PC based control system
PC based control system
(OP)
I am in the process of automating a small scale limestone processing plant and am looking for a cost effective PC based control system.
There a few I/O's (temperature, pressure, current etc) that I want to be able to monitor, control and historize. However, I have been asked to keep within a tight budget.
I have taken a look at "PANELMATE" which is functional but a bit of an overkill for the application. A section of my design includes the installation of VFD's that will be controlled by any of the parameters listed above.
I am looking for a PLC based system that can communicate serially with a PC with associated analysis software; something that is scalable and functional...
any suggestions?
There a few I/O's (temperature, pressure, current etc) that I want to be able to monitor, control and historize. However, I have been asked to keep within a tight budget.
I have taken a look at "PANELMATE" which is functional but a bit of an overkill for the application. A section of my design includes the installation of VFD's that will be controlled by any of the parameters listed above.
I am looking for a PLC based system that can communicate serially with a PC with associated analysis software; something that is scalable and functional...
any suggestions?





RE: PC based control system
I'm not sure if this is something like you are looking for. I don't want this forum to become a sales pitch so look at the site if you like what you see please contact them for prices. Compared to full SCADA this is low cost.
http://www.slb.com/Hub/index.cfm?id=id1140167&printable=true
Of course this is only one possible option available to you.
Good luck!
RE: PC based control system
I'm a motion control guy, so maybe some of the PLC people here can help more.
Cameron Anderson - Sales & Applications Engineer
Aerotech, Inc. - www.aerotech.com
"Dedicated to the Science of Motion"
RE: PC based control system
RE: PC based control system
Did some research and found wonderware to be a very interesting product. I have spoken to a few users who are surprised by the functionality.
I am in the process of choosing a PLC at this point
RE: PC based control system
http://www2.automationdirect.com/store/Home/Home
Good luck!
RE: PC based control system
How about writing your own control software and doing discrete I/O and analog I/O from the PC? You can write all of your MMI screens in a visual programming language. You can get PC cards, etc. to do field control. You could also use higher level communications protocols to download parameters to drives, etc. using Modbus, RS485, etc.
Just ideas for a shoestring budget.
RE: PC based control system
If you are going to use a PC with a Graphical User Interface anyway, why use a PLC? There are plenty of inexpensive and rugged I/O systems available now that can be controlled directly from the PC, such as Opto-22, Sixnet, Phoenix Contact just to name a few. Go to a search engine and enter SCADA, which is short for Supervisory Control and Data Aquisition. You will get hits on hundreds of suppliers. PLCs have their place as stand-alone controllers, but unless you want the redundancy, having a dedicated PC talking to a PLC is kind of a waste.
Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati
RE: PC based control system
My initial thought was that a PLC would be a bit redundant. However, going the route of writing control software etc seems a bit time consuming and too much of a headache. My last experience with the above was not too memorable.
I guess I am looking for an easy, quick but cheap way out.
It shouldn't hurt to do a bit more research!!!!
RE: PC based control system
However, adding SCADA and remote monitoring does notch up the complexity (and costs) a bit. In this application spending some money may ease the implementaion but will drive costs. It's about what is of most value to you.
RE: PC based control system
Lets change it around a little then. Why do you want the PC? If you want cheap and simple, I then agree with gcaudill because micro PLCs have become very very cheap. If you want an Operator Interface Terminal (OIT) without the need for import/export of data to a higher level program, then check out companies like Total Control Products (TCP), Spectrum Controls, Exor, Maple Systems or a host of others that have low cost color or B&W screens with built-in PLC communication interfaces, some even with touch screens.
Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati
RE: PC based control system
Normally, for a large industrial type installation cost is not an issue. However, this is more of a back yard type plant (business venture) with a total of only a few dozen I/O's.
Being more of a favor for a friend, I do not want to unnecessarilly incur high costs before the venture becomes lucrative. I am still struggling to decide what is actually feasible for the application. I confess that I am trying to accomplish alot for the small scale operation but I wanted to provide some amount of flexibility and functionality.
I guess bottom line I need to consider fundamental needs and develop a solution that satisfies that need.
The primary reason for choosing a PC based system is location. This plant is remotely located and as such remote access would be a nice touch.
There are so many products out there to choose from, so it's a bit difficult to find one that gives the biggest bang for the buck.
RE: PC based control system
What VFDs have you got now?
How many analog I/O?
What kind of expandability do you need?
Keep in mind that free advice from anonymous sources is a dangerous way of engineering a system. This is just a signpost to help you along the way.
Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati
RE: PC based control system
Completely understand your comment about anonymous resources. That can be very dangerous...
My problem is that I am not very used to working with a tight budget. I have implemented many systems and my philosophy was that if you want functionality it should be paid for...
Honestly, seeing the different postings has allowed me to think on different levels..and of alternatives
Your last post is what I had settled on last night. I am going to buy a couple of Control Techniques VFD's (unidrive to be exact) since I have installed several dozen of them!
Currently, I have say 24 analog I/O with the possibility of going up to 64 in the near future.
RE: PC based control system
RE: PC based control system
Do you happen to have a building automation system or security system in place that could take care of your needs?
Do you have any existing Modbus RS485 data gathering devices?
Also, Ethernet-based data gathering devices are becoming more and more prevalent every day. Probably would lose the cost battle, but they might be worth investigating.
RE: PC based control system
took all that into account..but have none of the above
got a budget figure today and have plotted some sort of path for implementation. task now is product hunting!
RE: PC based control system
RE: PC based control system
RE: PC based control system
RE: PC based control system
I was made to eat a couple of my words as it relates to cost and functionality but what the heck it is all about experience and exposure.
Haven't done any programming in while since my primary area of involvement is energy systems but this should be exciting...
Now, with a solution in one hand ("theoretical") and an open mind in the other I will head on over to the PLC forum to see what those guys have to say..
RE: PC based control system
RE: PC based control system
RE: PC based control system
Did you look at the Galil IOC7007? It has Ethernet communication, and you buy the amount and type of I/O needed. $700.00 will get the controller and several I/O modules and it is simple to program.
What price level are you needing?
RE: PC based control system
Good Luck!
RE: PC based control system
http://www.thomasregister.com
and type Automation under Product or Service, which will return various automation categories, e.g.
Automation Systems: Flexible
with 411 companies to contact for a solution that fits your needs. Notice, that you can type directly:
Automation Systems: Flexible under Product or Service to reach those 411 companies.
Some of those businesses mentioned in above postings are in there too with their contact information. Certainly, it would be difficult to mention them all in this Forum, however, as you can see the volunteers certainly provided an excellent start for you.