×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

HVGO Cutpoint/Yield improvement

HVGO Cutpoint/Yield improvement

HVGO Cutpoint/Yield improvement

(OP)
I was wondering what other refineries do to optimize their HVGO cutpoint/yield.  In my refinery the strategy is to always maximize the heater outlet temperature. I have noticed, however, that the actual yield does not necesarily increase with the higher duty/temp and that sometimes maximizing the heater increases the tower vacuum (3-5mmHG).  Can someone tell me how they maximize their HVGO yield?  I think that I may be hurting myself by always maximizing the heater outlet Temp/duty.

RE: HVGO Cutpoint/Yield improvement

You say the vacuum increases on heater increased firing. Do you mean the column absolute pressure increases, and the vacuum drops by 3-5 mm Hg ?

RE: HVGO Cutpoint/Yield improvement

Maximizing the heater outlet temp may increase the cracking in the heater, as a result more noncondensable gases will be produced, these gases will lower your vacuum and as well your HVGO cut, also reduce your unit run time.

In my refinery we try to improve the vacuum in the column, you will get more evaporatoin and deeper cut, improving the vaccum however is a design issue, in your case reducing the noncondensable gases and some operational adjustments may improve the cut.

You did not mension what temp you are using,current cut point and column vacuum, one of them may cause the problem.

RE: HVGO Cutpoint/Yield improvement

Operational-wise...lowering the vacuum in the vacuum tower at constant COT can help to increase the cut-point.
Is the overhead condensers performing? Are there any signs of fouling?

From the design point of view, packed tower generally gives a lower delta P drop. Is it a packed tower you are using?
 

RE: HVGO Cutpoint/Yield improvement

(OP)
The maximum heater outlet temperature is 775F.  Yesterday, we were step-testing the heater and we increased its duty 14% to a 775F heater outlet.  The HVGO yield did not improved and we lost 3-4 mmHg of vacuum (we started at 14.5mmHG and ended up at 18.3mmHg).  However, one of my operators (bless his soul!) increased the bottom liquid quench last night thus decreasing the tower btm temperature from 690F to 676 F.  The tower vacuum then improved by 2 mmHg (current P = 15.98 mmHg). I may add that this is a dry unit and that the ejector system is working as design. The tower has packing.  We can't adjust the ejectors to improve vacuum.  Everyone here is convinced that increasing heater outlet temperature will always increase yield.  I just wish I could prove it in paper!  Any ideas of things we should be doing to proof that our yield is optimized?

RE: HVGO Cutpoint/Yield improvement

The way I see it is you have cracking in the bottom of your column due to the high temp. The cracking increase the noncondensable gasses and the load on the vacuum system.

Our unit is not a dry unit ( we use steam ),but the vacuum we have is 25-27 inHg60F ( if my memory serves me right; with the units that is ). We use a three stage steam ejector system.

IF you can increase the quinch temp or circulation rate there is a chance to improve the vacuum by lowering the cracking rate.

On the vacuum system check if you are in optimal conditions, Ejector systems are constant mass flow not vol. so if you have more overhead products or underperforming washing sections you may overload the system.Do a mass balance on the top section and check the ejector curves.

RE: HVGO Cutpoint/Yield improvement

In an upgrading refinerey "optimizing" HVGO cut-point does not necessarily mean "maximizing" it.

Cutting deeper into the resid mean the marginal bbl of HVGO recovered is much poorer quality than the average quality of the HVGO stream.

The marginal value of this stream needs to be compared with alternative modes of operation of down stream processing units e.g. is it better to increase FCC conversion rather than increasing feed rate using a poor quality feed.

This is a fairly complicated optimization best done by a refinery-wide modelling tool. As well as changing coil outlet temp and quench rate, pumparound and wash oil rates  also affect HVGO yield and quality.

Note that cutting too deep into the resid in a unit that is not designed for it can lead to excessive coking in the column and furnace.

If it "optimum" to maximize HVGO yield then performing a few test runs on the unit a various conditions is usually he best way to confirm the best process conditions.

RE: HVGO Cutpoint/Yield improvement

As repeatedly said above, there is a limit to vacuum "cutting", and sometimes  solvent deasphalting combined with vacuum distillation becomes a better economical option to remove HVGO fractions from vacuum residue.

RE: HVGO Cutpoint/Yield improvement

Having said that, one mustn't forget that companies such as Buss-SMS GmbH, Butzbach, Germany, offer their three-stage vacuum residue short path distillation (VRSD) to markedly improve yields of VGOs, changing the overall refinery economy. See Hydrocarbon Processing July 1993 on Process Technology.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources