current can pass from component surface to liquid that corrosion has occured. Structural components like motor frame, exterior of pump etc are not affected. And we do not expect them to be affected either.


RE: VFD and Titanium shaft in sea-water

YBG:

Try:

www.tbwoods.com and look for: Sure-flex and Dura-flex couplings.  The HD coupling can provide isolation as well.

www.lovejoy-inc.com has a coupler that can provide isolation as well.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources