×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

(OP)
I've seen one in person, but at the time I wasn't interested enough to check it out.
I'm curious is to if anyne has any experience with this? If so was it done with the stock components or did it require extensive modifications? Basically I'm looking to convert a port injection engine into a diresct injection, but I have no idea where to even begin looking for this info... Yes I'm aware of the problems that occur from high sulfur contents of pump-gas. That's why I plan on running something like an alcohol.

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

I'm sorry, but your post makes absolutely no sense.

Franz

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

(OP)
Sorry, I was up a little late so I probably wasn't making much sense even to myself.

I've seen a gasoline engine converted to a diesel with a fuel injector installed where the spark plug belongs normally. I was curious if anyone knew anything about this. I'm looking to do this conversion with a Honda engine, but instead of using diesel for fuel I will be using alcohol if at all possible. Opinion's on whether this is a accomplishable task, or not is always appreciated.

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Diesels are typically much heavier than the same size gas engine to withstand the relatively higher compression ratios and firing impulses aka, the converted gas engine will fail quickly, ala the ill fated Olds/GM 350 CID conversion of the '70's.  Unless your goal is to deplete your bank account as quickly as possible, while walking to the parts store frequently, my advice is to find another project.

Blacksmith

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

I think the Blacksmith has not properly understood the problem. If I am right, you are trying to convert a gasoline engine to an alcohol engine without altering the compression ratio. So, there is no question of higher cylinder pressures causing engine damage in this case.

However, where I see this modified engine fail, is in the area of mixture formation. This is of course assuming that you would be using a stratified mode of mixture generation, which would be advantageous with regard to throttling losses. To accomplish proper mixture formation, you would require extensive revamping of the piston and combustion chamber shape.

Also, alcohol would require a different fuel metering system, due to its lower calorific value. Another thing you have to keep in mind is that alcohol has poor ignition performance and you have to ignite it with a spark plug afterall. So, you will be unable to simply replace the spark plug with injector.

Therefore, though I would not recommend it if you are short on time, it would be a good acomplishment if you do manage to do it. All the best!!

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

vinodkarthik,

Uh, if he screws an injector into the spark plug hole, where does he screw in--ah, never mind.

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

I guess the title Gasoline to Diesel confused me.

If you want to burn alcohol, just fill 'er up and adjust the current injection system (injector size and/or pressure and/or program) to inject enough alcohol to account for lower BTU value.

If you want direct injection, figure out how to fit the injector into the head along with the current intake valve, exhaust valve, and spark plug.

If you really want a diesel cycle aka compression ignition with engine power and speed controlled by the quantity and timing of fuel injected into the cylinder, I stand by my first post.

Blacksmith

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Actually, I think we are reading the post incorrectly.  He states "Gasoline to Diesel" conversion.  The diesel cycle does not use spark plugs but compression generated heat to ignite the air and fuel mixture.  You cannot use alcohol as a diesel cycle fuel.  Also, I think you did see the Olds diesel fiasco, it was a dismal failure.

Blacksmith is correct in his first reply, along with Metalguy.  How deep are your pockets?  Its easier to use alcohol as a spark ignited fuel engine, them adapt the injection curve to suit the particular fuel.  Also, alcohols are corrosive to certain engine components which is why it has not caught on in big numbers.  Stainless steel pumps, lines, tanks, injector bodies, fuel rails, and so on.

Franz

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

The important problem with using alcohol in the Diesel cycle is the very low cetane rating of alcohol fuel.
That is, it is very resistant to compression ignition.
The Brazilian government has sponsored a greaty deal of research into using alcohol in Diesel-cycle engines, as any web search will turn up,  and they have concluded that, for straight alcohol, "Research has demonstrated that it is not possible to establish this substitution program in diesel cycle engines."
They have run blended fuels with alcohol contents as high as 11%,  but they point out there are safety concerns in the storage of such blends due to their having a significantly higher vapor pressure than does straight Diesel.

Finally,  no discussion of dismal failures among "converted" SI engines would be complete without mention of the VW Rabbit Diesel of the '70's.

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

(OP)
Thanks that's the info I was looking for. I was trying to figure out how to ignite the mixture, but I couldn't without some drastic reshaping of the head, and accompanying materials. I wanted to use this in a racing situation where 1/4mi blasts are all that would be ran, but I guess I have to get a custom head made to do this.

Sidenote ~ This was an effort to maximize the fueling quality entering the cylinder, and to help improve the ratios on a turbo application for highest mean output. Sorry for the confusion, but I figured that the title would be a hint at what I was trying to get at.

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

TZSir, it surely would have helped us if you had taken the time to post your last in the FIRST place!!!!!!!
As it stands, I will stick with Franz's first post as being the DEFINITIVE of this thread.  I think in future threads a bit of forethought would be greatly appreciated by the very knowledgable engineers that have taken their time to try to decript your posts.

Rod

PS   I vote to give your star, Blacksmith, to FH.  

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

(OP)
Sorry I don't speak English very well so I don't really know how to say things clearly the first time. I knew what I wanted to say, but it didn't come out right at all. Being tired doesn't help either. Yes there are some very knowledgable engineers here, and I hope I can learn as well as contribute to this forum.

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Your English is orders of magnitude better than my Italian, so don't sweat it.  You're doing great.  Most of us here just need things spelled out real simple!

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Your English is just fine but most of us "get the hint" only when it is accompanied by a "sharp rap with a hammer"!
I ment no disrespect in my last post even though it does look rather severe when you see it in print.

Rod

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Rod -

"Sharp rap with a hammer" - are you setting the timing on the BBC motorhome again without a distributor wrench?

  Blacksmith

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

I am sooooooooooooooo offended!

Rod   me after a 1st place Sunday and enjoying our 85 degree weather. Na, na, na na na!

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Well, Connie Grats!

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

This is kind of a funny thread...  :)  I actually worked for a company that did just this thing...  We started with a Subaru 3 liter, 6 cylinder gasoline engine and converted it to run on JP-5, or kerosene.  We used a relatively low compression ratio (13.7:1), along with a EFI diesel injector in the spark plug hole.  The cylinder head was a pent roof type so fuel/air mixing was pretty bad and therefore power output was down (~100 HP for the engine).

As for controlling cylinder pressure (90 bar max for engine), it is amazing what a pilot injection (a small squirt of fuel before the main injection) will do for you...  

Kevin

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Here's my nomination for "silliest thread of the year".

Is there ANY competition?

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Ok, I don't know about these fiascos, so could you tell me what is the weak link in a gas engine being converted to diesel. I'm not planning to run it on diesel, I'm just considering using a diesel-like compression ratio while experimenting with other fuels like various blends, hydrogen etc. Dont some racing engines (turbo, blown) have similar effective compression ratio as diesels? What would have to be upgraded?

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

I've been under the impression that Diesel engines are manufactured to closer tolerances and with thicker cylinder walls to account for the higher compression ratios, which is what makes them so much more expensive than gasoline engines. I'd imagine that racing engines are the same.

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

I don't know if it is relevent to the thread but for what it's worth we run a 351 cu/in v8 on straight alky thru a carb and  11 to 1 cr.
A sprint car racing class runs alky 410 cu/in engines on fuel injection in the intake feed tubes as well as injectors direct into the chambers.
In our case we make in excess of 500 hp with carburation and the FI cars are all above 800 hp.  The FI 410s are well above 11 to 1 cr.
None of this comes even close to being a diesel type operation.
There are a nunber of different types of engine configurations for diesel use. All have high compression ratios.
I am most familuar with the old GM 4/71 and 6/71 industrial engines.  These had blowers that forced air into the cylinders when the piston uncovered ports around the cylinder then exhausted out a standard valve like a gas engine.

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Injectors direct into the chambers? You mean they are direct injected? Thats interesting, how did you do that, I've seen various solutions like modifiying heads, injection through spark plug hole etc.

I planned to run this engine with as close tolerance parts as I can get, just the cylinder wall's are pretty thin. I was thinking about some liners or sleeves...

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

As far as I know, sprint cars use "down nozzles" in the port or manifold near the port. They are shaped so as to be quite close to the inlet valve, and inject directly onto the back of the valve.

Regards
pat   pprimmer@acay.com.au
eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

They do use both injections at the same time.

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

It would be no problem building up something like a 350 sbc engine with the required compression ratio to run on diesel. 14 or 16 to 1 will do it. And there are many of those engines with that ratio running races. The angle of the injector would be a problem with a DI system. And it would be an unknown how long the structure would take the higher peak pressures of diesel operation. Unlike the standard gasoline engine the naturaly aspirated diesel engine has close to atmospheric inlet pressure most all the time, except of course considering highspeed flow restrictions. I think all will agree it would work. But for how long?  

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

icrman, based on my experience with my neighbors GMC PU with the Olds type diesel engine (late 70's, I think) I would venture that ~80,000 miles would be about the limit.  My bosses Oldsmobile diesel only made it beyond that because it had constant and continuous maintenance.  We towed it in, uuummm, maybe once a MONTH!!!!  Hey, he was the boss and who was to argue with him? (That may be a SLIGHT exageration).

Rod

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

I recall seeing a "reconversion" kit for those Olds gas to diesel engines 5 or 6 years ago.Yes, you could convert it "back" to gas.

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Rob45

Actually the Rabbit diesel was a excellent diesel engine for the vintage, and has developed over the years (using the same basic design and architecture) into the current TDI which is probably the nicest automobile diesel in the world.  The original ones were certainly not powerful, but they were reliable if maintained properly.  They virtually never had bottom end problems- the block crank and rods were more than up to the task.

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

"They vertually never had bottom end problems-the block crank and rods were more then up to the task".


Funny I saw an awful lot of broken cranks and bad bearings in the first incarnation of the Rabbit diesel in the U.S. It was quite common to convert them to the gasoline version at the time. If I remember correctly, the originals had the crank "snout" break off due to ???.  The original engines were prone to overheat (I do not know the reason) and the cyl heads would crack.  Any damage to the timing belt would result in a broken camshaft (and all that entails).
Granted the problems were solved---eventually.  My son in law will have nothing to do with VW to this day, irrational as that may be.  Some of the later Rabbits I have seen have accumulated some impressive mileage figures in spite of these original difficulties.  At least VW , unlike some domestic auto makers of the era, did not give up on the engines and continued to fix them.
I agree the new engine is super. My son had a 6 speed diesel wagon in Europe for a spell---he ablolutely loved it.
Unfortunately, it's not imported to the U.S. !

Rod



RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Check the restricter plate engines in NASCAR running over 15:1 on gas (static, not effective). CART engines run alcohol but purge the fuel systems after.

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Does anybody remember back in the 70s when you used to turn your engine off, take the key out and it magiclly turned into a diesel and still kept running as you walked away and into the house?

RE: Just curious about Gasoline to Diesel conversions.

Run on, mostly caused by hot spots, and that would make it a glow plug or glow spot engine not a diesel. Gasoline needs way more than 16:1 to autoignite. Its a low cetane fuel.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources