Threading a solid round bar
Threading a solid round bar
(OP)
I have a project where the client needs to tap their own solid material to form a nut and then thread their own rods to go into these tapped nuts. The material we are using is A304 stainless steel. I am wondering how one would go about making sure these items are capable of resisting the design loads imposed by them? ie, if the thread on the rod will be long enough/strong enough/not eat into the rod to reduce the tensile capacity of the member with the same questions for the tapped material.






RE: Threading a solid round bar
RE: Threading a solid round bar
RE: Threading a solid round bar
RE: Threading a solid round bar
I like to debate structural engineering theory -- a lot. If I challenge you on something, know that I'm doing so because I respect your opinion enough to either change it or adopt it.
RE: Threading a solid round bar
RE: Threading a solid round bar
RE: Threading a solid round bar
I'm thinking that maybe we should just increase the size of the rods by 1/4" across the board and not have to worry about it. Then again, I was a bit nervous about the project so these bracing members are only 40% stressed.... but I wouldn't be too enthused with cutting into my design FOS.
RE: Threading a solid round bar
Have you thought about just buying coupling nuts and threading both ends of the rod?
/EDIT/ I accidentally a word. Fixed verb tense.
RE: Threading a solid round bar
For all the times we say "just hire a structural engineer" on this part of the forum for a complex problem... you really should be talking to a MechE for this one.
RE: Threading a solid round bar
You really should give some more detail, maybe some sketches, to explain what you are trying to do. You say you have a 1" dia., A304 stainless steel bar, which is part of a bracing system, but it is only stressed at about .4Fy. You should have no problem putting an adequate threading on a rod with a load of .4Fy, although SS can sometimes be tough to thread. Also, there can be galling problems with SS threaded parts. Then, the question becomes, what does the rod thread into, is this pl. A304 also, or mild steel? You may have to adjust the thickness of this plate to get enough female thread. Do you need a turnbuckle in the system to make up the final connection? As mentioned above various Machine Design texts and Machinery’s Handbook should show you how to do the analysis. This will not really be covered by one of our normal bldg. codes, the design is a matter of some engineering experience and judgement.
RE: Threading a solid round bar
This project is a 100' tall tower in a coastal area. The owner originally wanted to build it out of mild steel (or carbon steel, I don't know the correct term) and after the bids came in they decided they wanted to switch it to stainless steel. The tower has 4 legs with bracing that runs in-between the legs. The SS fabricator switched every detail we gave them on the drawing in favor of details that were easy for them to construct. They also seem more focused on the aesthetics of the tower with the structural stability playing second fiddle. Some of the questions you asked are the same questions I sent back during their first submittal It has been a fight over the past 1.5 months that I did not anticipate when I put my proposal together.
Attached you will find a partial elevation of the tower. The X rods you can see are the bracing members I am talking about. In the specific elevation shown, the rods are 1/2" diameter. Also, my stresses are not 0.4Fy my unity equation is 0.4..... or I guess you could say 0.4Fy/omega.
RE: Threading a solid round bar
Structural stability never plays second fiddle and no one in their right mind would promote that. Take this as meaning the client has full faith in the structural engineer in making sure the final structure is stable.
How are you going to adjust the length of the threaded rod so that it fits the field conditions? If you have tapered threads on both ends of the rod, then you will have no adjustment = super bad idea. You also need to account for offsetting the rods (can't tell if you have or not). Just cut standard threads into both ends and design for the reduced section - KISS.
The simplest approach, in my mind, will be to provide clevises (with just a hole and no threads) at both ends (offset the holes for geometry) provide a jamb nut on the outside of the clevis and double nut the inside so the rods are tight. If they really want pretty, then they should get those gussets normal to the angle of the rods and line the rods up with the panel points, but alas, I am not an architect.
RE: Threading a solid round bar
RE: Threading a solid round bar
Be careful when mixing carbon steel and stainless steel in outdoor use. Carbon steel members with stainless fasteners is "ok".
The opposite, stainless steel members with carbon steel fasteners is "bad".
See this article in Structure Magazine, March 2016.
www.SlideRuleEra.net
www.VacuumTubeEra.net
RE: Threading a solid round bar
RE: Threading a solid round bar
My other option is to look at similar items (carbon bolts) and mimic what I see in terms of material sizes and thread lengths (and just be conservative) as stated above.
RE: Threading a solid round bar
I think stainless threads on stainless threads is not a good idea, mainly because of galling as others have mentioned.
Regarding analysing the joint you need to check that your external force does not cause the screw threads to strip internally before the bolt physically breaks in tension, this condition shows you have enough thread engagement. If you have a fatigue situation then clearly the bolt needs to be checked for failure in fatigue as well as the joint.
One point about thread engagement, following the formula for thread engagement either on the Roy mech site and/or machinery's handbook will lead you to believe that the shear stress can be reduced indefinitely by increasing thread engagement which is not so, there is no benefit increasing thread engagement beyond a length of 1 to 2 times bolt diameter.
http://www.roymech.co.uk/Useful_Tables/Screws/inde...
“Do not worry about your problems with mathematics, I assure you mine are far greater.” Albert Einstein
RE: Threading a solid round bar
I like to debate structural engineering theory -- a lot. If I challenge you on something, know that I'm doing so because I respect your opinion enough to either change it or adopt it.
RE: Threading a solid round bar
We are not using screws but rather using threaded and tapped members to form bolts and nuts (well not so much as nuts but rather clevises and sleeve/coupling nuts). I remember reading something in regards to bolt engagement of 1xbolt dia for bolting similar materials and 2xbolt diameter for different materials. This is where I came up with my 2xbolt dia requirement for this project.
Just so others are aware, this tower at this moment is 100% stainless. No carbon steel anywhere.
This project is really becoming a problem as you now have me concerned about this galling issue. ugh. I have asked the fabricator what his experience is with the issue. I am guessing that he has no experience with the problem.
RE: Threading a solid round bar
I guess provided the rods are the correct size then 1D thread engagement should be sufficient if the materials are the same or similar strength.
On the sketch you uploaded it looks like the tension is provided by winding the nuts down on springs, is that correct?
My concern in the above case would be the nuts winding off over a period of time unless you pin them in place after tensioning.
Galling issue could be overcome by using a lubricant on the threads during assembly however relative movement of the nut at a later date might gall particularly as the lubricant will have disappeared.
To be fair I'm not familiar with the construction you've presented but I'm just looking from a mechanical point of view.
Could the rods and nuts be made from carbon steel and plated to protect them from corrosion?
“Do not worry about your problems with mathematics, I assure you mine are far greater.” Albert Einstein
RE: Threading a solid round bar
Perhaps you could use stainless steel cable assemblies instead of rods, with stainless turnbuckles used for tensioning. This would avoid or minimize several problems:
1. The cables would not have to be custom manufactured. Threaded rods probably would.
2. Turnbuckles could be sized for the load, without the a limitation of thread size matching the rods.
3. If galling of turnbuckle threads or similar problems arise, they are confined to the turnbuckles or other fasteners which can be easily replaced.
www.SlideRuleEra.net
www.VacuumTubeEra.net
RE: Threading a solid round bar
After reading this stuff, I'm just a little paranoid about it. When the owner asked to switch the project over from carbon steel to stainless steel I though two things:
1) I never thought it would be this deep into details (I though it would be a similar process to carbon steel)
2) I though the fabricator would be more helpful as they specialize in stainless steel. Instead, they are just dumping everything in my lap which is frustrating.
I am probably going to specify similar threading to what is shown in the AISC table 7-18 (according to literature, this should help with binding. I'm also going to specify a lubricant be used during erection. I don't think the system will unthread itself, but maybe a binding nut is warranted to prevent movement of the system once everything is ok.
RE: Threading a solid round bar
I do have a lot of experience with sailboat rigging , both rod and cable. The biggest killer of stainless steel rigging is crevice corrosion. mostly in swaged cable fittings and turnbuckles. Basically anywhere moisture can collect without the presence of oxygen. An arrangement such as you are working on would require inspection at least once per year to look for the telltale brown marks of crevice corrosion, where possible type 316L is preferred over type 304L.
B.E.
You are judged not by what you know, but by what you can do.
RE: Threading a solid round bar
This site give some info on minimising crevice corrosion:-
http://www.bssa.org.uk/topics.php?article=116
“Do not worry about your problems with mathematics, I assure you mine are far greater.” Albert Einstein
RE: Threading a solid round bar
I also, as others do, caution against galling.
I've seen several presentations from Halfen on their rod bracing system. It's pretty elegant. Check it out. It's available in stainless. Halfen Bracing. They have listed capacities and everything you'd need. Plus they look very nice.