×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Hot Oil Heater - Natural Gas or Electric Heating?

Hot Oil Heater - Natural Gas or Electric Heating?

Hot Oil Heater - Natural Gas or Electric Heating?

(OP)
I am in the process of designing a new plant that requires a hot oil heater for process heating.  I am trying to determine which is more cost effective to heat hot oil - natural gas or electricity?  Plant is in TX.  I estimate the heat load to be around 2,000,000 BTU / hr.  Temperature of the hot oil will be maintained at 400 oF.

RE: Hot Oil Heater - Natural Gas or Electric Heating?

determine cost of energy input (electricity vs. gas vs. oil vs. etc.) and assume an efficiency of the heater.  my SWAG is that natural gas is the better choice (barring any environmental issues) for the duration of the plant/equipment.
certainly, the supply of resources will need to be addressed, but then again, location is in texas where there is an abundance of energy supply.
-pmover

RE: Hot Oil Heater - Natural Gas or Electric Heating?

dlefin (Mechanical):

Take it from another Texan: this is a no-brainer.  A direct fired heater with natural gas as fuel beats an electrical resistance heater everytime - and by a big margin.

There is no environmental issue in Texas, except a permit to fire.  At a heat load of 2 MMBtuh, I would not hesitate to commence my engineering and planning based on using Natural gas.  However, if you were working under me in Process design, I would require an economic calculation to justify the decision based on fuel and total operating and Capital costs.

There is no "abundance" of Natural gas (in Texas or any other US state); however, when you have to burn Natural gas to produce the electricity anyway, it doesn't take much brain cells to figure out that if there is no Natural gas, there is no electricity anyway!  I presume you are going to heat a DowTherm fluid or something similar.  Good Luck.

Art Montemayor
Spring, TX

RE: Hot Oil Heater - Natural Gas or Electric Heating?

If, as Art Montemayor rightly suggests, you carry out an overall plant economic (including "what ifs") balance, is it possible to also consider steam process heating (only if there is available steam) as an alternative in the study ? The total steam duty would be around 1 ton/h and you may allow yourself a lower steam temperature (and lower steam pressure) for the heating purpose, especially if the heated material is temperature sensitive.

RE: Hot Oil Heater - Natural Gas or Electric Heating?

25362:

I don't think you can achieve the 400 oF oil temperature that dlefin proposes by using conventional steam utility pressures and boilers.  You'd have to go as high as 300+ psig or higher, rather than the conventional 150 - 200 psig range.  However, your point is a great addition to the list of competitive heating methods is such a level of steam supply exists.  If it does exist, I suspect it would win out as the winning candidate.

Art Montemayor
Spring, TX

RE: Hot Oil Heater - Natural Gas or Electric Heating?

(OP)
Gentlemen,  Thank you for your response to my question.  My gut feel told me that gas was the right way to go as well.  Steam is not an option - the plant manager would never buy into a steam boiler.

This is my first time using this forum.  I am very impressed with how this works.

RE: Hot Oil Heater - Natural Gas or Electric Heating?

Umm, no.  If you don't have steam already on site, steam is pretty much of a no-go for a heat requirement this size.  

RE: Hot Oil Heater - Natural Gas or Electric Heating?

If you use electricity, you may be able to get a discount rate from the utility company. Otherwise NG is more economical "ounce for ounce".

RE: Hot Oil Heater - Natural Gas or Electric Heating?

To Art Montemayor and others, I'm well aware of the limitations you mentioned, however when a hot thermal oil needs 400F to achieve the heating duty you can easily use steam with a 100 F lower (saturation) temperature for the same purpose. That's the beauty of it. But, as I said, it should be already available, better even, with the possibility of returning the condensate.

An added benefit: if the material heated is thermally sensitive, you may protect it by keeping metal skin temperatures low enough.

This is a subject that only dlefin can tell when doing the full economic analysis.

RE: Hot Oil Heater - Natural Gas or Electric Heating?

Thank you for the undeserved star. There is another possibility that dlefin could include in his techno-economic analysis, and that is direct electric "process" heating without the use of an intermediary hot oil. My experience with this type of heating has been quite satisfying, especially with delicate stratifying heat-sensitive two-phase flows on the process side. All depends on the design "quality" of the heating units.

RE: Hot Oil Heater - Natural Gas or Electric Heating?

As a German supplier for Thermal oil systems, we would like you to consider even other issues. The capacity of the heater is rather small which keeps the investment for electrical thermal oil heater on an acceptable level. Using a gas fired heater, one should not forget that more equipment and space is needed. You need a gas burner, ducting and a stack. You probably have annual emission tests and require more spare parts such as flame sensors, ignition electrodes, gas soelnoid valves etc. An electrical thermal oil heater can be installed even within buildings very close to the consumer, which saves piping. Here in Europe electrical thermal oil heaters are seldom used as the costs/kWh are too high. Other countries where power is cheaper due to water power plants etc. can run these systems more economical. A major issue is the reliability - a burner can fail due to various reasons (solenoid valve, ignition electrodes, fan etc.) It is unusual to keep all these spare parts in stock which means that your down time can be quite long. For an electrical thermal ol heater, one only need a spare heating rod and some electrical parts. The first investment does not matter so much. Important is that one can operate the system with a minimum staff and down time, as down time will normally cause you the real problems - production loss, order delays etc. If you would like to go more in detail, please visit our webpage www.maxxtec.com or drop us a line

Stefan   

RE: Hot Oil Heater - Natural Gas or Electric Heating?

I'd heat it directly with an electric process heater.  Go to www.integraheat.com for more information and sizing /selection.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources