×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Lethal Service Criteria
3

Lethal Service Criteria

Lethal Service Criteria

(OP)
I am designing a vessel that is supposed to collect (by gravity) condensate containing about 38 ppm of H2S.  Once collected, this condensate will be displaced from the vessel to the flare using Nitrogen at 100 psi.

Would you consider this vessel to be on lethal service?

Thanks for your help.

Susana.


Ps: UW-2 defines a lethal substance as poisonous gases or liquids of such a nature that a very small amount of the gas or of the vapor of the liquid mixed or unmixed with air is dangerous to life when inhaled.

15 ppm of Hydrogen-sulfide(H2S)is the allowable exposure limit for 15 minutes according to SHE standards.

Please excuse my Engligh... it´s not very good.

RE: Lethal Service Criteria

Think you have answered your own question. I would prefer not to be exposed to this.

RE: Lethal Service Criteria

I can't say I have any experience with H2S but I do have a little with other lethal service chemicals and there may not be a simple answer to your question.

Look again at the UW-2 definition.  I think what you need to consider is the equilibrium concentration of H2S in the vapor above the liquid at the temperature of the condensate.  That would be the H2S in the "vapor" that might leak from the vessel.  Then what happens to the liquid if it were to leak?  Would it flash?

However, you may also need to consider single failure modes from upstream sources that might cause the vessel contents to be much different than you have indicated.

Having a full understanding of the chemical characteristics (odor, color) and physiological effects is also important.  Probably good to get an Industrial Hygienist involved.

For these reasons I believe it is up to you, the user to define whether lethal service is required.  Of course it would be interesting to hear if anyone has any experience directly related to the concentrations you've indicated.

I would wonder if the equipment upstream of your new collection drum is designated lethal service and whether there is already a lethal service definition for H2S at your facility.  Of course this is something you should already know.

It may be more appropriate to ask how to determine when to designate lethal service rather than does the indicated concentrations require lethal service.  Does anyone know of an established methodology for determining the need for lethal service?

RE: Lethal Service Criteria

The company you are designing for and local regulations may dictate your answer.  I work in a plant that has pressure >5000kPa total pressure with over 30% H2S and nothing is considered in lethal service.

RE: Lethal Service Criteria

Susana-

I do have experience with hydrogen sulfide - in fact, I'm wearing my H2S monitor right now. We're required to have a monitor clipped to our overalls or hard hat anytime we're out and about in the operating units.

I would not define 38 ppm H2S as lethal. Getting into the 300 ppm range would be - and officially you should consider 100 ppm as the basis for your decision. That value is once you have lost containment and it is spewing out into the atmosphere. Take a look at Thread794-22012, "Defining Lethal Service" at

Thread794-22012 Ok, how do you link directly to another post?

RE: Lethal Service Criteria

Hmmm... you just type in the thread and the site automatically creates the link... So easy even I can handle it!

jt

RE: Lethal Service Criteria

jte - the thread you referenced above didn't seem to have much there but it did make reference to another that seemed to have some good discussion.  Looks like this has been a topic of discussion several times before.  Here's a couple more from the past.

Thread124-23360
Thread794-17433

I found the post by TD2K dated Feb-23-2002 in the last thread noted above especially interesting in regards to the footnote in previous editions of the CASTI guidebook which gave examples of chemicals considered lethal (hydrocyanic acid, carbonyl chloride, cyanogen, mustard gas and xylyl bromide) and those not considered lethal (chlorine, ammonia, plus others).

Though RTP-1 may not constitute a pressure vessel since it is intended for pressures <15psig, it lists a service restriction referred to as "critical service" which one of the criteria sounds a lot like "lethal service".  I mention this only because I wonder if such criteria would be reasonable to apply to the lethal service definition.  Maybe this is why I've seen chlorine vaporizers and vessels in ammonia refrigeration systems not designated lethal service.

From RTP-1 1989, 1-210 Service Restrictions
"substance contained is known by the User to be an insidious and extremely poisonous gas or liquid of such a nature that a very small amount of the gas or of the vapor of the liquid mixed or unmixed with air is dangerous to life when inhaled, or of such a nature that a very small amount of the substance in contact with the body may be absorbed and cause a toxic reaction that is dangerous to life.  By insidious is meant the substance is of such a nature that exposure to the substance might result in a discomfort level not sufficient to warn of potential severe and irreversible damage to an individual's health."

RE: Lethal Service Criteria

HI SZOGHBI,
you may also have to look up NACE MR 01-75, dealing with other impacts(metallurgical) of H2S, and how to determine the concentration as effective or insignificant.There's also limits on the type of metal as well as the heat treatments/hardness of your shell material to contain H2S.
Finally, I agree with deanc in that you have much to consider - and do take your time !
hope you'll find it usefull .

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources