×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Moment of Inertia of Weld Groups in 3-axes

Moment of Inertia of Weld Groups in 3-axes

Moment of Inertia of Weld Groups in 3-axes

(OP)
Hello all-
We're designing a rather heavy test fixture to suspend and rotate a large mass. The fixture and mass will be rotated very slowly around the horizontal Z-axis and tilted fore and aft around the X-axis while we "operate" on our mass (all motions are slow enough and do not impart significant accelerations, i.e., static design is all that is required). The concept sketch of the fixture is attached. For the purpose of this question assume all plates are 1-inch thick (to be verified later).

THE PROBLEM: Need to determine the moments of inertia of the weld group which as you can see is configured along three orthogonal axes in order to design the fillet weld sizes. I'm not proficient in ASD or LRFD calculations so for our fixtures I'll use Blodgett's methods for designing welds. However every hand book on earth and every reference in the infinity of the internet only has charts of weld group properties for 2-dimensional single plane arrangements. Omar Blodgett's handbook includes a scant outline of a single computation for a 3-dimensional problem but seems to have made many simplifying assumptions that aren't explained and aren't obvious.

THE QUESTION: Can anyone advise on a source for weld group properties that includes 3-axis arrangements OR better yet, some other reference that shows details of handling this type of design. I can't be the only one to ever have to do this !!

Thank you for reading and all advice is welcome.

RE: Moment of Inertia of Weld Groups in 3-axes

Hi TC7

Looking at your sketch, it should be two different problems to evaluate, not a single problem

1) Determine shear flow between vertical gusset and horizontal plate (36" long weld). Size weld as required to provide adequate shear flow and act as composite (if you need to) its possible gusset is strong enough without moment of inertia contribution of horizontal.

2) Determine moment of inertia of weld group at wall (right sketch). Determine bending moment at wall and check welds. Use 2 vertical fillets to start, Add horizontal if necessary. Remember if you use uneven weld equations to check the side in TENSION, not compression

Hope this helps

Jeff
Pipe Stress Analysis Engineer
www.xceed-eng.com

RE: Moment of Inertia of Weld Groups in 3-axes

(OP)
Thanks for you speedy reply Jeff, I'll start off my calcs with your suggestions.

Say by the way ! Since you are a piping engineer, let me ask you this: I happen to have an old piping design book by Grinnell that shows a piping run routed in three directions and they illustrate a method finding Ixx & Iyy in the X-Y plane, then find Ixx & Izz in the X-Z plane and then find the Iyy & Izz in the Y-Z plane. So after all that is done they sum up each pair of I's. The book does also list line properties in each orientation. The calculation process is very orderly and I understand them perfectly - are you familiar with the Grinnel method? and can I apply the same methodology to my design problem ?

RE: Moment of Inertia of Weld Groups in 3-axes

No problem. I'm not familiar with that right now (I'm home). But if you add two moments of inertia that are orthagonal to eachother, you are calculating the torsional inertia of weld group "J". You don't have torsion so you shouldn't need to compute this. Can you upload Grinnell pages you described?

Jeff
Pipe Stress Analysis Engineer
www.xceed-eng.com

RE: Moment of Inertia of Weld Groups in 3-axes

(OP)
No, I'm not talking about the torsional inertia. In the Grinnell method, the line inertias are calculated for the projection of the 3-D configuration in each plane. For instance, Ixx is determined from the projection in the X-Y plane and then Ixx is determined from the projection in the X-Z plane, then each of these Ixx's are added together to provide a "Total Ix"; similarly, "Total Iy" and "Total Iz" are determined from their respective projection planes. Text pages are attached*.

What do think Jeff, is this a legitimate method to use when treating welds as lines and determining weld group inertias in a 3-axis system? It would seem to avoid need for simplified assumptions that appear to have been made in the Blodgett example.




* I don't think I am violating any web site rules, to give full credit, these pages are from the Grinnell text, " Piping Design and Engineering ", Third Edition, 1971.

RE: Moment of Inertia of Weld Groups in 3-axes

Can you treat the forces in the welds in a fashion similar to shear wall load distribution on a rigid plate?

Dik

RE: Moment of Inertia of Weld Groups in 3-axes

TC7, I don't think this is the correct application of the the Grinnell Line Inertia. Thats for determining support reactions at end of piping:

1) The line body (piping) is only supported at two points, while your weld is continuously connected and transfers load along its entire length

2) I see how you are looking at the weld as a 3-Dimensional weld group. But take a step back and look at load flow. Any loading that flows from bottom plate through your vertical gusset still needs to be resolved at the wall. The 36" weld isn't a support reaction for your load. Your critical weld is the weld to the wall which is a 2D setup

Jeff
Pipe Stress Analysis Engineer
www.xceed-eng.com

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources