×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Underpowered VFD....will it work?

Underpowered VFD....will it work?

Underpowered VFD....will it work?

(OP)
I have a 100HP/460V synchronous motor sitting in the back of my shop along with a 40HP/460V VFD.  I am hoping to hook the two parts together.  The motor will be very lightly loaded with a gear box.  The only thing I am concerned about is actually starting from 0RPM (kind of like a locked rotor situation).  Am I going to be able to start this motor or will I need a pull-start (just kidding of course)?

RE: Underpowered VFD....will it work?

In simple terms, you ain't gonna start a 100HP motor with a 40HP VFD.  So, get your starter rope ready, and hope you don't blow the rectifiers out of the VFD.

RE: Underpowered VFD....will it work?

I'm not all that familiar with vfd's, but I was under the impression that starting duty was mild since the frequency is slowly increased.  Couldn't any starting problems be overcome but programming a slower start?  

RE: Underpowered VFD....will it work?

I would think an unloaded motor could be started and run without overloading the VFD.  The VFD will current limit and shut down if it's overloaded, so I don't think you'll destroy anything.  

RE: Underpowered VFD....will it work?

(OP)
All decent VFDs have current limiting to ensure that the inverter doesn't blow itself up, therefore I am not worried about blowing any rectifiers up either(as per dpc's comment).

Most VFDs are rated for a temporary starting overload of 200% of rated.  This is for start-up since it resembles a locked-rotor condition.  I am not worried about anything but the start-up.

I will most definitely work with your suggestion "electricpete", but I am still unsure as to whether I will be able to get that rotor moving.

Any other comments?

RE: Underpowered VFD....will it work?

I would say try it.  Incidentally there is a good free NEMA application guide available on VFDs (previously posted by electricpete - thanks):

http://208.156.24.64/index_nema.cfm/1427/0DDF742A-8790-4A21-88D139CFC069648B/

- read in particular the comment on locked rotor current in section 4.2.2 (actually referring to design A motors but applicable here I think).  With VFD operation the motor is always operating on the final slope of the conventional 60HZ DOL torque-speed curve, regardless of actual motor speed.  So the DOL starting current doesn't apply.

RE: Underpowered VFD....will it work?

I would say that it is borderline.  We had a 40HP motor (2 pole) that we wanted to run at 4pole speed (pump load would've been 5HP), but our 10HP drive wouldn't do it.  We had to get a 20HP drive to run the test.  Where the line is between the two, I don't know (as in 50% of motor size???).

RE: Underpowered VFD....will it work?

pamcinto, programming a 'soft-start' may take care of the inrush starting current problem, but I would be more concerned that a VFD rated for 40HP may not be able to handle the continuous load of a 100HP motor, even if it is lightly loaded. I know that you stated that "The only thing I am concerned about is actually starting from 0RPM (kind of like a locked rotor situation)", but I would recommend checking what the maximum continuous current rating of the VFD is, and comparing that to the maximum continuous current that you expect to draw from it for the motor. You may find out that a lightly loaded 100HP motor may draw more current than the FLA of a 40HP motor.

RE: Underpowered VFD....will it work?

Suggestion: Contact the VFD manufacturer tech support for any recommendations.

RE: Underpowered VFD....will it work?

Hi Pamcinto

No reason why you can't run your 100 hp Sync motor  on a 40 hp VFD.the VFD will give you the soft start you need.
As you mention, it will be lightly loaded, and the VFD current limits will let you know when you have exceeded it.
You say that the Sync will be driving a gearbox,but you don't mention what is the gearbosx doing.
Don't forget that you can start the Sync,but  the Sync will be using nearly 40 hp just iddling.
It will have to be a very light load indeed.

Good luck  

GusD

RE: Underpowered VFD....will it work?

Perhaps not directly related, but where is the VFD overload protection located and is there duplicates. I mean, on the output to the motor and on the dc bus side also?

RE: Underpowered VFD....will it work?

Suggestion: The VFD overload protection is on the VFD input side and motor overload protection is on the VFD output side.

RE: Underpowered VFD....will it work?

Are you in a position to connect the motor in a 6 wire (inside Delta) connection? This enables a softstarter of approx. 1/2 the value of the motor current to safely start the motor. This causes the starter to only handle the phase current which is less than line current. Note that the soft starter must be capable of operation in the 6 wire connection format. 6 wire connection of non 6 wire connection softstarter will result in major damage to the softstart. Consult the manufacturer of the softstart to see if this is possible.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources