×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Vertical and horizontal bending of brick walls

Vertical and horizontal bending of brick walls

Vertical and horizontal bending of brick walls

(OP)
Hi guys,

Was hoping someone could shed some light on horizontal vs vertical bending of brick walls. I'm guessing if you had a wall that's restrained too and bottom then you would probably only need to design for horizontal bending of the brickwork. When would you look at both horizontal and vertical?

RE: Vertical and horizontal bending of brick walls

If the wall had buttresses spaced horizontally a distance that was less than the vertical span between supports, it may be better to design the wall to span horizontally. Technically, if the ratio of vertical to horizontal span was not too high you might get some two-way action but I've never seen this done in practice or addressed in codes for un-reinforced masonry. In either case, for un-reinforced masonry flexural tension is not normally allowed and the actual allowable stresses are very low per ACI 530.

RE: Vertical and horizontal bending of brick walls

Most codes do allow unreinforced masonry to be designed for horizontal flexure, but not for vertical. But then, some specifically residential codes, for some reason, allow unreinforced basement walls.

RE: Vertical and horizontal bending of brick walls

Sparkes1992:
As PengStruct suggests, the wall panel will tend to span in the direction of the shorter span length, and you might design it that way. There is no doubt that there is some two-way spanning action of the wall panels too. The horiz. (bed) joints are fairly weak because they are continuous, and because bond and tensile strengths are so low. But, they have the benefit of gravity loads (DL only?) cancelling out some of the tensile stress which you are designing to prevent. Spanning from column (or pilaster) to column the joint weakness is less significant because the joints are not continuous, except in stacked bond.

RE: Vertical and horizontal bending of brick walls

When did vertical flexure become a no no? I thought it was direct tension that was not allowed but flexural tension was OK.

RE: Vertical and horizontal bending of brick walls

XR250,

The answer is code specific. We have a lot of questions on this site about horizontal cracking in basement walls, I think mostly in the US, where that residential code must allow unreinforced basement walls.

RE: Vertical and horizontal bending of brick walls

Quote (hokie66)

The answer is code specific. We have a lot of questions on this site about horizontal cracking in basement walls, I think mostly in the US, where that residential code must allow unreinforced basement walls.

The residential code does allow un-reinforced masonry basement walls. But I believe ACI-530 also allows flexural tension regardless of orientation (at least it used to).

RE: Vertical and horizontal bending of brick walls

I'm pretty certain the CSA code allows it, and it fairly closely mimics ACI. It's just a different reduction factor applied when it's bending the other direction. If I remember correctly.

RE: Vertical and horizontal bending of brick walls

Yes I think ACI allows it but I'm just cautious about using it for sustained lateral loads such as at basement walls. If the stress is really low then fine but I also see a lot of bad CMU work done by small contractors.

RE: Vertical and horizontal bending of brick walls

PengStructural -

The problem with some small contractors building basements is quite common, maybe because of loose specifications and/or controls. Also, the ignorance of the possible availability of CMU units. - There are many CMUs that could be used for higher loads, while the range of availability of clay brick configurations is limited.

Some smaller contractors are certainly a questionable labor source, but the good ones do superior work (in comparison to some larger contractors/builders and do a great deal of the basements because of the creativity and ability to handle small basement efficiently from a logistic and construction/quality basis. - I have seen this based on about 25 years experience as an engineer and material supplier on codes and material standards (TMS, ACI, ASTM and many local and state codes).

There are many unique units that have been used domestically and internationally for CMU construction. Unfortunately, the domestic (U.S.) engineers have not used the resources and units available in comparison to many foreign engineers/contractors/builders using ACI 530. The ACI 530 document is the basis for most international masonry designs.

Even for the lowly basement, some builders have created reliable construction methods and the ability to use the same systems and CMU for both reinforced an unreinforced. As a supplier, we had a larger home builder (200 to 400 homes per year) that had unique CMU shapes made for him. He could afford to pay a higher price for specific units that were more economical and provided a higher quality home.

Dick

Engineer and international traveler interested in construction techniques, problems and proper design.

RE: Vertical and horizontal bending of brick walls

Quote (concretemasonry)

The problem with some small contractors building basements is quite common, maybe because of loose specifications and/or controls. Also, the ignorance of the possible availability of CMU units. - There are many CMUs that could be used for higher loads, while the range of availability of clay brick configurations is limited.
Most basements in my area are unreinforced CMU if the backfill heights fall within those listed in the IRC. I usually do not see any issues with them as long as they use decent backfill and drainage. Usually, the cracks develop at the mortar joints of the CMU so I do not see how using higher strength CMU is necessary.

RE: Vertical and horizontal bending of brick walls

(OP)
The Australian code AS3700 gives design guides for both verticle and horizontal bending i believe

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources