Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
(OP)
A DCS vendor has sent out an instruction that all of the 24VDC power supplies should have their negative terminal connected to ground.
I think they are marked 24V+ & 24V-. This system up/running no issues for a couple years now. What would be the purpose of such an instruction?
I think they are marked 24V+ & 24V-. This system up/running no issues for a couple years now. What would be the purpose of such an instruction?






RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
A more likely explanation could be that there have been problems with interference and someone found out that there are less problems with the DC- grounded. A very common practice in Europe and many other parts of the world.
Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
Half full - Half empty? I don't mind. It's what in it that counts.
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
Generally I would only fuse the ungrounded pole of a grounded system and use a link in the grounded pole.
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
So, who puts a fuse in the ground cable of a battery or power supply? Not me. And I guess no-one else. I don't put it in the ground lead (even if the terminal is marked "-") of a PSU either.
Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
Half full - Half empty? I don't mind. It's what in it that counts.
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
After some years I understand that the +ve terminal being adapted to prevent the electrolytic corrosion of the conductors/terminals connections.
Generally for the telecom power supplies, power supply +ve grounding is customarily adapted.
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
Metal case flash lights have always had the negative battery terminal grounded to the case.
Billions of flash lights can't be wrong.
Joking aside, almost-
Urban legend had it that this was to prevent corrosion.
Actually, historically, the first telegraph systems used a ground return. It was found that the ground electrodes acted as a crude electroplating process. The negative ground electrode tended to lose metal and the positive ground electrode tended to gain metal.
The central station grounded the positive conductor and all the remote stations grounded the negative side.
This gave a complete circuit, negative to positive.
The central station grounding electrodes always stayed in good shape.
The remote, negative, ground electrodes did tend to erode, but very slowly and if performance deteriorated due to a poor ground electrode, the operator could repair or replace the station electrode.
The combined area of all the remote ground electrodes at the telegraph stations down the railroad lines was collectively much greater than the area of the central station electrode so erosion of the negative electrodes was quite slow.
The central station electrode may corrode but it did not erode.
That was a long time ago.
For the last 75 years or so, it hasn't mattered whether the negative or the positive conductor was grounded.
Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
I left one of the former organisations to go to work in one of the latter, and some very odd things were happening to their gas turbine control systems: three machines share one central battery and ground faults on one machine would cause problems on the others. For example, occasionally a fuse in the I/O would blow without apparent cause, and the fault would only occur in very specific set of circumstances during machine startup when certain I/O was energised. Ground faults existed on both positive and negative poles, but only made contact when certain relays were closed.
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
I always ground the negative side of a 24Vdc power supply. I like the predictability of blowing only one fuse on a short-circuit. Also having the one side at ground potential makes trouble-shooting a tad simpler.
Having said that, 125Vdc systems (ie station batteries) are almost always floating. But these systems are always equipped with ground detection for both the positive and negative sides. If properly monitored, the ground can quickly be located and repaired.
Also the telecom industry uses a grounded positive 48Vdc system. I believe this practice dates back over a 100 years ago (and had something to do with corrosion?).
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
What is missing from this conversation is why the vendor would call for grounding a DC system. The answer is most likely because grounding one leg will VASTLY reduce common mode noise in the system. You can talk to just about any process control person that has had a noise problem that after extensive troubleshooting the only solution they could find is to ground a leg. It is common. Before you choose to go against the vendors instructions you might want to get their buy off if you expect to have any kind of warranty support.
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
Half full - Half empty? I don't mind. It's what in it that counts.
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
We generally "earth" the midpoint of a 110V DC
system via the coil of a ground detection
relay. The system tolerates a ground fault
until the alarm from the ground detection
relay is acted on.
Apart from master battery fuses (200A), the
negative side of outgoing circuits is linked
and not fused. There are very few (any?) real
faults which will not be cleared by a fuse in
the positive. On the other hand, a blown negative fuse can result in some truly bizarre
behaviour as loads start interacting via
bits of conductor which ought to be the negative.
Thanks,
Alan
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
Mid point earthing thru the ground detection relay does not make the system grounded. It is still considered to be ungrounded.
So in your case, not providing fuse in the negative side is actually a flaw. In my view, you better provide the fuse.
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
A part of the DC system protected by a large fuse - say an emergency lube oil pump for a turbine, with a fuse of 300A or thereabouts - develops a solid earth fault on the positive (fused) side of the supply. There's no problem as long as it is the first fault and everything works normally. The earth fault alarm comes in but it's nothing to worry about, right?
Now add a second fault, this time on the negative side of a much smaller supply to, say, a protection relay cabinet with a 20A supply. That leg only has a link protecting it on the negative side, not a fuse. What is going to melt to clear the fault - the 300A fuselink, or the panel wiring?
Having seen this exact situation for real, the answer was the panel wiring melted through, disabling the protection for the generator and caused a fair amount of damage to other wiring within the panel. The 300A fuselink was unharmed.
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
All the outgoing circuits have 32A fuses, and all the wiring is large enough
to safely blow a 32A fuse. If an earth fault occurs on one circuit #1, everything
keeps going. If a second earth fault develops on the negative side, the positive
fuse in circuit #1 blows.
Like I said before - it's hard to find a real case which is a problem.
Your 300A circuit example is interesting, do you often have DC supplies that large?
Thanks,
Alan
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
Most turbine-generators have a dedicated battery whose primary purpose is to power a pump sufficiently large to provide lube oil to the bearings for long enough to get the machine safely to a standstill in the event of a total loss of internal power. These pumps are usually a fair size, especially for a relatively low voltage DC machine, so the armature currents are correspondingly large. Batteries are typically 110V, 125V or 220V and from 1000 Ah - 3000 Ah capacity with the larger AH ratings at the lower voltages. It's quite common for other smaller loads such as protection relays, control equipment, excitation field flashing, switchgear local to the machine, and so on to tap off the battery too.
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?
Glad the info was of interest.
RE: Grounding a dc power supply on the negative side...what's the purpose?