TJL Floor Joists and Long Term Creep
TJL Floor Joists and Long Term Creep
(OP)
Got a project constructed under the 1976 UBC that has three stories of wood and steel framing over parking on a sloping lot.
The ceiling GWB is cracking in at least the second story end unit about 4 feet in from the end wall and I see no settlement issues with the foundation - on piling and no cracking. Don't know about the other units... yet.
I am leaning toward long term creep as the floor joists have a 1.5" thick topping spec'd at 9 psf. I am suspicious about the actual density of the topping too which would make matters worse... When coupled with the other framing, the dead load is 20 psf and the dead to total load ratio is 33 percent, exceeding the 22 percent guideline for table use, triggering a special computer analysis according to the November 2000 catalog, the oldest I have available. If you ignore the 22% issue, the joists appear fine for the loading and span seen.
Has anyone experienced similar long term creep issues in similar circumstances?
Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)
The ceiling GWB is cracking in at least the second story end unit about 4 feet in from the end wall and I see no settlement issues with the foundation - on piling and no cracking. Don't know about the other units... yet.
I am leaning toward long term creep as the floor joists have a 1.5" thick topping spec'd at 9 psf. I am suspicious about the actual density of the topping too which would make matters worse... When coupled with the other framing, the dead load is 20 psf and the dead to total load ratio is 33 percent, exceeding the 22 percent guideline for table use, triggering a special computer analysis according to the November 2000 catalog, the oldest I have available. If you ignore the 22% issue, the joists appear fine for the loading and span seen.
Has anyone experienced similar long term creep issues in similar circumstances?
Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)






RE: TJL Floor Joists and Long Term Creep
The standard TJI catalogs state that long term creep is not considered in their tables...either suggests that creep isn't an issue or they are simply covering themselves and don't know much about creep in their product.
Check out Eng-Tips Forum's Policies here:
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
RE: TJL Floor Joists and Long Term Creep
This is one of those problems where the cause does not immediately hit you in the face, but creeps up on you instead,(no pun intended).
Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)
RE: TJL Floor Joists and Long Term Creep
RE: TJL Floor Joists and Long Term Creep
RE: TJL Floor Joists and Long Term Creep
Otherwise, unless there is another way, they would just have to live with the situation, periodically making Crack repairs.
As far as I know, this is just a serviceability situation structurally, and not a life safety issue.
Any other ideas?
Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)
RE: TJL Floor Joists and Long Term Creep
Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)
RE: TJL Floor Joists and Long Term Creep
I guess what I found is what you found too.
Not much info here. I have contacted a local technical rep from RedBuilt. We'll see what he says.
Thanks all.
Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)
RE: TJL Floor Joists and Long Term Creep
I looked tat the reference you cited and there is still no specific mention, even then in 1988, of long term creep issues, only referencing the applicable building code - would have been the 1985 UBC for that one...
So addressing the issue had to have occurred between 1988 and 2000, as it was addressed in 2000.
Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)
RE: TJL Floor Joists and Long Term Creep
OR is the creep mechanism merely related to a relaxing of "E" over time, allowing further deflection not associated with any stress increase?
Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)
RE: TJL Floor Joists and Long Term Creep