Which one is correct for “all over” callout per 14.5 94 standard
Which one is correct for “all over” callout per 14.5 94 standard
(OP)
Different “all over” callout noticed on some GD&T books, just want to confirm which one is correct per Y14.5 94 standard. Thanks in advance.
Season
Season





RE: Which one is correct for “all over” callout per 14.5 94 standard
RE: Which one is correct for “all over” callout per 14.5 94 standard
Yes, I know "all over" added in 2009 version, I mean the right way to call it out in 94 version.
Season
RE: Which one is correct for “all over” callout per 14.5 94 standard
Application of 'ALL OVER' note is mentioned in para. 6.5.2(a) of Y14.5M-1994.
Looking only at what's been shown/said in the standard I would say there is no clear answer to your question (that's probably why you see different methods in different books). I would lean towards the option without the circle at the junction.
RE: Which one is correct for “all over” callout per 14.5 94 standard
John-Paul Belanger
Certified Sr. GD&T Professional
Geometric Learning Systems
RE: Which one is correct for “all over” callout per 14.5 94 standard
It still not clear even in 2009 version,But I will think without the circle is correct.
Season
RE: Which one is correct for “all over” callout per 14.5 94 standard
Please look at the symbols table in Fig 3-11 on page 42 of 2009, the last two rows
Certified Sr. GD&T Professional
RE: Which one is correct for “all over” callout per 14.5 94 standard
Season