×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

(OP)
i am designing a PEB shed as shown below , which contain the bay spacing 15.5m and i want to closed the wall upto 2m below from top so my question is that what shape is suitable for the girts design in Cold formed Cee section (maximum Cee section i can use 254-50-1.95).
back to back , double I shape ,Or LGS webbed beam parallel to wind which shape of girt will be better for this type of bay spacing ??
horizontal wind pressure is 1 KN/m^2.
what is horizontal allow able displacement for girts against wind???


https://res.cloudinary.com/engineering-com/image/upload/v1454416499/tips/SNAP_SHOT_ieqngf.bmp

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

Normally, single cee shapes are used for girts.

Is there any reason you think you need I shaped girts?

DaveAtkins

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

15.5m is a long girt. All the warehouses I've been in are hot-rolled C-girts with sag rods.

edit: hot-rolled when spans are approaching that level.

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

15.5m equals about 50 ft. in proper units. That is a looooong way.
I would be looking at tube steel or adding some more bays.

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

Sounds to me like you need a few intermediate columns. That will be a challenging wall girt for typical wind loads.

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

I have designed a few cold formed girts in my day. I don't really have a handle of the metric system loading units, but at 15.5m or 50 feet is way to long for a lt guage cold formed girt. I normally try to keep my bays less than 25' or so, otherwise, we will use structural girts.

As others have said, cold formed girts are usually Cees or Zees. With Zees you can nest them together to form a continuous system however, that can turn into a nightmare quickly depending on how you show your grid lines on your plans (you would need to reference outside face of foundation for perimeter grids).

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

With 50' bays, you'd better of looking at bar joist to handle that span. That would be the standard approach for Nucor or NCI in the states anyway.

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

Bar joists for girts? Never seen that.

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

That would be new to me as well.. I would expect a large amount of sag rods in that situation.

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

Maybe he thinks we are taking about purlins?

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

This could be handled with big cold formed girts, probably 350 Z sections lapped. But if you don't have access to those in your country, you need to cut the bay spacing. 250 C sections are just not deep enough.

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

My apology, I was thinking purlin. Its been a while since I've seen the detail, but for girts I recall a post going floor to roof at mid-bay - load from the top of the column had to make it though the roof diaphragm. Doing so allowed for use of cold formed girts.

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

I have seen that as well, along the outside edge of the building having columns at half the spacing of the interior bays to deal with the lateral loading aspects.

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

I agree with Hokie, was about to suggest if your client wants spaghetti girts, he will need at least a Z300 or Z350 double span girts overlapped at each support

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

ameyerrenke and jayrod12 have a point about the girts. A wind post connected to the eaves strut at the top will allow smaller girt sizes to be used. But if you can only get 250 deep purlins where you are, how are you going to build the roof?

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

(OP)
thanks for your suggestions.
i try this situation in SAP2000 with 325mm deep LGS webbed beam (section used 150-1.55) which will be parallel to the wind direction so horizontal displacement is coming about 130mm does this under the allowable limit however span is 15.5m (50 feet approx)??
to control the vertical sagging of the webbed beam i am providing the HR SHS member as a sag rods (one end of shs member will connect with HR beam and other with Webbed beam) at every 3 m and the sagging will also controlled by the LGS vertical studs as well.
only my confusing part is i assign the support on the top and bottom chord at both end of the webbed beam as you can see the attached picture does this provision correct how i can achieve this connection in practically ???

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

How do you know now what direction the wind will blow?

RE: 15.5 m Cold Formed Girt Design ???

150 is a fair bit of deflection but may well be acceptable for shed construction. It implies a five-ish degree rotation in the 2m studs.

From the the screen capture, it's hard to see just how the girt supports are modelled. You'd want at least one support at each end to be able to move freely in the horizontal plane I'd think as you probably want to simulate simple span behavior.

To racooke's point (I think), you'll need to find a way to brace the girt against lateral torsional buckling for the case where the interior chord is in compression (wall suction). Perhaps another line of sag rods inboard of the eave or a moment connection to the sag members that you've got if they're stiff enough to do the job flexurally.

I like to debate structural engineering theory -- a lot. If I challenge you on something, know that I'm doing so because I respect your opinion enough to either change it or adopt it.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources