×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

(OP)
According to the article "Pipeline Failure Results from Lightning Strike: Act of Mother Nature?" , a through hole in a 4.8 mm wall thickness, underground pipe, can be attributed to lightning strike.
Is it only me who finds this explanation groundless?
If a lightning hits a metallic object, it will cause only surface marks to the paint or the coating, since the current will spread to the whole surface of the object. It is well known than when lightning hits a car (auto steel sheet is about 1 mm) or metallic poles, there will be no penetrating of the steel. And if the underground pipe was hit by lightning, it would receive only a fraction of the total current.

Is there a way that a lighting could make this hole to a buried pipe?


RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

While I don't think it is out of the question (it has been known since on or before the time of our Benjamin Franklin that the many thousands of volts and amperes of some lightning strikes can pretty much do what/go where they want to!), I believe I have heard of a great many more, though perhaps non-obvious failures of plastic piping in lightning strikes (even though same are relative newcomers to the field, with a whole lot less out there) then legacy iron and steel, perhaps for the reasons you describe. In addition to normally quite catastrophic splits of e.g. pvc water and irrigation pipes in lightning events, polyethylene plastic pipe has also been reported to be perforated by build-up and eventual discharge of static electricity e.g. per http://ionixgastechnologies.com/static_electric_pi... .

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

The article in the OP is about lightning striking PE coated pipe. It is possible for lightning to strike a hole through the PE coating. This would concentrate corrosion into this small area, which could result in a hole in the steel pipe after some time.

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

Quote (CostasV)

Is it only me who finds this explanation groundless?

Nah, I'd say it's shocking.

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

Lightning supposedly can be blamed for many pipeline leaks. Somebody was making that claim in the US a few years ago, having plotted pipeline leak locations with known lightning strike locations. As I recall there was some question as to the accuracy of the lightening strike locations.

This article in Pipelines OZ appears to substantiate the possibility,
https://pipelinesoz.wordpress.com/2012/03/16/light...

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

I have sort of seen one: A smooth clean conical shaped hole about 15mm on the outer surface . SEM found high AL in the surface metal. The power company told us lightening knocked down one of their AL lines , it fell into the open ditch before the new line was buried and melted the hole in the pipe. So , sort of caused by lightning.

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

(OP)
Thank you for your comments.

Compositepro: The article says that the hole in the steel pipe was not due to corrosion. The crater formation was an indication or proof that lightning, or other electrical discharge caused it. Which I doubt it.

Gator: smile

BigInch: Yes, I have read it...

blacksmith37: Yes, this makes sense.


When electric transmission cables are hit by lightning, do they melt? Anyone knows?


RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

I agree that lightning cannot directly create a hole in thick metal. Aluminum aircraft are struck by lightning quite frequently, without significant damage.

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

however aircraft skins are thin
flight instructor

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

That picture is of a composite (non-metallic) nose cone, likely with a radar behind it. The rows of dots are lightning directors, which try to direct lightning to the metal fuselage, and are only used on non-conductive parts.. Composites are very susceptible to explosive damage due to lightning strike. Radomes must be transparent to radar and therefore cannot be metallic. Most composite aircraft have a metal mesh on the outer surface, under the paint, for lighting protection.

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

Either way, not especially comforting to see those.

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

There is perhaps a similar parallel in sorts of composite flex pipes that have made their way via low cost and convenience into even various domestic natural gas service lines and connections (per reports e.g. http://www.cleveland.com/nation/index.ssf/2011/12/... seems just don't drain the current quite as well as the old, thicker or hard-piped metal systems - also not too comforting, as same can be closer to the homes of many than those birds normally at 30-40K feet!)

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

They are also usually a lot farther away from the lightning. Don't use them for grounding connections though.

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

Yes, I believe so because I have seen a failure due to lightning, or at least we could come up with no other explanation. The issue is the coating on the pipeline, which is dielectric, but where you get entry and exit of the current due to coating damage/holidays, the current becomes concentrated, in that it will leave the steel all at one small area, and presumably cause the failure. In our case, and others, the corrosion like indication left is perfectly circular, ours looked almost like a bullet hole. Of course, there was a thunderstorm in the area the night of the failure.

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

I likewise heard several years ago of a "perfectly circular" hole found in a cross-country pipeline many years ago that also had many folks struggling for an "explanation" (i.e. until a drill bit was eventually found broken off in the pipe wall down the line!)

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

I think you need to look at age of the pipeline, quality of the coating, thickness of the pipe and ground type.

When a lighting bolt strikes the ground there is clearly some voltage gradient existing there, hence the reason they tell you not to stand with your legs apart next to tree in a thunderstorm.

I've seen a simple graph saying it could be 3kV/m at some distance (5m) from the strike.

If the strike is directly above a buried line 1m deep, this implies the ground around it is possibly at 10 - 100kV or more for a short duration.

Assuming you have a good quality coating, then it shouldn't affect the pipe - even a thin FBE coating can withstand 10,000V during holiday testing so with PE it's probably a lot more.

However a small existing hole in an otherwise well coated pipe will concentrate that current into a small point before it dissipates in the rest of the pipe. The pipe will conduct electricity much better than the ground so will become the lightning rod in effect for the local ground within 5m or os from direct strike.

I still think you've got to be quite unlucky and I would like to guess that all the failures are in pipes <5mm, though one article did not that they found depressions in thicker pipes from intelligent pig runs.

So groundless - no. Likely, also no. Possible - Yes

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

(OP)
LittleInch,
...if a fraction of the total lightning current is concentrated because of a hole in the coating, and this concentration is able to melt the 5 mm wall, then the 100% of the lightning current that hits electrical cables, cars and air terminals should also melt at least 5mm around the hitting point. Which, as far as I know, does not happen.

The skin effect applies to all metallic objects hit by high frequency current, isn't it?

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

Well that because the area affected in sheet steel is much much bigger - that's the point. As soon as the lightning strikes a car the voltage and current spreads over a much bigger area. The FBE and PE coating are really good insulators - that's what is around your high voltage wires.

It's pretty rare and I would hazard a guess only happens in fairly dry sandy soils where the ground conductivity isn't as good as it is in a lot of other places and hence the voltage gradient is much higher by the time it gets to the pipe.

Still kind of heats up the car a bit though... http://justonemorequestion.net/?p=59

skin effect and high frequency current are different things to lightning strikes I think.

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

I was in a DC-9 on landing approach in a snow storm when we were struck by lightening. It blew through the galley like it is supposed to. Knocked out all aux power on the plane (lights, AC, and so on) and left a hole in the floor plate the size of you fist.

Saw a structural column nearly cut off by lightening once. It struck an adjacent tower, when it got to about 6' above ground the building was close enough to offer a better ground path. It was melted, twisted, and a lot of metal was missing.


= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
P.E. Metallurgy, Plymouth Tube

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

Yes skin effect shouldn't apply.

I have trouble with a melted hole in a buried pipeline. Before I'd expect the pipe to melt, with its superior electrical and thermal conductivity, verse the 'dirt's lousy conductivity', you should probably see melted dirt and glass-like fingers near any pipe insulation holes.

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

May be, but if there was a leak it would get blown out of the way or just lost when they dug it up to get to the pipe.

I agree it seems a bit fantastical, but is feasible IMHO.

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

I know of 2-3 cases attributed to lightning. By memory, the steel surface is quite clean (i.e. free from corrosion), damage found after a lightning storm, damage at or near 12 o'clock of pipe, out in open terrain. Damage not as big as Figure 2.4.3 in Dehn's Lightning Protection Guide (https://www.dehn-international.com/sites/default/f...).

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

austsa; Was that on buried pipe or surface lays?

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Pipeline failure (through hole) due to lightning

Buried pipe.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources