×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

(OP)
Hi Eng-Tips

looking for some help on MV Motor, the nameplate gives the following information

2900Kw, 991 Rpm, 11000 V Y, 991 rpm, 50 hz .085 cos, Rotor 1375 A

This motor has been working fine for 15 + years I'm told, I have only started working in this plant.

In the last 2 years, the motor has started burning brushes on one phase and not always been the same phase.
We looked at the trends and the motor seems to be working at 80% of its capacity, but the rotor amps is very low just 70-80 amps per phase. We do see one phase with approx 10-15% higher reading tot he others.
On this trend we also see the vibration rises from normal 1.2 m/s to 2.6-2.9 m/s which is still quite low. The motor will then trip and the brush will be burned out.

I would like to try and ask your opinion as to why you think the rotor amps are so low and to see why you think the brushes are burning.

Regards
F.E.G

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

I think it would be very unusual to pass that much current through the brushes on a continuous basis, are you sure there is not some means of shorting out the slip-rings when up to speed. A poor short might account for the low current you see.

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

In what we can assume is a Woubd Rotor Induction Motor, there are usually various steps of resistance added to the rotor circuit that change the torque capability of the motor and thus the speed under specific loads. As a general rule you start it with high resistance / slow speed and slowly step up the speed by dropping out resistance, often with contactors in MV motors. If the original starting sequence of operations has been lost over the decades and someone is just switching it on at the resistance that will provide 80% load, that would put a lot of stress on the slip ring brushes and burn them out. The imbalance you are seeing in the Rotor current may also be indicating damage to a slip ring as well, and/or a step contactor too. If you have what's called a Liquid Resistance (liquid rheostat) control system, your electrolyte may be wrong and needs servicing. You need someone who fully understands WRIMs to go through the motor, controls and operating sequence.

It might also be time to consider dragging this into the modern age, because generally large motors like this are intimately tied to the bottom line of whatever your company does, so having it operate reliably means everyone stays employed
 
. If your operating speed never changes now, consider using a solid state soft starter for the stator and that fixed resistance value you already have. If the speed needs to vary to follow some sort of process signal, you can use a VFD but at 11kV that's going to be a budget buster.


" We are all here on earth to help others; what on earth the others are here for I don't know." -- W. H. Auden

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

What attention (if any) has been given to the slip rings? With all these burning brushes,
the slip rings would likely be in less than optimum condition. Including the brush holders.

Photographs of the slip rings, brush holders and the failed brushes provide very useful details.

John

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

(OP)
Hi Guys

Thanks for initial replies.

This motor has been working since Jan 2000, its a slip ring motor started by the same liquid resistance starter and the sequence of starting has not changed over the years. Its a fixed speed all the time. its starts very infrequently, it runs normally for weeks/months at a time.

I have attached some photos, one attachment shows the damage after failure, the other show's the motor in operation with one brush wearing more than the rest, the brushes were changed after this was found.
The slip ring assembly was repaired, skimmed with new brushes fitted and returned to service within 3 months it had the same failure.

F.E.G

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

How are you measuring the rotor amps, which is of slip frequency?

Are you using the brush grade recommended by the OEM?

Muthu
www.edison.co.in

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

(OP)
Hi Muthu,

we recently fitted CT's to measure the motor amps, the OEM no longer supplies the brushes for this motor but we are using the same grade brush as the original and they have been working well up to this problem.

F.E.G

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

Thank you for posting a photo. In viewing the picture, there are obvious signs of insulator deterioration
between the right and center brush sets. Note the discolored (darker) insulators.
There is also a sign of intense heat along the edge of where the slip ring is mated with its insulating hub.
Note the dull look of the metal spacing rod and its lost varnished sheen in comparison to the exposed
portion of the rod further to the left.

You’re not going to want to read this.

The entire slip ring assembly pressed on the rotor shaft must be removed from the apparatus
and completely cleaned/washed, dried out and re-varnished, or totally replaced.
Obviously the brush holder assembly would need the insulators replaced, or inspected for
their electrical integrity as well.

As clean as it looks, it’s difficult to comprehend potential tracking between the
three rings, “but” it does… and likely is.

One opinion based on one photograph.

Keep us posted.

John

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

It does have a lot of brushes but I still can't see 1375 Amps 24/7
And the very low rotor amps running is trying to tell us something
Excessive wear on those brushes

Could there be something wrong with the liquid resistor, I am not familiar with the liquid type.

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

Assuming your current reading is before the shorting device, the rotor current should be approximately 1100A when the motor is running at full speed and 80% load. Your current reading of 70-80A is indicating that thee rotor current is bypassing the external rotor circuit, possibly by a short between phases in the brush holder assembly or the slip ring assembly.

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

Do you not have a shorting contactor to short the brushes when the motor is up to speed?

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

Hi Feg

You use CT's on the rotor circuit? Your read rotor currents are then suspect.

Possible reasons for brush wear out.

1. Wrong grade

2. Inappropriate spring pressure

3. Loose connection from slipring to rotor winding lead

4. Hard dirt (like cement particles)

5. Excessive temperatures

Have you tried measuring the brush temperatures during running with a thermal camera or a non-contact temperature meter?

Muthu
www.edison.co.in

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

A long time ago, and the details are hazy, I had to load test a new generator for a week to satisfy the supplier that the piston rings were well seated to avoid future possible warranty claims if the engine started using oil.
I used six 60 gallon plastic barrels and 12 truck leaf springs for electrodes. With a clamp meter on the lead, I poured salt into the water until I saw an acceptable current. I was running about 200 Amps per barrel, 400 Amps per phase.
What's the point of this?
I boiled off about 600 Gallons per day of water. I made multiple trips to the site every day to refill the barrels.
In the mornings the barrels would be close to empty.
Please tell me that you are not leaving the liquid rheostat in the circuit while the motor is running at speed.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

OK, I missed the CT comment. When the motor is at full speed the rotor frequency is really low so a standard CT won't measure the current. You'd have to use a hall effect sensor type of device to measure the current with the motor at full speed. Using standard CT's would be why your current reading is so low.

I would suspect the quality of your brushes has changed.

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

Has there been any RTV silicon sealant used in the vicinity of the brushes recently? The fumes from RTV silicon are a known brush killer.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

(OP)
Waross you may be on to something. We sent the brushes away to be analysed and they found a trace of a type of silicone/rubber compound we don't know where this came from.
The Elec guys tell me they checked that the contractors are working properly and the starter is out of the system when the motor is up to speed.
I'm a mech guy so I would like to clarify the following, I would have thought that when the motor is up to speed there would be no volts/amps in the rotor is this right ? We are seeing approx 70 amps with the CTs which we only fitted recently, as they only ever trended the stator amps prior to the problems. What we are doing now is monitoring it with the CTs and when it gets to 250 amps it trips, this is actually protecting the motor now and we know this as we have had 8 months now trouble free but we have had 3 trips which is a problem for us. The 250amps was just a guess in case you wonder where we came up with that.

They fitted rope type CTs from Powertekuk RCTRMS-3ph/1500/4/500 (4-20 mA)

Edison, we got a thermal check done and it's shows one phase a lot hotter than the others I just don't have it to hand as I'm away from site. The area is clear with no deposits of dirt, the grade of the brush is the same as the OEM according to SCHUNK and new brushes and springs were fitted after failure.

Thanks for input so far guys

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

Edison 123
Good point, the CTs won't measure the slip frequency I missed that.
Is there a correct way of doing that?
I recall we had a clipon that was nothing more than a magnetic circuit with a changeable moving iron movement, Hall effect nowdays I guess.

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

Bill

"Please tell me that you are not leaving the liquid rheostat in the circuit while the motor is running at speed."

Once the LRS is shorted (either via contactors or a shorting ring at the end of the travel of the LRS), not much current will be flowing through the liquid. The case you are describing is where the salt water was used as a load 24x7.

Feg

"I would have thought that when the motor is up to speed there would be no volts/amps in the rotor is this right"

No, the rotor will have the rated rotor current at full load at the rated speed.

Again, you cannot use CT's to measure low frequency rotor currents. And rotor currents are not measured or used for motor protection in normal applications.

A complete revamp of your sliprings (not just surface machining) is needed.

Muthu
www.edison.co.in

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

The Silicone Theory would be a good one if all three slip rings were being equally attacked by the corrosion causing [out gasses] non-electrical grade silicone
exhibits during its curing process (which takes years).

The photo of the slip ring area of the motor clearly shows one phase is affected. Not all three.

(Silicone -out gasses- would not choose just one phase; it would attack all copper bearing surfaces.)

The slip ring area of the motor is tracking “potential” which needs to be corrected.
And the only way that can happen is by removing the apparatus from service, and fixing it.

The absence of visual dirt or debris is meaningless. Conducting carbon from past brush changes can be/is likely
painted over from previous attention to the apparatus.

John

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

Quote (Feg)

I would have thought that when the motor is up to speed there would be no volts/amps in the rotor is this right ?

Easy approximations for the rotor of a slip ring motor.
- current is proportional to load
- voltage is inversely proportional to synchronous speed.
- frequency is inversely proportional to synchronous speed.

So, at full speed and full load you should see a low rotor frequency, a low rotor voltage and rated rotor current.

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

The rightmost pair of slip rings (which has overheated pigtails) is sunk much deeper into the brushholder. Is that a result of wear or something else?

1.2 m/sec would be very high vibration velocity. I assume you meant 1.2 mm/sec.

=====================================
(2B)+(2B)' ?

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

(OP)
The wear was even across all the slip rings, we know that the motor and slip rings perform well for most of the time as we see no damage until the failure happens so the problem arises quite quickly
the vibration was a typo its 1.2mm sec

F.E.G

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

Have you checked the external circuit for hot spots and or loose connections?
Are the contacts in the shorting contacter in good condition?
Have you considered a ductor test of the rotor to determine if there is a failing internal connection to one slip ring?
A poor connection to the slip ring may cause excess heating of the slip ring under heavy loads.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

Quote:

The wear was even across all the slip rings
Thanks. Is it correct to conclude that the right brushes were heavily worn? (or is there some other reason they are sitting deeper in the brushholders).

=====================================
(2B)+(2B)' ?

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

(OP)
yes, its when it failed it had heavy wear on that one ring. But 3 days prior when we inspected it all rings were good with even wear, so we are trying to establish why it is failing on one ring. This is the original motor the spare went in and it has the same failure but on a different ring and the original is back in now.

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

1: I think it is due to mixing of carbon brush grade; below I will try to create a scenario.

In case if we replace some worn brushes with grade other than original. Suppose new brushes have high conductivity comparing to original brushes, then these new brushes will carry more current than other brushes. Wear rate will increase on these brushes due to excessive current and finally in very short time brushes will reach to their minimum length. Now at this moment, burden of those worn brushes will be shifted to remaining brushes and current density on remaining brushes will increased. In result, after some period all brushes would be looked heated-up and consequently worn-out.

2: I think your current measurement seems not ok; you cannot use normal CT's to measure low frequency rotor currents.

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

What is this motor driving? Is the operator able to control the loading on the motor? Where is the motor mounted? Is the environment clean or dirty? Are there periods when there is dirt or contaminants in the air? Is the motor installed in such a way the air circulation is impeded in any way?

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

So let me summarize. Please comment if I've said something wrong:

1. Occasionally something happens where vibration goes up, motor trips, and brushes are found worn and overheated.
2. Those worn brushes are found in a different phase each time.
3. But (at least from latest photo), the two brushes within a given phase have similar wear?
4. After the failure, brushes replaced but nothing done to slip ring?

If I have it right that's tough to figure.
Overheating may be a consequence of severe brush wear which extends spring to the point that contact pressure is lost and it creates the heat. But in that case, what would cause the severe brush wear to begin with.
Items 2 and 3 don't seem very consistent with a mechanical cause.
Electrical cause on rotor doesn't seem likely to shift phase.

Maybe something to do with external shorting...if there are multiple contacts involved and all of them have some erratic behavior. Just a shot in the dark, not sure. Maybe try some resistance measurements from the brushes with brushes lifted off the slip rings and the external circuit in the shorted/running configuration (with motor not running though!).

Photos of slip rings or the other side of the brushes might possibly have some clues.
Also if there is a spectrum associated with this increased vib, analysis of which frequencies increase may give some clues (does it suggest a stator unbalance 2*LF or a rotor unbalance which I think might have pole pass characteristics, or something else). For that matter, any unusual frequencies in the normal vib? Also if you notice the vib going up you may be able to grab some three phase current measurements on stator or rotor if there are safely accessible measurement points and methods. Also take a close look at your maintenance procedures, spring tension checks, condition of slip rings, also the potential contamination issues mentioned by John / D'Arsonval


=====================================
(2B)+(2B)' ?

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

I know next to nothing about brushed motors or brushes:

Wouldn't imbalanced current on the three rotor poles cause vibration?

Higher current on one pole is caused by lower resistance in that pole. Lower resistance could be due to:

Shorted turns in a winding?
Shorter lead length to the shorting point?
Higher brush contact pressure compared to the other poles?


I've heard that brushes have a negative coefficient of resistivity within certain temperature ranges (a property of carbon). Something I've been wondering: to avoid thermal runaway, is it necessary to have a certain minimum resistance in the shorting circuit on each pole such that the resistance of the brush is not a significant portion of the total resistance in each pole? (i.e. varying brush resistance does not significantly influence rotor current) If the shorting resistance in each pole was approximately equal but more importantly, too small, would thermal runaway be possible? In such a case, I would expect the pole to burn out to be the one that had the lowest contact resistance which is I'd guess would be most dominantly determined by the initial spring tension.

Is it typical that the brushes are in shorting circuit on a WRIM?

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

We have similar 6kV motor and sometimes we performed simply test to see if exists some problem with external shorting , contacts and resistor .
We give low voltage * 3 x 380 Volts* on stator windings ant then simulate motor start with contactor and timers beetween every steps .
Then you should measure current on every stator and rotor phase with amper clamps without big risk because motor did not run .
In several last steps, stator and rotor currents are a bit larger so that you need to pay attention to this when selecting the power wire .
IF is current at every step of all phases is same and ballansed you did not have problem with rotor , contactors , start resistor and your problem is on the other side .
Good luck

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

panter

The rotor will turn even at 380 V if the rotor circuit is closed with or without resistor.

Muthu
www.edison.co.in

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

11,000 Volts down to 380 Volts?
Uncoupled the rotor will turn.
We don't know what this motor or the motor that panter tested were driving.
A lot of loads will not turn with 3.5% of rated voltage applied.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

It is 6kV, 3,55 MW motor with more than 4 Tons rotor weight on sleeve bearings .
It is coupled with pump and 380 V is low voltage to turn rotor during test .
Good luck !

RE: MED Voltage Motor - Rotor amps

Let's look in the other direction. An unbalanced supply may cause heavy rotor current.
Have you checked the incoming supply for balanced phase to phase voltages.
Check first with the motor off-line and again with the motor running.
A running induction motor acts as an induction generator and will try to correct unbalances in the supply.
This may cause circulating currents and excess rotor heating.
My experience with unbalance issues has been with squirrel cage motors, synchronous alternators and transformer banks.
Given that unbalanced loading has caused rotor heating and damage in alternators, and unbalances have caused unbalanced currents in motors and rotor heating and in the case of transformer banks, caused one transformer to run much hotter than the second overheated transformer, it is possible that unbalanced supply voltages may cause heavier current in one brush.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources