×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Slender steel column: Linear FEA vs Moment Magnification

Slender steel column: Linear FEA vs Moment Magnification

Slender steel column: Linear FEA vs Moment Magnification

(OP)
Apologies if this seems like an elementary question, but I haven't been able to confirm the answer searching here or elsewhere. Given: a slender steel column with a downward vertical force P at the top and a sideways force P, also at the top. Assume the material is in the elastic region and deflections are not large.

If statics equations are used to find the moment at the base, then AISC code says apply moment magnification equations to adjust the result to account for the P-Delta effect. Those equations are basically a fudge to make first-order analysis a good approximation of what a second-order analysis would achieve. That's fine, no problem there.

Now assume the column is modeled in a _linear_ FEA program, with the column refined into many segments. The result shows the expected deflection curve. Does this result include the P-Delta effect because the FEA calculation automatically considered the P-Delta moment when it solved for the equilibrium solution that balances nodal deflections and strain? Therefore one would not apply moment magnification equations to this linear FEA result? (I understand the best answer would be to use non-linear FEA. What I'm asking is the linear FEA result "good enough" to be used in lieu of the moment magnification approximation).

RE: Slender steel column: Linear FEA vs Moment Magnification

It all depends on the program. You said that this was a linear FEA program, right? That would imply that it does NOT consider 2nd order effects, because that is an inherently non-linear effect.

That being said, some programs will use a hand-calc type of moment magnfication method. Others will include an option for P-Delta analysis (though this would make them something more than a pure linear FEA program).

RE: Slender steel column: Linear FEA vs Moment Magnification

(OP)
@JoshPlum: It's a linear FEA program. And maybe this gets at the heart of my thinking: that linearity (Hooke's Law) holds for each segment. Now as the column is broken up into an increasing number of segments, the accumulated nodal deflections and strains act as a limit function and approach the desired non-linear result, in this particular case anyway.

RE: Slender steel column: Linear FEA vs Moment Magnification

Nope, it most likely doesn't consider second order effects. The FEA code will probably solve equations of equilibrium, compatibility and boundary conditions and display the displacement from the initial position. That's it, it doesn't iterate many times having as the original state the displaced structure for this new iteration, FEA code that takes into acccount second order effects would continue to do this until the change in stress and displacements between positions at tn and tn+1 are basically negligible [t being time]

RE: Slender steel column: Linear FEA vs Moment Magnification

Ultimately you have to know your program. There are plenty of "benchmark" problems that you can test against to see if the results are the "correct" non-linear results or not. I'm specifically thinking of the ones in the commentary to AISC 360 (2005 or 2010 version).

So, your best bet is to test it out yourself to be sure. From your description, it is not likely. But, the only way to know for sure is to test it out.

RE: Slender steel column: Linear FEA vs Moment Magnification

Run one model with a single element and another with divided elements. If it's linear you will get identical results, if it's performing p-d you won't. If you are already sure it's linear then breaking it up does nothing, analysis would be based on a single iteration of the undeformed configuration.

RE: Slender steel column: Linear FEA vs Moment Magnification

The underlying assumption in the standard stiffness method used in frame analysis programs is that deflections are small, and do not affect the stiffness matrix.

It follows that a linear analysis does not include the effect of deflections on the structure geometry, and moment magnification factors must be included.

If the program can do non-linear analysis it is possible to specify linear elastic material properties, but the analysis still needs to iterate to find the deflected shape, taking account of the deflections.

Doug Jenkins
Interactive Design Services
http://newtonexcelbach.wordpress.com/

RE: Slender steel column: Linear FEA vs Moment Magnification

(OP)
@bookowski wrote: "Run one model with a single element and another with divided elements. If it's linear you will get identical results, if it's performing p-d you won't."

Of course, thank you for the suggestion. Set up a simple model of a 20-foot tall HSS 2.50x0.125 A36 steel tube. 100 lbs of lateral force at the top and 3.1 slugs mass (100 lbs weight) also perched on the top. Results:

Segs	Disp X(in.)	 Disp Z(in.)   Moment @Base(ft-lbs)
1	24.09641	-0.00117	2000
5	24.09641	-0.00117	2000
50	24.09641	-0.00117	2000 

The only thing that changed was the plot of the tube, it went from straight to a nice curve. Okay, I'm convinced, the P-delta effect is not reflected in the results. Thanks to all for your replies.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources