When to use hot dipped galvanized piping
When to use hot dipped galvanized piping
(OP)
When should you use the hot dipped galvanized piping for sprinkler systems. Why would you use this over standard black piping?
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS Come Join Us!Are you an
Engineering professional? Join Eng-Tips Forums!
*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail. Posting GuidelinesJobs |
When to use hot dipped galvanized piping
|
When to use hot dipped galvanized pipingWhen to use hot dipped galvanized piping(OP)
When should you use the hot dipped galvanized piping for sprinkler systems. Why would you use this over standard black piping?
Red Flag SubmittedThank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts. Reply To This ThreadPosting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members! |
ResourcesWhat is rapid injection molding? For engineers working with tight product design timelines, rapid injection molding can be a critical tool for prototyping and testing functional models. Download Now
The world has changed considerably since the 1980s, when CAD first started displacing drafting tables. Download Now
Prototyping has always been a critical part of product development. Download Now
As the cloud is increasingly adopted for product development, questions remain as to just how cloud software tools compare to on-premise solutions. Download Now
|
RE: When to use hot dipped galvanized piping
RE: When to use hot dipped galvanized piping
RE: When to use hot dipped galvanized piping
First and foremost, lets address what hot-dipped galvanized pipe is and how it is applied - especially for sprinkler systems.
Most, if not all, downstream sprinkler applications are screwed fitting joints. Galvanization, by common sense, is thoroughly removed when the pipe is threaded! There is no way to protect this area again with additional galvanization. It is forever doomed to a short, corroded life in the application it finds itself in (if the static water it contains is corrosive in the first place). Many young engineers don't analyze what they are applying or spend time studying the skills and application at hand. This leads to false dreams or anticipations about what results will be. Practical, experienced engineers will testify that galvanized pipe is for PLUMBERS - not for serious pipefitters in a process plant application. Plumbers LOVE galvanized pipe; the more they install, the more they will come back to replace. It's called job security.
In other words, galvanized pipe inherently has the weakness of having it's threaded section totally exposed to corrosion and thereby is weakened by this. Black iron or cast iron pipe many times is more effective - depending on the fluid and the application. I would not apply galvanized piping to serious Fire Sprinkler applications where I was not going to routinely inspect and monitor pipe integrity - and this costs money and time.
Think about it. If you are trying to protect a steel pipe by galvanizing it, isn't this a statement that you know you have inherently weak steel pipe that you must protect? And if you have an "Achille's Heel" (a breech in the galvanized coating) because you have forcefully removed the protective coating due to the installation need, what can you expect? I don't trust such a scenario.
I hope this experience helps.
Art Montemayor
RE: When to use hot dipped galvanized piping
RE: When to use hot dipped galvanized piping
Static water is more corrosive that flowing water.
The galvanized pipe will work. That's not a problem; the problem is that future corrosion which will take place in the unprotected joints - that's a fact; no one can tell or predict when this will come to a head.
You originally stated that this was "hot-dipped" galvanized piping. This is expensive stuff because of the intensive manual input and the environmental restrictions. You may only have electrolytic or "sprayed" galvanization - which is another, much cheaper and ineffective protection.
As I said before, galvanized piping is the product of choice if we are talking about plumbers or commercial contractors. It's a logical decision on their part. We engineers, however, have to look at the long-term effects and costs. But, to go directly to your present situation, the galvanized pipe will work. My decision would be not to accept it unless it formed part of the original job specifications - but that's easy for me to say because I'm not in the hot seat like you are now. I suggest you make a documented memo,noting the pipe specifications and request a reason for its selection from the contractor while advising the owner/operator of what you have found and reported. This way, you have documented the suspicious spec and responsibly advised the owner and the contractor of your opinion on the spec.
Good Luck.
Art Montemayor
RE: When to use hot dipped galvanized piping
the biggest problem with steel, galvanised or not , is the life expectancy in water service. In many installations this is no greater than 8 years. I have seen it fail in 9 months. If the corrosion inhibitors are used correctly and your system is well maintained it will work. Sadly this is a thing of the past.
Do NFPA codes allow the use of galvanised steel? Will the insurer sign off on it? have you considered cPVC?
Sharing knowledge is a way to immortality
RE: When to use hot dipped galvanized piping
We always specify hot dipped, if you spray on a coating that later flakes off and plugs up any spray nozzles, you could have a problem...