×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

(OP)
Hello,

The situation I'm in is that I am using a Motor I/O Card to control two different motors. The card has two outputs to control the motors. The card is being used in conjunction with a PC104 card, which will control the motion of the motors through the Motor I/O Card.

The problem I have is that the Motor I/O card can only output a maximum of 3A and an absolute maximum of 6A for very short transients --- however each motor draws upto 11A initially before settling to steady-state of 1-1.5A.

So what I want to do is find a way to supress that initial current needed by the motor.

It has been suggested to me that the use of capcitors across the battery would be an effective solution and the use of Power Mosfets was also suggested.

Does anyone have any comments on these or any other solutions to this problem.
Thanks in advance,
joe.

RE: Supression the initial current drawn by a motor


One cannot get blood from a turnip.  In ANSI regions, a magnetic starter is the accepted method for controlling motors, for either PLC-based I/O or 'passive' control components.  

Also, it is imperative to incorporate motor-overload time-current characteristics in the motor-power circuit.
  

RE: Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

absolutely valid concerns raised by busbar.

I assume it is a dc motor. I believe a help capacitor across the battery/supply output would maintain the voltage during the high current.

You have the responsbility to make a safe choice.

RE: Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

(OP)
electricpete and busbar --  thank you very much for your replies.
My apologies for failing to mention it is a DC Motor !

Can either of you shed some light on choosing an appropriate capcitor value -- as this seems the most suitable solution given the situation I'm in.

Thank You

RE: Supression the initial current drawn by a motor


Whether AC or DC, the magnetic starter would be considered effectively a very desirable “interposing relay.”  
  

RE: Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

I can get you started.

i = c * dv/dt
integral i dt = integral c *dv = c* integral dv = c * deltaV

C = i*t / deltaV

Let's say your power supply is 10vdc and you want to keep it above 90% voltage (deltaV=1vdc) while supply I=11A (neglect current provided by battery) for t=2sec

C =i*t / deltaV = 11A*2sec / 1V = 22F

Maybe you should check my math and my units. That's a pretty big cap.


RE: Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

The starting current of the motor needs to be analyzed if the motor is loaded or not.

Though, the motor will require additional current to start the run and it is going to be difficult to have it reduced.
The problem that I had, somewhat close to yours, was solved by having an additional circuit that detected the initial arrival voltage and added a circuit to apply at 3 times the incoming current for about 4 seconds.

I had designed the circuit for it.

Nando

RE: Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

Hello jophuds .

Capacitors are a great device but unfortunately they don't perform miracles.Your card relays are good for 3 Amps, max 6 amps and your motors draw 11 .You cannot change those conditions.Just to take a page out of Busbar's book ,You cannot get blood out of a Turnip.The best course of action is the use of interposing relays or contactors with high enough current rating to run your motor.Most relays/contactors are probably good for at least 15 amps Inductive.

GusD

RE: Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

(OP)
Thanks GusD,

Can anyone recommend a site or a place where I can learn more about relays and the possibility of using them.

Does anyone know if it is possible to build a circuit that will only involve the use of the relay when the motor is stopped and needs to be restarted ?

Thanks in advance,
joe.

RE: Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

Hi, all you need is a current limiter in the motor cicuit. Cheapest is a resistor, if that degrades the performance too much then a power transitor can be used. look up constant current circuits to find out how to connect it.

RE: Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

Suggestion: Depending on nature of motor control needed, the following might be considered:
1. The output from the controller could be connected into the input of a suitable amplifier. There is a variety of amplifiers with various characteristics.
2. If the motor control is simple, e.g on/off, the controller amplification might be implemented via a suitable contactor, e.g. solid state contactor or relay.

RE: Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

(OP)
jbartos,

I am concerned about the use of a relay as the motor must be able to accelerate and have differenct velocities. My understanding of a relay indicates that it can only be on or off -- is this correct ??

If possible could you detail more about the use of an ampflier and state any possible pitfalls with this method.

Thanks in advance,
joe

RE: Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

Comment:
1. On/Off amplification of the I/O control card is implemented over a suitably sized contactor or relay that would be rated for the maximum 11A with some design margin added. I/O card output controls the contactor or relay coil. Contactor or relay contacts control the input from a suitable power supply controlling the motor.
2. The amplifier approach is more flexible since the I/O card output is possible to adjust, thus implementing the variable input to the motor control over the amplifier output controlling the power to the motor.
Visit
http://www.aveox.com/lcbmc.html
etc. for more info on the amplifier

RE: Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

Yes, I think I misunderstood your setup.  I thought that the power supply was limiting your current, not electronic switch capability.  Even in that case there would be a problem with inrush to the cap upon power-up.

RE: Supression the initial current drawn by a motor

Hello jophuds  
It sounds to me as though you are using a card that is designed to control the voltage applied to the motor, probably using a PWM technique, rather than an OFF/ON switching arrangement. If this is the case, then you should try to program it to apply a ramp up in voltage rather than a step to full voltage. This will allow the motor to accelerate to full speed more gradually and will reduce the "starting" current.
Best regards,

Mark Empson
http://www.lmphotonics.com

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources