×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

stranded and solid copper cables

stranded and solid copper cables

stranded and solid copper cables

(OP)
usually specs require using stranded copper cables for substation applications .what is the problem with solid copper?
thanx.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

Flexibility.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

I believe, the larger gauge is required to reduce the skin effect. One large wire would have all current flowing on the outside (essentially). Multiple wires will distribute the current more evenly. Just a guess but that is my two cents. Also, solid wire in larger gauges is harder to work with (did they actually think of the workers in writing that part of the NEC? I doubt it, hehe)

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

reduces cost as well....

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

(OP)
actually in one project some of the cables were solid and
were pulled easily but after noticing that they are solid they were ordered to be removed.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

NEC requires stranded wire be used above a certain gauge. I dont know what that is off the top of my head. But working in substation I am sure that is why they were ordered pulled out.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

The bend radius is probably a concern depending on the application. Stranded copper has a larger bend radius and therefore can be pulled through conduit with sharper turns.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

If you're talking about control wiring, the main reason for avoiding solid conductors probably has to do with wire terminations.  

Most terminals in substation equipment are designed for use with stranded wire or compression lugs.  Solid conductor terminations will be less reliable.

Stranded wire is also easier to work with and pull.  

We typically specify solid copper wire for lighting and receptacle circuits and stranded for everything else.

   

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

The NEC 2002 Handbook says of Article 310.3 (requiring stranded conductors in #8 and larger):

"Larger-size conductors are required to be stranded to provide greater flexibility.  This requirement does not apply to busbars and the conductors of Type MI mineral-insulated metal-sheathed cable.  In addition, the bonding conductors of a common bonding grid of a permanently intalled swimming pool are required to be solid, nonstranded conductors of 8 AWG or larger, according to 680.26(C)."

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

(OP)
as dpc said I mean control cables but why lighting cables should be solid?

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

Stranded copper wires have greater flexibility compared to solid ones. Solid wires also break easily compared to stranded ones. Have you tried cutting/breaking a small solid wire without a cutter and you just bend it (using your fingers) a lot of times until the bent area heats up then breaks? You try that maneuver with a same size but stranded wire and you will realize that it's a lot harder.
-Max

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

As regards use of solid wire for lighting circuits, it is generally allowed because wire costs are less and terminations and splices used are generally designed to work with solid wire.  

I really don't think flexibiity is a critical factor when dealing with #12 and #10 control circuits.  Stranded wire will be easier to pull, but most substation runs are pretty short.

I have seen a lot of solid control wire in very old substations, but it isn't used anymore, at least in the US.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

For substation wiring(not for controls), stranded copper wire is used to reduced the vibrations caused by the currents passing thru at high voltages. Solid wires exhibit more vibrations compared to stranded ones. This is because, each strand in a stranded cable vibrates separately. However since the strands are laid tightly with each other, the vibrations in each strand counteracts with each other, therefore, reducing significantly the overall effect(vibration).
-Max

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

GOOD MORNING FOLKS FROM THE LAND OF OZ - THE M.I.M.S. TYPE OF COPPER CABLE CALLED PYROTENAX HAS BEEN USED EXTENSIVELY HERE ESP IN THE AREAS OF INTRINSICALLY SAFE / FLAME PROOF WIRING IN GASOLINE/OIL TYPE FUEL PLANTS - ALSO IN THE AREA OF ELEVATOR MAINS.   THIS TYPE IS SOLID CORE WITH SINGLE SOLID COPPER CONDUCTOR WITH MAGNESIUM POWDER INSULATION IN BETWEEN - USUALLY IN THE 500A -2000A SIZE .  THE SMALLER SIZES ARE AVAILABLE IN MULTI CORE FOR CONTROL WIRING / SMALL LIGHTING / POWER ETC .  SINGLE IS USED ALSO FOR UNDERFLOOR HEATING EMBEDDED IN CONCRETE . TALK TO YOUR HEAVY INDUSTRIAL ELECTRICIAN AS OPPOSED TO THE HOUSE WIRING ELECO .   HE WILL ALSO HAVE INSTALLED SOLID COPPER BUSS BAR INSTALLATIONS . SOMETIMES ALUMINIUM IS ALSO USED - THE COMMENT ON SKIN EFFECT WAS INTERESTING AS WE USE 208V / 115V-400HZ SYSTEMS ON MOST LARGE + MILITARY AIRPLANES - ONLY TRUE INTERNATIONAL ELECTRICAL STD I HAVE EVER SEEN INC THE TYPE OF PLUGS + SOCKETS   - TRUST THAT ASSISTS J.C.     

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

Flexible/stranded wires have the advantage of flexibility over  solid conductors.But sometimes too much flexibility is a disadvantage -eg wiring inside a panel .The leads will not remain in place and give a shabby appearance.Then a solid conductor is  an advantage.
Many electrical engineers have the notion that a stranded wire of same dia as a solid conductor will have less skin effect and will have a higher current carrying capacity.This is a misnomer.AC current will see the stranded wire same as a solid rod and current will tend to concentrate on outer layers.In fact skin effect will be more for stranded wire due to the stranding factor .
But all this will change once the strands are insulated from one another by an insulation say ,enamel or paper.Then skin effect is completely eliminated or reduced and still better results are obtained when the strands are transposed.This is the application in Roebel bars used in large generators and motors and Continuously Transposed Cable used in the windings of large Power transformers

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

I would think the skin effect would be worse with stranded wire that was individually insulated since the strands are not touching, all the current divides amongst each individual strand. Whereas the no insulation on individual strands would tend to act like a solid conductor. I do not understand why you say skin effect is less with stranded than solid conductors. Also, just to note, I never thought stranded had a higher current carrying capacity than solid.
Also, when terminating large gauge wire to terminals, we use conductive tape to hold the strands together. But the stranded often needs tightening more often than solid.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

Some thoughts.
The NEC does not usually apply to substations.  Parts of privately owned substations may, but in general the NESC and/or the whims of the local inspector cover substations.  In my experience seldom does a local inspector look at a substaion, usless it's just for a tour.

Solid aluminum cable with XLP insulation is commonly used for URD system in sizes up to 2/0.  It would seem that solid cable would be harder to pull but in practice it is not. The stiffness of the insulation is greater that that of the conductor so the change from stranded to solid doesn't really affect the overall stiffness.
On reason for solid conductors was water intrusion in the conductor and the "treeing" and failure of insulation.
Cable pushers work well with solid cable.  It may sound strange to push a cable but it works more like installing a speedometer cable or brake cable on a bike.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables


For a fair amount of US utility and industrial switchgear, default control wiring is 14AWG/41-strand, 12AWG/65-strand, 10AWG/105-strand, etc…
     

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

Response to Buzzp:
My understanding is skin effect is higher for non insulted sranded wire because of stranding effect .When srands are insulated from one another current flows in all strands equally (an assumption wrong in many cases and hence the need for transposing )there by reducing the skin effect substantially.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

PRC, I will have to check into thatmore when have time. Thanks.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

I hate to spoil a good argument, but skin effect at 60 Hz is pretty insignificant, and has nothing to do with the choice between solid or stranded wiring for control circuits in substation.  (especially the dc circuits )

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

One of the biggest issues with control wiring in substations is that it often lands on the doors, which means the wires will be flexed relatively frequently.  If possible, the permanently installed control wiring should first land on terminal blocks to avoid this.

Any control wiring installed entirely within a switchboard, that lands on the switchboard door and which crosses the door hinge should be specified to be type SIS, as defined in Article 310.13 as approved for use as "switchboard wiring only".  This is a very flexible conductor which is made specifically to withstand the abuse of flexing across a door hinge.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

DPC, This side discussion started before we knew it was DC control wiring. Thanks for the input though.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables


peebee's comments are consistent with IEEE C37.20, .21 verbiage.  Having to install any significant quantity of switchgear/control wiring that is not of K/H stranding would be insanity.
  

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

My understanding from the power electronics end of the world is as follows:

Skin effect is present to similar level in solid and stranded cable. The effect can be minimised by using special types of stranded cable in which individual strands are insulated from each other. This is known as 'Litz wire', and is used for high-frequency work in RF and in power electronics applications. At 50 / 60Hz skin effect is negligible except in exceptionally large conductors such as are found in generator bushings and gen xfmr LV bushings. The unequal distribution of current within insulated strands of a bundle is due to proximity effect, which is similar to but quite distinct from skin effect.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

Suggestion: It depends. As NEC indicates the limit for larger conductors to be stranded, this is matter flexibility. However, smaller conductors, e.g. up to #10AWG would be wiring inconvenience for many devices, e.g. receptacles, that have snap in hole for solid conductors. Also, many screw terminals of smaller size conductors fit better to solid conductors since special pliers produce a suitable hook or eye on the solid conductor, which fits properly under the screw head.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

Just my 2 cents worth!
Being an Emergency Generator Tech I can say this after some thirty years in the field, solid wire tends to fracture do to the constant vibration after a while particularly at the terminal.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

To 144X:
I agree with most of the arguments here, stranded wire is easy to install, you don't have to worry about the bends where you can break a solid wire and its easy in your fingers when you install it.
But all of that is not the point...When you're checking for a faulty wiring in an old substation where they used solid wire, pray that you don't pull a current transformer wire too hard because it will slip from the terminal and that'll be your last day...I don't know the relation between pulling stranded wire or solid wire and disconnecting it, what I do know is that we had many substations with both of them and we had a lot of problems with the ones with solid wire so we forbade the engineer department to approve the use of solid wire in any new substation due to personal safety.
I hope this usefull to you.

RE: stranded and solid copper cables

Suggestion: It appears that the stranded conductors may absorb more of corrosive agents among strands, which may lead to faster dilapidation of the stranded conductors.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources