Actual strength of a structure to resist wind-loads
Actual strength of a structure to resist wind-loads
(OP)
Say you have a residence that was constructed in 1995, and you want to accurately determine the wind-speed at which the residence would start to sustain structural damage. My thoughts are that you could not reliably do this by calculation using ASCE 7, primarily because of all of the additive strength from components that we don't calculate such as stiffness of partition walls, connections, stucco cladding, etc. IMHO, the only way would be an actual load test on the building, and even then that's a best approximation. Any thoughts on this?






RE: Actual strength of a structure to resist wind-loads
I like to debate structural engineering theory -- a lot. If I challenge you on something, know that I'm doing so because I respect your opinion enough to either change it or adopt it.
RE: Actual strength of a structure to resist wind-loads
www.SlideRuleEra.net
www.VacuumTubeEra.net
RE: Actual strength of a structure to resist wind-loads
RE: Actual strength of a structure to resist wind-loads
I've done quite a few full scale load tests on structures. One method is to instrument the structure to measure deflections and strains and then backfit the data to structural analysis. That way you don't have to fail the structure to get the data.
RE: Actual strength of a structure to resist wind-loads
Were the full scale test been used to evaluate cladding or the Main Wind Force Resisting System (MWFRS)? I have only seen Air Boats on TV. Do the big fans provide enough wind to simulate leeward wall suction and wind loads on the roof. Wind and water spray test on exterior wall mock-ups are not uncommon. I have never heard of in-situ wind tests on a MWFRS.
RE: Actual strength of a structure to resist wind-loads
Are you serious about load testing for wind? I've seen it done for gravity loads.
I was asking the question because I'm reviewing documentation from an individual who is alleging that a structure was damaged because his/her ASCE 7 calculations of a wind event exceed 1990's code design pressures....regardless the calcs used inflated wind-speeds, wrong exposure, and didn't consider directionality.
RE: Actual strength of a structure to resist wind-loads
I have proposed two such wind load tests but neither was done because of cost considerations. Even gravity load tests are expensive. I have done a couple of them in the $100k range. Another issue with full scale wind load tests is isolating the building itself. You need to consider the slip stream effects, but you don't want to risk damaging someone else's adjacent structure. Airboats are readily available in my area!
RE: Actual strength of a structure to resist wind-loads
If the calcs don't work, you are in "safety factor land" as an old professor used to say. For wood, that safety factor may be between 1.5 and 6 depending on loading and how well they followed the drawings.
Forensic74, your situation sounds like something that I would want to avoid. Two engineers butting heads gets expensive quickly and there are never any winners.
When I am working on a problem, I never think about beauty but when I have finished, if the solution is not beautiful, I know it is wrong.
-R. Buckminster Fuller