×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

(OP)
I'm designing a concrete cover for a 22' diameter existing concrete circular tank. The Tank is embedded in the ground and there will be people walking on top of it. Here are the conditions:

- The slab on the bottom has a slope.
- The depth of Tank varies from 9'-6" at the edge of the wall to 15'-6" at center.
- I can add columns in between to support the roof/cover, since I don't know the thickness of the bottom slab, I'm thinking to add a concrete slab on top of the existing one to support the columns.

I have a hard time finding a good design guide for this and I'm not sure if there are going to be any special considerations in comparison to a two way slab here. Do you have any recommendations for references or things I need to consider in my design?

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

Deleted...

Dik

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

You could just take the maximum span (22 ft.) analyze it for dead and live load and be done with it. So you're going to end up with a 14 inch slab for deflection reasons and reinforce it with #5's at 6". Or you could find someone with Roark, dust it off, go to Table 24, case 10 and get 10.4 foot kips and put in minimum reinforcing of #6 at 12".

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

Continuous support around the periphery plus a single column in the middle would be my choice if the existing perimeter footing is adequate. That would require a single new footing which could be poured on top of the existing slab. You could use a circular column on a circular footing. A circular drop panel could be used on the upper slab, but my preference is to just use a flat slab for simplicity in forming.

BA

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

(OP)
Thank you for the replies. Actually the diameter is 44 ft not 22. I think I would probably end up with a flat slab with 3 columns. The center of the tank has openings and equipments and I won't be able to add a column there...

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

If the slab is to be reinforced as a two way slab, perhaps four columns in a square pattern would be better than three columns in a triangular pattern.

BA

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

(OP)
Thanks...

I came up with 4 columns and a 12" slab on top. The problem is the bottom slab of existing tank is only 6 inches thick. I'm worried there is not enough room for rebars to be embedded in the old concrete for a new slab to be poured on top of the old one to act as a foundation. Does using HILTIs help?

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

Hilti anchors don't really improve the situation. Moreover, you may well have a failure of punching shear etc at the slab on grade. I believe this is what BA was getting at with this statement:

Quote (BA)

That would require a single new footing which could be poured on top of the existing slab.

I like to debate structural engineering theory -- a lot. If I challenge you on something, know that I'm doing so because I respect your opinion enough to either change it or adopt it.

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

Not sure why you would need a 12" slab on top. The diameter of the tank is 44'. The live load is 100 psf so if you place the columns at 16' o/c in each direction, you would have a maximum interior span of 16' and a maximum end span of 14'. I would estimate a 6" slab would be adequate, but let's say 8". The dead load is 100 psf plus weight of waterproofing.

A continuous slab over the existing slab seems a bit excessive. Why not cut four holes through the existing slab to accommodate four new footings, maintaining as much of the existing reinforcement as possible, then excavate down as required for the new footings. The top of footing should match the top of existing slab except that the bearing area of each column should be depressed and level to provide good bearing for the columns.

The joint between new and existing concrete must be waterproofed to prevent leakage.

BA

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

BAretired, I'd lean toward not cutting into the slab at all. Pour a new footing on top of the slab large enough to carry the column loads. Size it based on the bearing capacity of the subgrade. If you want to anchor it, use small bars (#3's?) epoxied shallowly into the thin slab. It's going to be a major pain to seal the footing to the slab, so why fool with it?

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

Quote (sengineering)

Actually the diameter is 44 ft not 22.
The depth of Tank varies from 9'-6" at the edge of the wall to 15'-6" at center.
The center of the tank has openings and equipment...

Does that tank happen to have an internal rotating rake, also?

www.SlideRuleEra.net idea
www.VacuumTubeEra.net r2d2

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

Yes JedClampett, you may be right; waterproofing between new and existing concrete could be problematic.

If there is a rake as suggested by SlideRuleEra, columns cannot be used at all. That would be a whole new ballgame.

BA

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

(OP)
There isn't a rake. This is a clearwell built in 1950s for a waterplant and it's just holding water. Drilling through the existing concrete would make it difficult to seal it after, but if that's the only way then we have no choice. With pouring the new slab on top of existing one, I'm more worried about the new concrete sliding on top of the old one as the vertical pressure will be high. I"m thinking to specify HILTI rebars embedded in concrete, but that's such a low penetration I'm not sure if it works. Do you have any recommendations?

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

If the slab is called out as 6 inches, it's probably a little more. Contractors typically over pour slabs on grade. It's easier than grading super accurately. But even if it's 6 inches, you can pretty much develop a #3 bar in a 4 inch epoxied hole. And if you have a 4'-0" square footing and space them at 6", that's 64 #3 bars. That's a lot of reinforcing. And there's nothing prohibiting (actually there's nothing allowing it, but I'm a glass half full kind of engineer) the use of epoxied bars for shear friction. Make sure to hook the tops and you're good.

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

Forming the the bottom of a cast-in-place roof, supported by only 4 interior columns is going to be a real challenge. This forming work will take place inside the sloped-bottom tank which, with the forms in place, becomes a confined space. Shoring and maybe even the forms will have to be removed after the top is in place.

Any chance of not using interior columns at all, but span the the entire tank with structural steel? Probably about W27, maybe W24 sections for the longest members. A (relatively thin) cast-in-place roof uses stay-in-place forms installed from the top. Since top of the existing tank is near ground level, the steel beams can be supported by independent footings (outside the existing tank walls). Walking surface of the roof would be, say, 30" to 36"+ above grade.

www.SlideRuleEra.net idea
www.VacuumTubeEra.net r2d2

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

Why not use precast hollow core concrete panels? No forming required.
12" hollow core can span the 44 ft. per my literature, 8" would require interior support.

These have been used in many water tanks in my experience.

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

sengineering - What is your live load requirement for the roof? BAretired estimated 100 psf, which I agree with as reasonable for an industrial environment.

www.SlideRuleEra.net idea
www.VacuumTubeEra.net r2d2

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

Clear spanning is an attractive idea. A concrete slab on steel deck on open web steel joists is a possibility but the steel would be in a continuously humid atmosphere, so would need to be protected from corrosion.

BA

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

(OP)
Thanks for the great comments.

I used 100 pcf for the live load even that seems a bit much. This project is in the middle of nowhere.

Using a slab with steel beams or hollow core and skipping columns are both good ideas. However, I'm hesitant to use steel since this is going to be a very corrosive environment... I don't have much experience with hollow core, this slab is going to have a few pumps (about 2-300 lbs each) on top of it and needs to have openings, is that possible with hollow core if you want to span a slab with no middle beams?

Also, I just realized there is a requirement for the tank cover slab to be sloped by 16:1. So the roof either has to be mono slope or an A-frame...

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

Make one end of the W27 / W24 members 3'+ higher than the other end, keep each W10 level (along it's length)... there is the required 16:1 mono slope. Include framing for pumps in the structural steel layout.

You need to define the live load requirement now. That number will influence the whole design. Being in the "middle of nowhere" is NOT a valid reason to reduce loading requirements. In fact, it could make higher loading on the roof more likely... say, (heavy self-powered) equipment, has to put on the roof for maintenance or repair work.

www.SlideRuleEra.net idea
www.VacuumTubeEra.net r2d2

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

(OP)
Thanks for the sketch and comments SlideRuleEra. Yes, I have used 100 psf for live load and added 0.3 kips point loads for the pumps.I will do a cost estimate to see if using steel beams is going to be cheaper than columns.

RE: Circular Concrete Slab Cover (Roof) for Circular Tank

Good, glad it helps. Keep in mind that all of the weight from the new sloped cast-in-place roof + live load (a few hundred kips total) will bear on either the existing tank walls (which most likely were not designed for that load) or the proposed (corrosion resistant) interior columns which put high load on the 6" thick, 60+ year old slab that has been in a corrosive environment since built. Depending on soil conditions, expect some differential settlement (cracking the existing tank bottom) when the columns are loaded.... dead load alone will probably be enough to do that. Suggest rereading my comments on construction concerns (i.e. dollars) for building a cast-in-place roof on columns.

A clear-span roof avoids every one of those issues. I'm not saying this will be a perfect solution, but with proper design (both structural & geotechnical) there is no dependence on the 60+ year old tank to do more than it was designed for.

Please let us know the decision.

www.SlideRuleEra.net idea
www.VacuumTubeEra.net r2d2

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources