×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Decay and Dampening

Decay and Dampening

Decay and Dampening

(OP)
How do you back the damping ratio out of a transient wave measured on an oscilloscope?

RE: Decay and Dampening

You have to measure the exponential decay.

I've forgotten how to do so exactly but basically draw an envelope over the peaks, this gives you the decay curve against time. It should be in any noise and vibration or dynamics text.

Cheers

Greg Locock

RE: Decay and Dampening

Let's say have a waveform exp(-sigma*t)*sin(wd*t)

Hopefully you know how to find wd. It is the radian frequency. If you find the time between zero crossing T, then wd = 2*Pi/T

How to find sigma?

Let's say the waveform decays by ratio K (<1) between two successive peaks (separated in time by t = 2*Pi/wd)

exp(-sigma*2*Pi/wd) =
-sigma*2*Pi/wd = ln (K)
sigma = -ln(K)*wd / (2Pi).

Now you have the info to define the pole zero position at sigma +/- j*wd.

One definition of damping factor is cosin of the angle that the pole makes with the imaginary axis.  That would be cos(sigma)/sqrt(sigma^2+wd^2)

There may be other definitions of damping factor. Let me know your definition and I can tell you how to express it from sigma and wd.

By the way, for lightly damped systems, you can draw the frequency response curve very easily from sigma and wd.  As you know it is a bell shaped curve (for single-degree of freedom single damped mass spring system).  Make your horizontal axis radian frequency. The peak of the curve is wd. The point where the curve drops to 1/sqrt(2) of it's peak is sigma away from wd.  That is called the half-power bandwidth.

RE: Decay and Dampening

There is a dangling equation:
exp(-sigma*2*Pi/wd) =

There should be a K on the right hand side of that equation

RE: Decay and Dampening

"That would be cos(sigma)/sqrt(sigma^2+wd^2)" was incorrect.  It is cos of angle but I don't need cos function when I express it in this form.

The damping factor is (sigma)/sqrt(sigma^2+wd^2)

For lightly damped systems it is approx sigma/wd

RE: Decay and Dampening


Let me go ahead and state the obvious.
From the decaying time graph one can get the amplitudes of the peaks. the logarithmic decrement is given by

logdec delta=ln(Xn/Xn-1)
ln=natural log
Xn,Xn-1= amplitudes of 2 successive peaks.

The llogdec and the damping ratio are related by
logdec = 2*pi*zeta/sqrt(1-zeta^2)
where xeta=damping ratio.

THese are the ones deriuved from electricpete eqns.

RE: Decay and Dampening

Here is an attempt to simplify it:
exp(-sigma*2*Pi/wd) = K
-sigma*2*Pi/wd = ln (K) = logdec
sigma = -logdec*wd / (2Pi).

Zeta = (sigma)/sqrt(sigma^2+wd^2)
        =  -logdec*wd  /  [(2Pi) *sqrt( (logdec*wd / (2Pi))^2+wd^2)]
        = -logdec*wd  /  [wd * sqrt(logdec^2 +  (2PI)^2)]
        = -logdec  /   sqrt(logdec^2 +  (2PI)^2)

For lightly damped systems logdec^2 << 2PI^2
Zeta ~ -logdec / (2Pi)

So you can estimate damping factor zeta from logdec = ln(K) where K is ratio betweeen two sucessive peaks (K<1).  

Even though sigma and wd are not required for the above calculation, sigma and wd are in my view useful parameters in their own right. They give us an estimate of the equation of the time waveform (exp(-sigma*t)*sin(wd*t)) and an estimate of the shape of the spectrum (bell shape centered on wd with half-power bandwidth of sigma).

RE: Decay and Dampening

Hi Tom - do you disagree with
Zeta ~ -logdec / (2Pi)
where "logdec" is ln(k)
k = ratio between two positive peaks

The error in the approximation would be <5% for k>0.2

RE: Decay and Dampening

Electricpete..The approximation has worked out quite well for me in most cases. The fact that Zeta gets squared adds to this.

RE: Decay and Dampening

Update...

rfulky sent me his time history data, in response to my offer.  The data was interesting in that it consisted of several spectral components, which produced a slight beat frequency effect.

I have written a paper and a software program that identifies frequencies and their respective damping ratios for such data.  The paper is called:

A Time Domain, Curve-Fitting Method for Accelerometer Data Analysis

I will be presenting it at the:

AIAA Conference, Session 100 DSC-10, April 10, 2003; Norfolk, Virgina

If you are interested in receiving a copy of the paper, let me know.

Tom Irvine
tomirvine@aol.com
http://www.vibrationdata.com

RE: Decay and Dampening

That's interesting. I think a similar technique was the basis of the MDOF curve fit in SDRC's MPLUS modal analysis suite. The modal parameters (frequency and damping) were done by some sort of successive subtraction on the impulse response. It also extracted the eigenvector at the measurement point, but must have used the FFT to do that, I guess.

I'm sure your paper would have helped me a couple of years back, now I don't get to play with FFTs at all.

Cheers

Greg Locock

RE: Decay and Dampening

We have developed damping identification methods based on analysis of sinusoidal decaym (known as the "Resonant Decay Method"). This uses a combination of force appropriation and least squares regression. The benefit of this approach is that it is able to identify the degree of non-proportional damping coupling between modes. If significant NP damping is present then the concept of a damping ratio is inappplicable.

The danger of fitting any old sinusoidal response decay is that you have no idea which modes are contributing to the decay. It may well give reasonable results for a mode which is not close in frequency to any others, but this is often not the case.

If anybody wants more info the I can send you copies of papers.

M

michael.platten@man.ac.uk

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources