×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

automobile starter motors

automobile starter motors

automobile starter motors

(OP)
IS THIS AN APPROPRIATE QUESTION FOR THIS FORUM?  Do you have information, experience, or suggestions regarding using starter motors from trucks and cars under continuous operating conditions?  My hopes are to use a low cost motor to power my boat.  My question is how much can I load a motor without it overheating.  How much additional HP can I expect by having the case wrapped with copper tubing and circulate cold water to keep the case cool?  What is a good RPM to have them run for best efficiency?  I plan on using PWM to keep in the wanted power and speed curves.  If I build my own controller, what is the best method to use for speed and power control?  Should the field be kept alive constantly and pulse the armature, operate in pulse mode with a series wound motor, or ?????   If you don’t have information and or thoughts along this line, any idea where I can go on the net and find people who might have interest in this method of using motors?  Thanks for any and all ideas, suggestions, or just comments,   Bernie

RE: automobile starter motors

Hi Plats,
I don't think you can have a normal vehicular starter for power boat application.In cranking application(prime mover of engine) it is in circuit for only a fraction of time and by that time it drains from the battery current in 100s of amps.You need to have very high ampere hour battery which will come very heavy and will drain rapidly - low mileage .Further I think these starter motors are not rated for continous duty.Go for outboard engine instead.

RE: automobile starter motors

I agree with kuwait, a starter motor is designed for a very short duty cycle and would probably not last very long under continuous operation due to overheating.  

Even it could operate continuously, I suspect it would be incredibly inefficient and consume lots of power.  Plus you would have to provide some type of speed control.  

I think the least expensive solution would be to buy an inexpensive electric trolling motor designed for this application.  

RE: automobile starter motors

I agree with the above posters. The starter will only last a short time, like minutes. For every 30 seconds of starting it needs to cool for 2 minutes. Try the suggestions above or look at continuos duty DC motors.

RE: automobile starter motors

(OP)



Yes I realize it cannot be run continuous at full power, thus the concern about PWM.  I have seen them used in commercial applications and last for years and they are a very solid motor thus used.  They are built for max. load, and when used under less demanding loads, the bearings and brushes last a long time.  I have lost my contact with these folks, and do not know how they were controlled, operated, etc.  For my use it will not be turning a prop.  A tolling motor will not work.  Thanks for all inputs and ideas.  They all are very interesting and help me to think about what I am doing.  

RE: automobile starter motors

I HAVE COME ACROSS AN INTERESTING MOTOR.HAVE YOU SEEN A HAND HELD VACUUM CLEANER (I THINK BY ROYAL APPLIANCE).A PRETTY SMALL MOTOR
(46MM STATOR CORE)BUT IMAGINE THE RATING IS 1.0HP!!!!(720WATTS)
YOU CAN OPERATE IT CONTINUOUSLY BECAUSE THE INHERENT NATURE OF THE
VACUUM CLEANER IS TO SUCK AIR WHICH IN TURN COOLS THE MOTOR EFFECTIVELY
THE LIFE GUARANTEED IS 250HRS AND THE VAC CLEANER ITSELF COSTS
20 DOLLARS!!!.TRY TO USE PWM FOR THIS TYPE OF MOTORS WITH APPROPRIATE COOLING

RE: automobile starter motors

(OP)
Thanks for the info, however my guess is that it is 110 volt, 60 Hz.  What I am looking for needs to be DC (Batery) and about 24 volt.  I need speed control.  

RE: automobile starter motors

Suggestion: Motors for marine applications are typically built lighter than ordinary motors and they belong to a category "marine applications." Nowadays, permanent magnet motors are becoming more attractive for marine applications. E.g. future Navy ships will have permanent magnet propulsion motors. Please, what is exactly that motor going to be used for if not for propeller?

RE: automobile starter motors

(OP)
Working on a 20 foot sternwheeler.  The motor will be driving the paddle wheel.  Thats the reason I need varible speed, and reverse.  From a distance she will appear to be an old time sternwheeler.  Thinking about putting one on each side.  When running would like to have a little over one horse.  Of course running slow will need less, thus the need to have PWM.

RE: automobile starter motors

Suggestion: This application has a hidden hitch, namely, the motors will have to have synchronized speed, else, the rudder would often have to be used to correct the incorrect navigation, which means that the ship sail efficiency is considered in here.

RE: automobile starter motors

(OP)
The wheel is one system.  It is a sternwheeler, not a sidewheeler where there are two wheels.  The paddle wheel is not separated into two sections.

RE: automobile starter motors

I was wondering similar problem. I planed to build an EV with starter motor. I checked the problem quite deeply. There are some problems while use starter: one is, the bearings. You have to change the bearings to roller type. It needs modified shields. The other is that the starters are designed to give very high torque at low speed. The efficiency is appr. 50-60%. It is applicable, but should be rewound. Without any calculation I would suggest 2 times more number of turnes in both stator pole and rotor armature. And I would change the brushes also to natural graphite. In your application the current will be much lower, so the high current density type brushes like metal-graphite will not be proper.

RE: automobile starter motors

I agree with all above posts.  The starter is designed and optimized for a very different application than what you're looking at.  Why not look at other 12-24v motors that are designed for continuous usage?  There's got to be lots of better suited off-the-shelf motors available for RV, automotive, and marine applications.  A troller motor still sounds like a good idea to me -- how come you don't like it?  Other motors might include water pumps, winches, hydraulic pumps, tools, hybrid-car wheel motors, blower/fan motors, etc.

RE: automobile starter motors

Just a thought. Try looking for a used golf cart. You can get a smashed up one for as cheap as $100us. The motor is there and the speed control would also be included. Heck, you may even get the charger for the batterys!

RE: automobile starter motors

Suggestion: Visit
http://www.thomasregister.com
and type Motors: DC under Product or Service which will return 322 companies to inquire about the right solution.

RE: automobile starter motors

I like the golf cart idea.

RE: automobile starter motors

(OP)
SteveHuck and all:  Steve I like your idea of using a golf cart motor.  I have been looking for one for several months, and just haven’t been able to come up with what I want yet.  That was my original idea.  Then I started looking at alternative possibilities.  Starter motors, I can get all I want for a song.  Price!!!!, that is what got me looking at the them.  Controls don’t bother me, that I can take care of.  A couple days ago I located a motor out of a powered pallet jack.  Price is right.  Will check it out.  Still looking for golf cart equipment as I think they will come as close to what I want as I can get, at a reasonable price.  Thanks to all that had comments, and with a little bit of luck this project will be on the water this summer.

RE: automobile starter motors

Suggestion: It may be worthwhile to check the motor prices at various electrical distributors and manufacturers. There may be some inexpensive motors available too.

RE: automobile starter motors

(OP)
I have done some checking, not much, but the prices I have come up with so far are higher than I want to go.  Who knows, that may be where I end up, but at this point I am still looking for a bargin.  After all, this started out to be just a whim, and a hobby.

RE: automobile starter motors

hi,
I am presently building my kids an electric go-cart.  It is a new and unusual design.  In my search for an appropriate motor to drive it, as well as batteries, chargers and controllers, I have found this site to be the only one on the net that offers all of what I need.  Please visit:

 http://ecoleco.freeservers.com/scooterparts.htm#MOTOR200

They have 24VDC motors there, at a very reasonable price, with controllers, batteries etc.  I have seen an 800Watt motor available there, at 24VDC. These motors are specificaly designed to move people around, up and down hills, for extended periods of time.  Maybe this will help you?

RE: automobile starter motors

If your going to use two motors then you will still have to think about synchronizing the speed of the motors. This will be based on whether your going to use one PWM source or two, etc. Given the differences in the motors, drive system etc, it may be difficult to control without an attempt at sychronizing the speed. Something to think about.

RE: automobile starter motors

I am user from 1996 of small low price SMB12 trolling motor (aprox. 1/5HP, 12lb thrust max.), 12V, 3-blade propeller 128mm dia, ~72mm pitch, Low Speed 3390 RPM/5Amp, and High Speed 3580 RPM/12Amp, mount on the light inflatable  two person canoe (total load max 200kg/ 450lb).
Now, I want to sell or make stronger trolling motor about 250W, but standard light 250W trolling motor have propeller suitable for 480kg(1100lb) weight boat, max. thrust about 22lb and max. boat speed  about 5.5 km/h ~ 3.3 mph (MotorGuide 22, Thruster 2200, see http://www.boote-magazin.de/testtechnik/motoren/tec1001.htm).
( I want to use car engine cooling fun, 2-speed DC 12V motor).Can anyone recommend me another  propeller, with smaller  thrust, about 16lb, and bigger boat speed, maybe about 5mph, suitable for light two person canoe and 250W / 20Amp trolling motor, maybe about 152.4mm ? propeller diameter with max.speed in range about 1500 - 2000rpm ??

RE: automobile starter motors

Another possible source for inexpensive DC motors and controls is excercise treadmills, typically 1 to 1-1/2HP. I once chased that business with AC drives and motors and could not even get near 1/2 the DC drive and motor price they were using. Most treadmills end up in yard sales after the novelty wears out and can be picked up even cheaper! Yet another industry that uses cheap DC drives and motors is supermarket checkstand belt conveyors.

Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati

RE: automobile starter motors

Oops sorry!
I forgot the 24VDC part. Both of those are probably 110VDC.
My bad.

Never mind.

Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati

RE: automobile starter motors

How about using a generator from an older vechicle. Should that not work better than a starter motor. OR even a wiper motor with the gearbox.

RE: automobile starter motors

That wiper motor sounds like it'd make for one  s l o w  paddleboat.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources