×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

(OP)
Hi
We are developing a machine that involves a mass of the order of 300-400 tonnes suspended on cables.  The mass will be lowered at a constant acceleration of about 0.5g to a maximum velocity of 12m/s.  We need to have a secondary system that is able to trim the velocity of the mass should it exceed the maximum velocity, or to arrest its fall should the acceleration exceed the design value (i.e. if one of the suspension cables fail).

Does anyone have any ideas about how this could be done?  We are thinking about secondary ropes that reel from drums at the top of the shaft and which are monitored and braked if neccessary, or maybe using caliper brakes just like a lift.  Is there anything else that might be suitable, or has this situation been solved somewhere else already?

Any help is greatly appreciated.

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

You could check out the design of safety brakes on elevator systems.  I hear that the Taipei 101 project is using ceramic-shoed brake pads, with velocity in that same range you're looking at.  Good luck!

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

There is a system employed in some elevator systems that involves some sort of clutch... if the elevator falls, and a part of the device begins to spin too fast, drag of some sort is created.
I do not know what exactly the device is, or exactly how it works, but it is something you can checkl into.

Crude idea - if this involves a true potential emergency, one crude back-up might be a parachute.. probably a dumb idea, but it never hurts to think WAY outside the box just to get a new direction.

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

If your mass is not guided by some sort of rails or guides, then I guess that only a secondary system of cables could be used, as you suggest: however this would be difficult to design for a sufficient reliability.
If a guiding system is present, then you could consider the elevator parachutes suggested by others, or a kind of shock absorber (if the falling height is not excessive) or an eddy current brake with permanent magnets: this is used in the free fall towers in amusement parks and its main characteristic is the very high reliability, as it requires no power nor mechanical actuation to perform its action.

prex

http://www.xcalcs.com
Online tools for structural design

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

(OP)
I have done a few more calculations and I think we can get the mass down to about 280Tonnes.  The peak speed will be just under 10m/s and the total stroke about 13m.  This means it will drop the entire distance in about 2.7s.

I think that in the event of the mass accelerating outside the design range (either because of a suspension rope failure or as part of normal operation) the mass does not need to be brought to a halt, but it certainly must be prevented from accelerating any further so that it becomes a controlled descent.  Caliper brakes do seem to be a obvious choice (which could be triggered by an external monitoring system) and provided that they can generate a total reaction equal to the mass times 1g then it should prevent the mass from accelerating further.

However, this machine will operate every 80 seconds and there is a possibility of the weight accelerating outside the design range every time.  I would be worried about heat build up/premature wear that a normal caliper brake would have to endure and so I am wondering if there is any other system/material that might be able to generate such high reactions quickly and repeatedly without problems.

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

This might come across as a stupid idea because of the mass and stroke involved but how about some form of air or hydraulic damper? A piston or series of pistons with sized orifices.

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

Is the acceleration important? If you really can't accept more than 0.5 g then you need a counterbalance of half the mass, or some fancy leveraged smaller inertia.

To limit the velocity reliably I'd look at Hush's idea.

Probably we'd all be a bit less vague if we had some idea of what you were trying to do.

Cheers

Greg Locock

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

I would apply secondary independent hydraulic energy absorbing sistem (washers with precise calibrated holes)
This sistem must be mounted on separated bases and joined
to heavy weight(Cables) with two degree of fredom.

 

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

(OP)
The mass would form part of an amusement device - a giant catapult - with the rope from the mass passing through a pulley system to the accelerate another part of the device.  At the end of the stroke the mass needs to be decelerated and stopped relatively quickly.  We have looked at eddy current brakes (too many needed) and now we are concentrating on an air piston arrangement and hydraulic buffers.  I think that trying to 'trim' the acceleration of the mass during the stroke is not really practical so we will deal with the excess speed that will be generated at the vehicle in another way.

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

Most the suggestions, thus far, involve vertical constraints.  The following might sound strange, but how about a "TOOBS" or Try-an-Out-Of-the-Box-Solution {always wanted to say that}?  Best analogy I can give is that of falling tree or falling dominos (or is it domini) in a chain, but in reverse.

Think of a column, of suitable mass, free to rotate about its base and somehow connected to the falling mass.  I'll leave the somehow part to you.  Now you have the kinetic energy of a rotating mass, controlling the rate of decent of a falling one.

BTW, if you aren't aware, O-O-B is the latest buzz word in "Problem Solving!"  I added the 'T' and 'S' bits!

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

Dynamic braking is a possible solution if you decide on an arrangement of a cable and drum system.  Modern elevator technology uses dynamic braking to slow descents and ascents before reaching  designated landings.  Brakes then are energyzed to hold elevator cabs in place.  Elevators have flyball governors that will engage emergency brakes and may not be practical if the braking system is used over and over.

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

RobertCasey,

I meant to say a column pivoted, not rotated, at its base, like a felled tree, only it can be initially positioned anywhere in its 360 deg range of motion, i.e., +Y, -Y +X, or -X, and 0,0 is the pivot point!

Now, go out and amuse!

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

I don't if this will be of help but I've done something similar on a much smaller scale (1 tonne out of balance on a 7 tonne counterweighted vertical door). I assume you have rope drum driven by a brakemotor and gearbox arrangement to lift this beast. On the "down" cycle, try back driving the suitably efficent/inefficent gearbox and sticking a hydraulic gearpump on the back of the drive motor. Use a one way valve so hydraulic circuit is only effective during lowering cycle. In "down" cycle pump fluid thru a circuit of course and fine control needle valves (switch between course and fine control mechanically, say travelling nut on lead screw chain driven off drum shaft to actuate a change over valve). In my case this was the primary system of decent control and had to work in power fail conditions (fire safety curtain), so may be you need a governed system before your system kicks in. Depending on your duty cycle you may also need a heat exchanger (or very large oil reservoir) and watch for pump cavitation.

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

Hi,
After two weeks, I would like to add an idea,
What about using a motor and a regenerative variable frecuency drive to absorbe the energy in the system. In that way, you can give back to the electrical circuit the energy to be disipated, and you can control the amount of torque to be used and thus the tension on the steel rope. I have not done the numbers on the economical meaning of the electricity, but it sounds like an interesting idea. Another posibility is to use the energy to move a big blower, since the blower will have a cubic law against speed, it will achieve equilibrium with your falling system at some point (with some calculations, not so fast, I expect)
sancat

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

If you made the guide rectangular and the guide hole for the mass to match you could use two spring loaded channel beams made so that upon emergency application the spring pressure would force the two beams apart and through friction stop your load, high phosphorus cast iron shoes are used on rail systems against steel rail with good service life. You could use any method of collapsing the two rails together to allow the load freedom of movement.

Think of the spreading opposing rails used on other amusement park rides such as roller coasters used to retard car movemement as an example.

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

(OP)
Thanks for all your suggestions - some very interesting ideas.  The problem with such a huge mass was that all the ropes/drums/sheaves/governers/motors etc that are needed are huge and are all heavily contributing to the inertia of the system.  The retarding forces needed to trim the acceleration/speed of the system were so large that we were worried about heat build up, shock loading and wear on any component that would be used so frequently.  Therefore we have managed to reduce the mass down to a "reasonable" 250T and have abandoned trying to control the speed - that will be done directly to the train after the launch.  If the cables break then we have managed to find some powerful caliper brakes that will at least prevent the mass from accelerating away (the high phosphorous brakes suggested by FourJawChuck were interesting), and we have spoken to a company who say that they can supply hydraulic buffers to catch the weight at the end of every stroke.  So, I think we have just about got to a solution.  Of course if anyone else can add anything, I am still open to suggestions.

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

Robert,

Is there a relation between your project and the new thrill ride "the Sky Swatter" in Utah, mentioned in the April issue of "Popular Mechanics?"

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

(OP)
No.  That ride was designed and built in the US by S&S.  We are based in Europe.

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

This is just 'Food For Thought' but have a look at how they raised the Kursk Russian submarine. They employed hydraulic pistons under the pulley wheels, this avoided shock loading due to the wave motion on the ship etc. Seems to be over elaborate for your application but a neat bit of lifting all the same.

Cheers

Speedy

"Tell a man there are 300 billion stars in the universe and he'll believe you. Tell him a bench has wet paint on it and he'll have to touch to be sure."

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

Robert-
I just came upon this thread in searching for something else. I have worked with a few different water brakes in the distant past. Basically these are a paddle wheel or tubine wheel arrangement immersed in a tub of water of glycol and connected to a cable or tape reel. Very repeatable, very reliable and fairly low maintenance. I've seen them used in oil rigs for exactly your application and also military applications (which is my experience).  These might be adaptable to your project.  If you are still looking for ideas, I might have some for you. Write back if you do.
TC7

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

i also have marine and oil rig experience. We use Baylor electric inertia brakes on the Drawworks hoist to arrest loads up to 600 tons. VFD drives with regenerative braking are now in vogue.EATON multi disc drag brakes are also now in use, these require water cooling. The water type brake went out of fashion many years ago but was reliable if primitive, it is in design a reverse torque converter.
  To control speed descent, take a look at the lifeboat lowering systems which use a centrifugal brake pad arrangement to control lowering speed, the disadvantage here would be the high heat loads generated.

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

Could always follow the Pyramid Builders lead, and use sand jacks in support.  Cheap and cheerful, no moving parts, all you have to do is work out the flow orifice size.

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

I, too, was thinking along the lines of "sancat" -- there is a similar ride in the US designed and built in Europe (in Ohio?) which uses a number of VFD's (regenerative motor loads) and PLC's to control the hugh mass as it swings... as I recall the VFD's were all ABB -- you might visit with them and other large VFD mfg. for guidance or suggestions..

if there is an opportunity in it for them, they'll be more than glad to assist you..

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

Check out www.airflex.com which is the site for Eaton Industries brake components. These brakes can hold up to 1000 tons no problem, they are air operated and are air or water cooled. Used on offshore rigs for Drawworks braking and Anchor chain braking. It is a drag type to correct the rate of descent by means of air pressure control on the disc pads.

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

(OP)
Thanks for all the ideas - they are very welcome!  The project has been delayed for a couple of years but is still going ahead so the pressure is off for the time being.  We are still considering the use of the deadweight to accelerate the system but need to look at ways of reusing the energy lost in stopping the mass so the ideas about regenerative braking are very interesting. We are also looking at the use of accumulators to try and reduce the energy loss, and at ways of eliminating the ropes and sheaves.

RE: Ideas sought for arresting the fall of a large mass

How about some sort of air bag?

You could even have some fun with the exhausted air from the air bag. i.e.  blow up a big balloon

Or a water bag that would drive a big fountain and shoot a jet of water into the air?




Rick Kitson MBA P.Eng

Construction Project Management
From conception to completion
www.kitsonengineering.com

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources