×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

(OP)
Dear Sir,
i want to select the suitable pump to lift the gasoline from the Truck. the truck is located 3 meters under the platform that pump is located on it.
we try with gear type pump (that used in gas stations), but the result is not good becuse of very low flow. we can not used check valve in suction line becuse we have to drain all remaining fuel to truck and start this process with next truck. could you help me to select the suitable pump that can prime in short time?

best Regards,
mirghaffari

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

First you need to establish how much vapour pressure you have available as this will vary with temperature and atmospheric pressure. As zda04 keeps reminding us, atmospheric pressure in mountain and high plains is a lot lower than at sea level and will reduce the amount of "lift" that is physically possible.

3m may be at the limit of "lift" and even if you can get liquid at this height, you might not be able to get a pump which will not vapourise in operation, i.e NPSHA might be too low.

What is the TVP of your product at the temperature you're pumping at? If its coming in on trucks it could be a lot warmer than when it left the filling station.

What elevation is the site?

TBH, it sounds to me like you are vapourising the liquid in the pump.

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

(OP)
thanks alot,
the site elevation is not too high but it seems that the pump can not wotk becuse of low NPSHA. is there any solution to incrise the NPSH in this case? or is there any pump that can work at this sicuation?
wen we fill the sucton line with gasoil, the pump works better than befor but we have to drain the suction line each time.

BR
Mirghaffari

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

Q" is there any solution to incrise the NPSH in this case"

A - Not unless you change something.
The only real things you can change are: temperature of the gasoline (not likely by enough), properties of the gasoline (again not likely to be enough) elevation of the pump - your best option.

Or lower a submersible pump into the tanker?

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

Can you push gasoline with Nitrogen, in a controlled way of course? The additional pressure (above gasoline vapor pressure) inside the truck will generate additional NPSHA.

Other than that, you remain with options proposed by LittleInch - or change the pump type.

Dejan IVANOVIC
Process Engineer, MSChE

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

Emmanueltop - Come on - this is a road tanker. They are not built for any internal pressure.

Type of pump is irrelevant if it's sucking vapour.

I have never come across a gasoline unloading system which has the pump inlet above liquid level, never mind 3m above it

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

I was referring to raising the pressure up to the maximum allowed vapor pressure for transport of gasoline - clearly not to pressurize the tanker up to several hundred kPa's. Apologize to the OP and to others if my post was interpreted that way.

I also understood they have problems because NPSHA < NPSHR, not necessarily that there is vapor at the pump suction. If the case, yes you are definitely correct - changing the pump type will definitely not cure the problem.

In one plant we have used a specially designed Nitrogen utility station for flushing and purging of trucks that were used for loading and transporting of the hydrocarbon product/condensate from the plant.

Dejan IVANOVIC
Process Engineer, MSChE

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

(OP)
Thanks Dears
But it is impossible to use the nitrogen for increasing the pressure. We know that the maximum lifting height is around 10 meters. Why we can not lift the gasoil 3 meters?

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

Maximum lifting height of 10m is theoretically possible with cold water which results in a pressure at the top of the column of water of around 0.05bara. More than that the water will start to boil.

Gasoline, especially warm gasoline, will boil at around 0.6 to 0.7 bara. That only gives you 0.3 bar "lifting".

research "vapour pressure" and NPSH a bit more an then you might start to understand why your system is at the limits of physical probability.

Lower the pump inlet relative to gasoline liquid height.

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

(OP)
Thanks very much littleinch
I underestand that our main problem is vapou pressure
Now i can chech and solve the problem
Thanks again for your help

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

There are centrifugal pumps that are fitted with vacuum assisted suction lift - in some previous discussion on this forum, such a pump is in use in water service - see if a similar pump can be offered for gasoline service to prime the suction line / fill it up on startup.

But, as suggested, with gasoline with an RVP of say 8psi or so, there may be NPSH issues if the gasoline level is 10metres below the pump centreline.

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

There is a system of gasoline vapor/liquid transfer between R.R. tank cars and storage tanks in which vapor is forced into the RR tank cars and liquid is transferred to the storage tanks. Research the web as I am sure there is information that could assist you. Altho. I have not dealt with this type of operation , I am more involved with a similar transfer operation of LPG products.

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

(OP)
Thans alot for your kinkly information and help. Today we test this arrangement again with som modification and i reflect the result here.
Thanks again

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

(OP)
Dear sir
Today we test the mentioned pump(gear type) for lifting the gasoil from 3 meter. The pump lift the gasoil esely and discharge flow was good. But the pump worked only 30 secends! And after that the flow decrease to zero!
Then we stop the power and reverse it for secend. Again we connect the power and start it and every things was ok but only for 30 secends again!
Do you know why pump work only short time?
What happen wen we reverse the direction of pump?
Why in new start pump work good again?
Thanks for your help

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

Lifts (when the pump port is above the liquid level in the tank) should be kept to 6 feet or less when pumping gasoline to prevent vaporizing the gasoline at the pump inlet. Check the system NPSH to make sure it is adequate.

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

No real idea.

Are you letting air in at the same time as pumping out?

Draw a sketch or attach some photos so we can work this out better.

Also do you mean gasoline or gas oil. Big difference.

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

(OP)
Ok and thanks again,
The teat was down with gas oil.
And in this atached schematic you can see the our plant. In fact we want to lift the oil, gas oil or gasoline from the truck for sampling. All part work ok except the pump. As i toold our pump work only 30 secends!
Regards

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

That's a start.

How far down does your sample tube go into the truck?

Why don't you use a simple container dropped in?

How much are you "sampling"?

flow rate?. line size?

Why only 30 seconds? We're too far away to see the operation or all the components so can't really add anything unless you can describe what you're doing in more detail

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

The drawing is about as useful as tit's on a bull. If you want answers how about some decent information, sketches etc. We are very smart people but not mind readers or crystal ball gazers.

It is a capital mistake to theorise before one has data. Insensibly one begins to twist facts to suit theories, instead of theories to suit facts. (Sherlock Holmes - A Scandal in Bohemia.)

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

Artisi - great comment.

mirghaffari - We can provide some useful assistance, but you're giving us information small piece by small piece. We have about 10% of the information any one would need to help you.

I think most of us thought you were trying to offload a road tanker into a facility. It now seems you're trying to obtain small volumes from a road loading facility where you are top loading with loading arms. Big difference.

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

(OP)
Excuse ne my dears,
Our plant and our target is very simple ( as shown in schematic). We want to lift a liquid(oil, gas oil, gasoline,...) from the truck for sampling and its qualificatin.
For this porpose, we have to lift the liquid with PD pumps. The distanse between pump and top of liquid level is around 3 meters. We instal the pump and start it. The pump lift the liquid correctly but after 30 secends the flow decress to zero!
Wen we shout down the pump and start again, the pump work again for 30 secends!
Do you know why?
The flow rate is not important becuse wevneed only one liter for sampling, but we have to circulate the liqid in our piping for around 3 minets to clear the piping from previous remaining oil (that may be remain from previous truck). But unfortunatly our pump works only 30 secends!
I think the vapor traps in pump and do not allow the liquid to flow!
This is my guest! What about you?
If i am right, could you help me how can solve this problem?

Regards

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

Ok. Please draw the entire system. I still don't understand why you just don't drop a sample can in...

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

Could you use an eductor to lift a small flow of this liquid up - No NPSH issues then - you'd have to use some inert gas ( like MP nitrogen ) and install a vapor- liquid separator d/s of the eductor.

In the case of gasoline, you may lose some light ends may migrate into the vapor phase - does that matter in this case ?

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

Another alternative would be to use an air operated DD pump - Wilden or similar - these can handle intermittent dry suction. This would be easier to install too compared to a N2 powered eductor - you could use compressed air for this provided a leak sensor is included. Off the shelf item in most countries.

RE: selection of suitable pump for gasoline lifitng

(OP)
Dear sir,
thanks for your good cooperation and helpful files.
1- Mr.LittleInch : we can not put a sampling cap in to the truck because we want to lift the liquid from different location and also different liquid level. for example water is heavy that gasoline and deposit in bottom of tank. with pump we can lift the gasoline from different points.
2- Mr. bimr : for safety we try to use flexible non metal hose to avoid spark.but we use this helpful file.
3- Mr. georgeverghese : thanks for your proposal. could you please give me more information regarding this air operated DD pump?
4- Mr. georgeverghese : small sampling is not our target. because before sampling we have to circulate the liquid in our sampling pipes to clear the remaining previous ;liquid in our piping. after that we open the sample point to get one liter liquid for laboratory. you are right, we have a lot of vapor in discharge of pump. because we vacuum the air in top of the liquid level for lifting and it cause the liquid be vapor. our main problem is this. i think this vapor can not totally vent from the pump and trap in pump casing and don't allow the liquid to flow (i think and i am not sure). i am seeking for a solution to select the pump that can work with this situation or a way that vapor can vent from the pump easily.

thanks alot


Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources