×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)
4

Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

(OP)
Hi guys, what would you suggest to use for determing bearing capacity of shallow foundations on a high plasticity silt? The in situ permeability test were about 1E-04 cm/s. Water table is about 4 meters deep.

Would you use drained or undrained analysis? The results from the undrained triaxial tests where fricion angle=27 and cohesion=25 kPa. The undrained resistance is Su/r0=0,3

Thanks for your help.

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

I'd check all that stuff, for sure. I'd likely determine the allowable bearing pressure on settlement; however. Did your run a consolidation test?

f-d

ípapß gordo ainÆt no madre flaca!

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

any capillary rise with the WT? would have thought it would be saturated to near surface. With highly plastic material there can be a volumetric change with change in moisture content... about 20 years back I did a bunch of investigations into foundations that had 'settled' to find that it was high plastic and there had been several 'dry' years.

Dik

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

Based on the UU triaxial test results, appears that the layer where you took the sample is unsaturated. Perhaps you took the sample within 4 m below ground surface. Your footings will be installed in this layer. But, is there any chances to these soils get saturated as dik mentioned? I would check the allowable bearing pressures based on settlement considerations as fattdad suggested. If your footings are small so the depth of influence of stresses is shallow, you may be able to calculate elastic settlements using the approximate modulus from the stress-strain curves of the UU tests.

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

(In my mind it seems impossible to attain saturation through capillary rise.)

f-d

ípapß gordo ainÆt no madre flaca!

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

With fine grained highly plastic silt, I'm not sure... or maybe that is the top of the capillary rise. I assume the WT was determined by using tubes and left for a period of time.

Dik

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

Hi Atros
What is your footing width? If the fluctuation of ground water depth is outside of the failure criteria, the undrained parameters may be applicable. Since the soil is MH- a high plasticity silt, an undrained insitu test such as shear vane test may be considered as a design parameter. I believe that the insitu test is less disturbance than the laboratory test. Lok.

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

I found this for capillary rise:

http://scholarworks.wmich.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?...

I didn't read the entire thesis, but just looking at the conclusions, appears that the available equations to predict capillary rise for silts underestimate the actual values measured in the lab.

I will also check my notes from Prof. Stark's class. I recall he provided an equation for capillary rise as well.

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

(OP)
Hi all, thanks for your help.

L0k, im considering a 1x1 m square foundation.

The unconfined compresion test of a not perturbated sample has this results:

-Undrained shear strength, Su: 0,32 kgf/cm2
-Undrained shear strength of remolded sample, Su: 0,89 kgf/cm2

Consolidation test (see attached image)




Tension (kgf/cm2) Void ratio
0 1,472
0 1,478
0,1 1,459
0,25 1,442
0,5 1,425
1 1,399
2 1,352
4 1,276
8 1,176
2 1,184
0,5 1,196
0,1 1,196
0 1,203
2 1,184
0,5 1,196
0,1 1,196
0 1,203

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

Hi Atros

The undisturbed sample will create the the undrained Su > the remoulded strength, it was not happening in your strength where Su=0.32kg/cm2 < Sr=0.89kg/cm2. This showed that your sample is having a certain disturbance, that's why I prefer the in-situ strength. I cannot calculate your ultimate bearing capacity.
Your consolidation test gave the Pc value is about 1.2kgf/cm2. I guess the Po+dp value will be in the elastic condition. So the Cr value will determine your settlement.

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

The residual clayey soils in my area also show higher remolded unconfined compressive strengths than the undisturbed samples strengths. My soils are unsaturated overconsolidated clays. This is interesting. I am not really sure about why this is happening and am still researching on this.

Anyways,for your footings which are 1x1 m and assuming that the Df is about 1m, your footings may not be greatly impacting the saturated silts that are at 4 meters below grade (depth of stresses influence for square footings for 10% of stresses at approximately 2B: 2m in your case). So I would use the elastic modulus from your unconfined compressive test and calculate elastic settlements of the silt layer. Again, consolidation settlements may be very small since the stresses for the saturated layer are low.

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

I've only ever encountered soil sensitivity (su,undisturbed/su,remoulded) less than unity when the soil had notable structure. The fabric/structure of the intact soil can result in weaknesses to loading in certain directions (and also extra strength when loading in some other directions). In such cases the process of remoulding can remove these weaknesses associated with the soil fabric/structure.

If there is no notable structure or fabric to the intact soil, then it may be the case that the testing had some issues. Was the remoulded test performed on the same sample with the same density and water content?

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

You cannot really apply the concepts of sedimentary soils to that of residual soils.

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

(OP)
Thanks for your answer. I think the material is from volcanic ash (alofanic) and thats why the remould resistance is bigger than the indisturbed.

The in situ density test gave this results:

Wet density 1,65 t/m3
w% 48,20
Dry density 1,11 t/m3.

The structure is a house with no big loads. What do you think? Remove 2 meters of material and use a structural fill?

Thanks.

RE: Bearing capacity of a high plasticity silt (MH)

Attached is some notes about capillary rise for reference.

pelelo, 2m of overexcavation and structural fill may work but looks expensive for a house. I think that you may be able to work with the soils you have but you need to check settlements and so on. If settlements are too high, try with 1 m of overexcavation and structural fill and see how it goes.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources