×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Air Compressor Burning Up!!

Air Compressor Burning Up!!

Air Compressor Burning Up!!

(OP)
I have an application where an air compressor frequently needs replaced.  It seems that it runs constantly, never catching up with itself.  My first opinion was that the motor was too small.  However, our HVAC service guy says that the air tank is too small.  

I do not have too much experience in air flow systems, has anyone else encountered this problem?  If so, which way should I go (bigger motor or bigger tank?)  I'll post the specifics is anyone is interested.

Thanks, guys!

RE: Air Compressor Burning Up!!

Perhaps the bigger compressor. Give us the details.

Regards,

RE: Air Compressor Burning Up!!

(OP)
Okay, Here's the Spec's!

1.5 hp oil-less 4 clynder motor - rated at ~7 CFM for 60 psi
30 gallon tank

Line Feed (consumption) = 1 CFM

It does seem like I actually have some over-kill on the motor size, doesn't it?

RE: Air Compressor Burning Up!!

What is the compressed air used for?
Can you verify that 1 cfm is the actual consumption?

RE: Air Compressor Burning Up!!

Your tank is about 4 cubic feet volume.
With 1 cfm diverted for consumption, 6 cfm is pumped into tank, and it will work about 40 minutes to pump 4 cu ft.
Than it will rest no more than 4 minutes (obviously less than 4 minutes, to keep pressure).
Increasing compressor size will never give you more than 4 minutes off time (this is the time of 1 cfm consumption to empty the tank).
Increasing your tank will increase off time almost linear. Knowing the compressor'sdesign duty cycle you can calculate the optimal tank volume.
For example, by adding a 60 gallons tank the compressor will run 2 minutes to pump 90 gallons and will rest about 10 minute. With 120 gallons tank it will be <3 min on and ~15 min off.

RE: Air Compressor Burning Up!!

Generally you should not have any problems with your system provided your 1 cfm consumption is SCFM.

Motor is properly sized. The calculation goes like this.

for adiabatic compression

BHP = (4.36/1000)[k/(k-1)](cfm)(P1)[(P2/P1)(k-1/k)-1]

Where k = ratio of specific heats and for air it is 1.4
P1 = initial pressure in psi (atmospheric 14.7)
P2 = final pressure abs = 74.7 psi
cfm = 7 (scfm)
therefore, BHP = (4.36/1000)(1.4/0.4)(7)(14.7)((74.7/14.7)(0.4/1.4)-1) = 0.928

Considering 80% motor efficiency and 80% compressor efficiency IP = 1.45 HP, so motor is well sized.

A thumb rule for receiver sizing

Receiver capacity in gallons = compressor capacity in cfm. So you generally don't have problems until an unless you have some equipment which require more air for short span of time. You should tell us your load pattern and equipment.

1 cfm is SCFM (14.7 psi and 60 deg.f) or ACFM (at 60 psi g)

Do the following checks.

1. Shut off receiver outlet valve and start compressor. Check whether compressor unloads (or stops)in about 35 to 40 seconds.
2. After filling receiver, stop the compressor, open air outlet valve, operate the machine(s) and check rate of pressure drop. This will give you an idea about your consumption.
3. Check for proper operation of pressure switch. (sometimes it may malfunction)
4. Clean the suction filter.
5. If the compressor is loading and unloading type check for proper operation.
6. Clean the suction valves of compressor. If dust accumulates on seat and control plate, discharged air will be bypassed to suction.

Regards,

RE: Air Compressor Burning Up!!

(OP)
Thanks for the help, guys!  I will put a new tank online.  Quark, I wish I could give you the load pattern, but the compressor on it right now is burned up, and I did not know much about this application until it broke (typical, right?).  All I know is that the compressed air is used in conjunction with an ozone system. As for the 1 cfm air consumption, I am not completely confident that's the true useage of the application . . . that is what the machine manual specified.  As soon as I get the new compressor online, I will run the checks about and monitor the pressure drop.

Thanks again!   

RE: Air Compressor Burning Up!!

Air Compressor sizing is dependant on the # of permissable starts/hour and the duty cycle of the compressor.  Duty cycle or run time is directly linked to consumption or load (pressure,Displacement,RPM).  The lower the RPM the better.  Air cooled, oil lubed compressors should not exced a 33% duty cycle.  Any greater duty cycle cuases overheating and promotes oil carry-over.  Oiless compressors can have have varing Duty cycles based on ring and bearing quality, anywhere from 10-75%.  # of permissable Starts/hour is mostly motor dependant, single phase and smaller compressors (1/3 thru 2hp) 4/hr, three phase and medium sized (2.5-4hp) 6/hr, 5 and up call the rep, are general rules of thumb.  To minize starts/hour and the wear that is produced, get a bigger tank, the differance in a 120 vs a 200 gallon tank is around $100.  Adding a tank has the same effect and may be less of a installation issue.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources