×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Optimum pH for NaOH based Wet SO2 Scrubber
2

Optimum pH for NaOH based Wet SO2 Scrubber

Optimum pH for NaOH based Wet SO2 Scrubber

(OP)
I am looking for assistance with the best pH to operate a small NaOH based scrubber for controlling low concentrations (75 ppm ) of SO2 from a CHP exhaust, with a high CO2 content. I wish to minimise NaOH losses to carbonate formation while still removing SO2. Technical references as well as field experience most welcome.
Thanks in advance,
TISM

RE: Optimum pH for NaOH based Wet SO2 Scrubber

Since SO2 is much easier absorbed than CO2, the presence of CO2 should not pose much of a problem.  Very little CO2 is absorbed below a pH of 9.  By contrast, the blowdown pH from an SO2 absorber is typically around 6.  Pick a blowdown pH of 7 if you must have a neutral discharge, or if you plan the neutralize the discharge with caustic anyways.  On the other hand, if you can handle an acid discharge, then to minimize the caustic consumption let the pH drop as low as possible whilst maintaining the outlet SO2 concentration required.

RE: Optimum pH for NaOH based Wet SO2 Scrubber

I suggest you pay a visit to Thread127-56418.

RE: Optimum pH for NaOH based Wet SO2 Scrubber

(OP)
I appreciate the reference but that thread relates to lime (CaO) based wet scrubbing systems where I am interested in an NaOH only system.
Thank you anyway

RE: Optimum pH for NaOH based Wet SO2 Scrubber

OK.
Technical references may easily be found in the internet.

Since the scrubber is small, have you considered using just water? If you simply dissolve the gases in water you'd probably absorb much more CO2 than SO2 because of their relative proportions in the gas (divided by their respective Henry Law constants). For example, if the relative volume fraction of CO2 /SO2 in the gas is, say, 190:1 the mol fractions absorbed in water @ 30oC, would be: (190)(50)/(1900) = 5. Five times more CO2 than SO2.

The reactions with water:

CO2(gas) <-> CO2(dissolved); +H2O<->H2CO3<->H+ +HCO3-

SO2(gas) <-> SO2(dissolved); +H2O<->H2SO3<->H+ +HSO3-.

The right concentration of H+ in solution that drives the first reaction to the left while driving the second to the right happens at 10-4 to 10-6 mols per liter (pH= 4-6). This pH is not achievable with NaOH solutions. NaOH solutions (pH>7) would absorb more CO2 than SO2 at 30oC.

To remove SO2 without absorbing CO2, the scrubbing solution should be a weak acid. That's the reason I suggested you visit the other thread.

Industrial-size solutions consider using soda ash (sodium carbonate) or bicarbonate which are cheaper and can be regenerated. A typical reaction would then be:

Na2CO3 + SO2 -> Na2SO3 + CO2 for the scrubber

And in the holding tank one may regenerate the sodium carbonate with calcium salts in a reaction such as:

Na2SO3 + CaCO3 + 0.5 O2 -> CaSO4(Gypsum) + Na2CO3

then to a thickener for precipitation and separation of calcium sulphate (with a flocculating agent), while the supernatant liquid would be reused in the scrubber. Some carbonate is lost in the cake, and some calcium would be retained in solution but in sufficiently low concentrations not to form solids in the scrubber.

Yours is a apparently a small outfit so my suggestion is you heed PeterAB's advice.

RE: Optimum pH for NaOH based Wet SO2 Scrubber

pH control is really a function of how much caustic or lime you add, not a function of which alkali you choose.  Keeping a low pH is more critical for lime than for caustic based scrubbers, because the slightest CO2 absorption can cause scaling (CaCO3 formation) in lime-based scrubbers.  Since sodium carbonate/bicarbonate is more soluble, scaling is typically less of a problem with caustic-based scrubbers.

Note also that whereas the absorption of SO2 into aqueous solution is a virtually instantaneous process limited only by the diffusion rate of the SO2 molecules to the gas-liquid interface, the absorption of CO2 is a much slower process controlled by resistance to mass transfer in the liquid phase.  Quoting Perry's Chemical Engineer's Handbook (p. 18-44 in 5th ed.):
"Sherwood and Pigford ("Absorption and Extraction," 2nd ed. McGrawHill, NY 1952) indicate that the controlling step is a slow pseudo-first-order irreversible reaction between dissolved CO2 and OH-,..."
Hence in addition to minimizing pH, the absorption of SO2 over CO2 may be favored by minimizing the reaction time available for absorption.  For this purpose you may wish to consider a finely atomized spray scrubber, which due to its large gas-liquid interfacial area completes the absorption in about one second. see www.turbosonic.com

RE: Optimum pH for NaOH based Wet SO2 Scrubber

Even for fine atomization the absorption of SO2 in one-stage contact spraying may be only around 70% efficient, when the molar ratios of alkali to SO2 are up to 20% above stoichiometric, for flue gas entering at about 400oF.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources